Well to coin a cliche, history is written by the winners. The Pauline viewpoint, filtered through the versions of it we see in the forgeries, won the day. So all the non-pauline views were marginalized. But early on it seems clear Paul was merely one voice among many, and in his own day perhaps not even the most important.

Thanks for the replies and observations.
But, Paul is the only source we have for anybody’s Christian beliefs before Mark was written in 70.
And, Paul’s reference to what he was taught upon conversion arguably goes back all the way to the mid-late 30s.
So, shouldn’t Paul’s thoughts have some weight as the “original” religion?
Anyway, this seems to undermine the Bauer Hypothesis that Pauline Orthodoxy was one of many hypotheses competing with Arianism, Marcionism, Ebionites, Gnostics, etc. – as it was much earlier – right?
But, Paul is the only source we have for anybody’s Christian beliefs before Mark was written in 70.
And, Paul’s reference to what he was taught upon conversion arguably goes back all the way to the mid-late 30s.
So, shouldn’t Paul’s thoughts have some weight as the “original” religion?
Well, Paul’s are the writings that survived. We dont have anything from his contemporary competitors. We know they existed because Paul is constantly complaining about them and warning his congregations against them.
We don’t know what Apollos taught but it’s likely it required some level of Torah observance on the part of gentile converts, a view shared by James. The point of view that really set Paul off. It’s easy to forget how easily the early Jesus movement could have remained a Jewish sect.

sberry said
Bart has spoken a lot about this distinction recently – that what we call Orthodoxy was just one of many theories that is the one that survived.
But isn’t Orthodoxy much closer to Paul’s writings than any known Heresy (Marcion, Arian, Ebionite, Gnostic, etc.)?
It’s much closer to Paul’s writings as we have them, but the internal evidence combined with Patristic attestations suggest that include substantial redactions of the “authentic letters of Paul” and the deuteroepigraphical letters of Paul as inherited from the 1st century CE.
So it well may be that the reason that the letters of Paul tend toward Orthodoxy is that the versions we have inherited are the work of the precursors of the orthodox strand, and if some other strand had become the orthodox strand, we would have versions of the letters of Paul that tended toward that strand.
So it well may be that the reason that the letters of Paul tend toward Orthodoxy is that the versions we have inherited are the work of the precursors of the orthodox strand, and if some other strand had become the orthodox strand, we would have versions of the letters of Paul that tended toward that strand.
Yeah that’s the frightening thing about these texts that scholars tend not to dwell on overmuch. We have no idea how often they were modified by later generations to bring them in accord with current thinking. There are some real blank spots in the first couple centuries. If there are surviving variants then we can tell if something was modified or interpolated. But what do you do when all but one of the variants perished? You wonder.

Stephen said
So it well may be that the reason that the letters of Paul tend toward Orthodoxy is that the versions we have inherited are the work of the precursors of the orthodox strand, and if some other strand had become the orthodox strand, we would have versions of the letters of Paul that tended toward that strand.
Yeah that’s the frightening thing about these texts that scholars tend not to dwell on overmuch. We have no idea how often they were modified by later generations to bring them in accord with current thinking. There are some real blank spots in the first couple centuries. If there are surviving variants then we can tell if something was modified or interpolated. But what do you do when all but one of the variants perished? You wonder.
The argument of the Marcion’s Evangelion priority over canonical Luke people, including both D. Litwa and Vinzent’s krewe, is that attestations of what Marcion’s New Testament included and excluded give us an indirect look at a variant that did not survive.
On another line, April DeConick argues that the study of rolling corpus’ where we are able to observe the layers provides us with a reasonable approach for identifying and removing the most likely later additions to the Gospel of Thomas that we have. Obviously there is some entropy in the reconstruction, as, for example, something that was added later that doesn’t fall into one of the “likely to be added later” categories will remain in the residual, but the result is, without being positively selected for being a coherent sayings collection, something that seems to me to hang together.
And of course Alan Garrow, working in a vein that is very much not along the lines of Vinzent’s krewe, in, for example, taking the Acts of the Apostles seriously as history, nevertheless makes an interesting argument regarding the Didache, found in Constantinople in 1880, in a codex found in 1873, but referred to in some of the surviving ancient canon lists is, in the version we have, a collation of two different versions of an evolving document, including two titles, one Catechism section, two Baptism sections, two Eucharist sections, two sections on the treatment of Visitors, and on apocalyptic section on “Last Things”. His thesis is that there were two distinct versions of the same text where the person preserving them found two of the sections sufficiently close that it was not necessary to have duplicates of those sections. While I can’t take it as more than an intriguing thesis without statistical stylometric testing for consistency of the sections he reconstructs as part of the same document and for inconsistency of the sections he places in different documents, it is still intriguing.
But, yes, without a fortituous survival of a hidden codex (perhaps hidden to protect it from an anti-heresy campaign), or coming upon an obscure codex lying in a collection, or being preserved by the determination of proto-Catholics to argue against the dangerous heresies they were though to represent, there is so much simply lost to the decay of papyrus or parchment over time. Bilby argues for internal “signals” in the texts preserved in the canonical gospels for surviving traces of their preceding versions, but without a group of people actively engaged in their publication over time, we are unlikely to ever find a “proto” Mark or “proto” Matthew or “proto” John along the lines of the “proto” Luke reconstructed from the efforts of heresiologists to argue against Marcionite views.

