One of my favorite parts of Christmas for most of my life was the tree.  I’m not sure why exactly.  When I was a kid we had those old bubble lights, and I found them fascinating.  I loved sitting in the dark room by myself just looking at them – something like sitting in front of a fire and watching it burn, thinking deep thoughts.  Well, as deep as thoughts can be for a 10-15 year old.  I don’t recall any content, just the deep quiet satisfied feeling of peace.

The first Christmas I was married, in 1977, my wife and I were living in a tiny apartment in Oak Lawn Illinois, where I was a youth pastor at an Evangelical Covenant Church (and a senior at Wheaton College).  There really wasn’t much room for a tree, but we were bound and determined to get one.  It was a very cold winter, with snow, and the nearest Christmas tree lot had trees that were bundled shut and frozen, making impossible to see how good it was.  A Charlie Brown Christmas tree or a real beauty?  No way to know.

We guessed.  Loaded the frozen thing on the car, got it up to the apartment, decided we didn’t want it to thaw out on the carpet (such as the carpet was….) and so untied it (still frozen shut), put it in the tub in the small bathroom, and went out to do some shopping.

When we got back, hours later, it had thawed out and we could have a good look at it.  There was a lot to look at.  It was enormous.  Huh.  Had no idea.   And there was no way we could get it through the bathroom door.  Well, there was a way.  I grabbed it by its trunk, planted my feet, and drug it through the door, knocking off roughly 2000 needles.  But hey, we had a tree.

A woman in my church who had two kids in my youth group had a large house and frequently over the course of the year would have the youth group come over for our social events.  She had a silver (aluminum?) Christmas tree in her basement.  All year long.  Couldn’t be bothered to take it down.  That always struck me as odd, and continues to be against my religion, on two grounds.  Trees are to be real and seasonal.  Isn’t there a law about that somewhere?  (OK, I’ll admit, as I’ve gotten older and the artificial trees have gotten oh so much better, I SO much more sympathize with going that route [though not with silver].  But in July??)

Years later, when I was again single and living, again, in a very small apartment, and poor as a church mouse, I got a tree but couldn’t afford any decorations.  But no problem.  Hey, I had seen

In some ways Christmas trees decorated with lights and ornaments remind me of my life of faith.  At first it was new, bright, sparking, and meaningful; it generated deep thoughts and brought a kind of peace and quiet into my life, a kind of light in the darkness.
But the season ended, the lights came off, the decorations were put in boxes.  Like the tree, my faith dried out and was no long part of my life. the old movies!  I spent hours stringing together cranberries and popcorn.  My sewing skills were never top rate, but I could manage that much, at least.  It was glorious.

Like most everyone else I know, I still celebrate Christmas today, but, alas, there has not been a tree for years.  When my kids had grown and gone (my god, can that be some twenty years now?) Sarah and I started coming to England for the holidays to celebrate with her family – something she had not been able to do for our early years together when I wanted to celebrate with the kids.

 

Before flying over we do have “Christmas” every year in North Carolina with my son and his family – including two of our grandchildren! –usually a very nice brunch, presents, and play time.  My son is as big on trees as I was.  They have two large ones in the house.  And each grandkid has their own small one as well.  It’s a flippin’ forest in there.

Here in England a tree is not really feasible (more logistics!).  But we do see family  hither and yon, a veritable Twelve Days of Christmas.

In some ways Christmas trees decorated with lights and ornaments remind me of my life of faith.  At first it was new, bright, sparking, and meaningful; it generated deep thoughts and brought a kind of peace and quiet into my life, a kind of light in the darkness.

But the season ended, the lights came off, the decorations were put in boxes.  Like the tree, my faith dried out and was no long part of my life.

That may seem very sad to some folk.  But not so much for me – or at least it’s a happy sadness.  I still have warm feelings about Christmases of old, when I was a committed Christian working in churches, doing my best to help people out, learning more and more about the faith.  But like the tree, it wasn’t bound to be a permanent part of my life.

The tree is indeed seasonal.  In a sense, so was my faith (though for only one season). It would be very sad indeed if people were happy and thoughtful only when the tree was standing for the holiday, but not when its time was up.  In some ways the most important thing about the tree – at least in my experience – is that it encapsulates a season of giving to others, a coming of light in the darkness, time of deep thought, celebrating a story of a divine being who showered his love on the world by sending a young child in the world to save it.

I do believe that is a story, not history.  But like the tree, the story is metaphorical and full of meaning.  It is possible to be moved by memories of the story when the tree is taken down, and to live out its meaning when even the faith too is gone.

Over $2 Million Donated to Charity!

We have two goals at Ehrman Blog. One is to increase your knowledge of the New Testament and early Christianity. The other is to raise money for charity! In fact, in 2022, we raised over $360,000 for the charities below.

Become a Member Today!

2025-12-22T10:53:03-05:00December 23rd, 2025|Reflections and Ruminations|

Share Bart’s Post on These Platforms

20 Comments

  1. peripheraldream December 23, 2025 at 10:53 am

    What a poignant post!