“But what do you do when all but one of the variants perished?”
You simply stop using the hypothetical sources you’ve been bringing to life until now. No proto-gospels, no original letters. Because their existence serves only to justify your claims that the letters derive from authentic correspondence and that the Gospels are accounts of actual events based on historical sources.
And then you don’t have to untie any Gordian knots you’ve created or been convinced exist.
And heresy and orthodoxy are tools of mere rivalry. A call to others to join your side.
Biblical studies is like socialism. It heroically combats problems that don’t exist anywhere else. (Stefan Kisielewski on socialism).

Robert said
Jarek said
Biblical studies is like socialism. It heroically combats problems that don’t exist anywhere else. (Stefan Kisielewski on socialism).What does this mean?
Implementing theoretical concepts and paradigms generates problems that don’t arise when they are abandoned.
The researcher’s goal is to solve the problem, not to seek confirmation of one’s own assumptions.
In politics, the Chinese communists are an example of this. They have not relinquished power, constantly changing their policies without being bound by communist orthodoxy.
It doesn’t matter whether a cat is black or white – it’s supposed to catch mice. (Deng Xiaoping)

Jarek said
“But what do you do when all but one of the variants perished?”
You simply stop using the hypothetical sources you’ve been bringing to life until now. No proto-gospels, no original letters. Because their existence serves only to justify your claims that the letters derive from authentic correspondence and that the Gospels are accounts of actual events based on historical sources.
Using the evidence of variants to suppose that these texts evolved in a way similar to texts in a similar context that we know more about, is not “only to” justify the claims you present.
Indeed, presuming the opposite of the supposition that there were distinctive previous versions to the versions we have from a couple of centuries or more later seems more suited to justify the claims you city.
After all, just presuming that the variant we have is the only variant, in the face of real evidence to the contrary, is precisely the approach used by many who also presume that the letters derive from authentic correspondence and that the Gospels are accounts of actual events based on historical sources.
And then you don’t have to untie any Gordian knots you’ve created or been convinced exist.
A Gordian knot is not a problem of scanty or insufficient evidence. The knot is there. There is all of the evidence required immediately at hand to confirm that it is a very tricky knot to untie.
And heresy and orthodoxy are tools of mere rivalry. A call to others to join your side.
They are, specifically, tools to call others to join the same side: claiming one variant as “right belief” is to claim that the other variants are wrong precisely to the extent that they vary.
But the recognition of variants is simply a recognition that there were multiple sides. Unless followed by identifying one of the variants as the side to choose, it is not an implicit a call to choose sides
Biblical studies is like socialism. It heroically combats problems that don’t exist anywhere else. (Stefan Kisielewski on socialism).
And when you explain it, it seems that the reference is not to socialism in general, but to a particular variety of authoritarian socialism in particular — that variety that includes a faith orthodoxy regarding a future free, egalitarian society here on earth that will inevitably emerge from a group of self-selected elites ordering people around in their productive activity.

BruceRMcF powiedział
Jarek powiedział:
„Ale co zrobisz, gdy wszystkie warianty oprócz jednego wyginą?”
Po prostu przestaniesz korzystać z hipotetycznych źródeł, które do tej pory ożywiałeś. Żadnych protoewangelii, żadnych oryginalnych listów. Ponieważ ich istnienie służy jedynie uzasadnieniu twoich twierdzeń, że listy pochodzą z autentycznej korespondencji, a Ewangelie są relacjami z rzeczywistych wydarzeń opartymi na źródłach historycznych.Posługiwanie się dowodami w postaci wariantów, aby założyć, że te teksty ewoluowały w sposób podobny do tekstów w podobnym kontekście, o których wiemy więcej, nie służy „tylko” uzasadnieniu przedstawionych przez Ciebie twierdzeń.
W istocie, założenie odwrotne niż założenie, że istniały wcześniejsze wersje, różniące się od wersji, które posiadamy, pochodzące z kilku stuleci lub więcej później, wydaje się bardziej odpowiednie do uzasadnienia Twoich twierdzeń.
W końcu, samo założenie, że wariant, który posiadamy, jest jedynym wariantem, w obliczu rzeczywistych dowodów przeciwnych, jest właśnie podejściem stosowanym przez wielu, którzy również zakładają, że listy pochodzą z autentycznej korespondencji, a Ewangelie są relacjami z rzeczywistych wydarzeń, opartymi na źródłach historycznych.I nie musisz już rozwiązywać żadnych węzłów gordyjskich, które sam stworzyłeś lub o których istnieniu jesteś przekonany.
Węzeł gordyjski nie jest problemem skąpych lub niewystarczających dowodów. Węzeł istnieje. Wszystkie dowody są dostępne od ręki, aby potwierdzić, że jest to bardzo trudny do rozwiązania węzeł.
A herezja i ortodoksja to narzędzia czystej rywalizacji. Wezwanie do innych, by stanęli po twojej stronie.
Są one w szczególności narzędziami do wzywania innych do opowiedzenia się po tej samej stronie: twierdzenie, że jeden wariant jest „słusznym przekonaniem”, oznacza twierdzenie, że pozostałe warianty są błędne właśnie w takim stopniu, w jakim się różnią.
Jednak rozpoznanie wariantów to po prostu uznanie, że istniało wiele stron. O ile nie następuje po nim wskazanie jednego z wariantów jako strony do wyboru, nie jest to implicite wezwanie do wyboru stron.Studia biblijne są jak socjalizm. Bohatersko walczą z problemami, których nie ma nigdzie indziej. (Stefan Kisielewski o socjalizmie).
A kiedy to wyjaśnisz, wydaje się, że mowa nie o socjalizmie w ogólności, ale o konkretnej odmianie autorytarnego socjalizmu w szczególności – odmianie, która obejmuje ortodoksyjną wiarę w przyszłe wolne, egalitarne społeczeństwo tutaj na Ziemi, które nieuchronnie wyłoni się z grupy wybranych elit wydających ludziom rozkazy w ich produktywnej działalności.
The hypothesis of “pushing a fictional epistolary novel onto the market” is always a simpler solution than the current consensus regarding the historical Paul, the original letters, their complex editorial changes during their unconfirmed initial circulation, supplementation with spurious texts, and their unknown fate for a period of 40 to 60 years after Paul’s death. Moreover, it requires no original or intermediate versions. Someone commissioned it, someone implemented it. The commissioned teaching entered the market with a fabricated tradition of a great hero. A fictional narrative is difficult to refute if one personally controls the content and its authors.
The evangelical consensus, and the consensus regarding Paul, requires hypothetical sources.
Commissioning content, creating a fictional narrative, and marketing it requires nothing. Ruthless leaders are sufficient for this.

This may be a bit off-topic, so just ignore it if it is.
If someone were writing “the word of God”, wouldn’t they have known it? If so, and they believed they had just written “the word of God”, wouldn’t they have gone to town saving and preserving the original?
We don’t have the originals of any of the books in the New Testament. If anyone believed they had “the word of God” or were recipients of what they believed was the woG. it seems they didn’t go out of their way to save, cherish, and preserve it.
So, does this show or lend evidence to the idea that people, in those times, did not believe these writings to be the “word of God”? (Including the original writers).

Robert said
Jarek said
The hypothesis of “pushing a fictional epistolary novel onto the market” is always a simpler solution than the current consensus regarding the historical Paul, the original letters, their complex editorial changes during their unconfirmed initial circulation, supplementation with spurious texts, and their unknown fate for a period of 40 to 60 years after Paul’s death. Moreover, it requires no original or intermediate versions. Someone commissioned it, someone implemented it. The commissioned teaching entered the market with a fabricated tradition of a great hero. A fictional narrative is difficult to refute if one personally controls the content and its authors.But conspiracy theories are sometimes just too simplistic. Reality and history are complicated. This is why Occam’s razor can be differently applied and evaluated from metaphysical and epistemological perspectives.
The evangelical consensus, and the consensus regarding Paul, requires hypothetical sources.
Not necessarily. We are left with honest unknowns. A conspiracy theory may be merely a simplistic substitute for an honest admission of what we do not know in detail, but that does not make it a better substitute for the unknown or only partially known reality.
Commissioning content, creating a fictional narrative, and marketing it requires nothing. Ruthless leaders are sufficient for this.
Inventing a conspiracy theory may be nothing more than an even simpler fictional narrative. Doesn’t make it true. Just simplistic.
Life is simple. People complicate it. Almost everyone acts like a lawyer – defending their chosen side. In this way, they limit their search area.
You can call my hypothesis whatever you like. Only one thing matters – it’s correctly constructed and the simplest available. And that’s the only point. And it will remain so until the first new discovery that disproves it.
BDEhrman
FreedomBen
evgendob
Robert