  2. GeoffClifton December 23, 2025 at 11:03 am

    So perhaps the woman who kept her Christmas tree up all year in her basement was on to something 🤔

  3. GeoffClifton December 23, 2025 at 1:03 pm

    Dr Ehrman, I did enjoy reading this reflection. I found it deeply moving and insightful. Thank you very much and I wish you and your family a very happy Christmas and New Year.

  4. Judith December 23, 2025 at 1:44 pm

    Beautiful!

  5. kirbinator5000 December 23, 2025 at 5:17 pm

    Do you have a favorite Christmas song?

    • BDEhrman December 26, 2025 at 1:01 pm

      Oddly, Little Drummer Boy!! Go figure.

  6. peripheraldream December 23, 2025 at 8:00 pm

    In your book Misquoting Jesus, on page 150 just before chapter 6, you have a picture of a manuscript which you describe as “one of the most extravagant biblical manuscripts of the tenth century: written on purple vellum with silver ink.”

    Could you share the name of that manuscript? I found some examples online but those are from the 6th century

    • BDEhrman December 30, 2025 at 8:32 am

      Sorry not to reply sooner. I’ve been out of town and didn’t have access to the book to check to see what it was. I’ve looked at it now and I’m — still not sure what it is! It’s definitely a “purple codex” and those are indeed from the 6th century, so…. Maybe I made a mistake? Hey, it’s possible. A scribal corruption of the text! Or possibly … I don’t know. I’m not around my research books still and can’t look it up (the book came out 20 years ago and I haven’t looked at that page since!). So, let’s just say it’s a mistake….

      • peripheraldream December 30, 2025 at 12:38 pm

        I can’t believe I am the first to find it in 20 years! Is that why I have been feeling strangely powerful and scholarly since the last few days? Ha!
        On a serious note though, thanks for taking the time and effort to look into it!

        • BDEhrman January 3, 2026 at 8:25 am

          You may be the only one who actually read the book….

          You’re welcome.

  7. petfield December 24, 2025 at 2:08 am

    I’m enjoying this Christmas with a Bart Ehrman marathon. I’m reading “Heaven and Hell” for the first time and listening every day to old Gold member Q&As! People think I’m strange, but they don’t know what they’re missing out on!

  8. Yeshua hamashiach December 24, 2025 at 10:28 am

    Beautiful thoughts! Enjoyed reading it! Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year to you and your family

  9. johnsotdj December 26, 2025 at 1:34 pm

    Thanks for the memories… I remember as a young boy walking along neighborhood streets in the late 1950s and seeing Christmas trees in the picture windows, some with the bubble lights clearly visible. I still have a set of those lights in a box in the garage.

    By the way, I think this relates – we watched football last night (Christmas) and I was struck, after seeing so many recent games with pushing, unnecessary roughness, and brawls, by what appeared to be mutual respect between the opposing teams, to the extent of players helping up opponents after a play (I watch for that and don’t see it often). Was it the Christmas spirit? I really think it goes beyond a particular theology or creed…

    • BDEhrman December 27, 2025 at 1:36 pm

      Ah, yup, it’s a rarity. Maybe it *was* the Christmas spirit!

  10. Swwiener December 27, 2025 at 8:35 am

    Bart, beautiful memories. Like you, i am not a Christian. As a graduate student I took undergraduate courses in Greek in order to read Plato and Aristotle and others in the original language and this soon led to reading the New Testament in Greek in pursuit of my thesis that Socrates’s paradigmatic “city in speech” Jesus’s “kingdom of God” were equivalent. Of course, that notion couldn’t be more wrong. As I came to regard the very heart of Christianity to be grounded in a big lie, I found myself still in love with Christmas stories, hymns and carols, trees, and all the trappings of the holiday. I still do. I also realized that for many Christians like my parents (Lutherans) the church was more about community and a social center for like minded people. That’s as good a reason for church as misguided belief and I wonder if pastors “protect” their flocks from the scholarship on the New Testament to maintain community perhaps even more than faith. Well, all this because of a shared nostalgia about Xmas trees.

  11. EricBrown December 27, 2025 at 1:52 pm

    No earlier than the day after Thanksgiving, no later than Jan 6 (Epiphany).

    That’s in the Bible!

    • BDEhrman December 30, 2025 at 8:03 am

      Should be! And please, stop with the Christmas music before Halloween!

  12. Sazanka3 January 2, 2026 at 10:13 pm

    This is because what Bart had was made by humans. When it ends, it dies, and is no more. I believed in the same thing Bart believed and it died in the same way. I call it my deconstruction. In this fake faith I was made to believe, there was a tree that God had planted in me. It went through storms of misinformation and doubts and disbelief. The tree was pulled out, and eventually died. In nature a tree that dies would never be wasted there. Next comes the beginning of a new life. A dead fallen tree trunk becomes a place for mushrooms to grow. It will become a part of God’s fertile soil and the soil will become fertile enough to invite small plants. When these die, they fertilize the soil to invite larger size plants. The cycle continues until a big tree comes and grows again. This is what one tree planted by God that died with deconstruction did in my heart. Now I live in this God’s natural cycle thanking Him. I am enjoying my life and my new faith that was given by God, where His presence and grace supersede all human doctrines.

Leave A Comment