15 votes, average: 4.87 out of 515 votes, average: 4.87 out of 515 votes, average: 4.87 out of 515 votes, average: 4.87 out of 515 votes, average: 4.87 out of 5 (15 votes, average: 4.87 out of 5)
You need to be a registered member to rate this post.
Loading...

Did Jesus Go to India? A Modern Gospel Forgery.

Last week I mentioned in passing the little-known fact that the apocryphal idea that Jesus travelled to India as a child to learn from the Brahmins, comes to us not from ancient forgeries but relatively modern ones.   That raised some interest among readers, and I realized that I haven’t actually dealt with this intriguing issue on the blog before.  But I did deal with it in one of my books on forgery, the one written for a general audience, Forged: Writing in the Name of God. 

In that book I devote a final chapter to modern examples of the ancient phenomenon, forgeries of Gospels.   I will spread this discussion out over several blog posts, for your reading pleasure.

Here is how I begin the chapter and then discuss the first example, a particularly influential forgery (even though most people who have been influenced by its views have never actually heard of the book!).

**********************************************************

When I give public talks about the books that did not make it into the New Testament, I am often asked about apocryphal tales that people have heard.  What do we know about the “lost years” of Jesus, that gap of time between when he was twelve and thirty?  Is it true that he went to India to study with the Brahmins?  Was Jesus an Essene?  Don’t we have a death warrant from Pontius Pilate ordering Jesus’ execution?  And so on.

Very few of the apocryphal stories that people hear today come from the ancient forgeries I have been examining in this book.  Instead they come from modern forgeries that claim to represent historical facts that scholars or “the Vatican” have allegedly tried to keep from the public.  The real facts, however, are that these mysterious accounts have uniformly been exposed as fabrications perpetrated by well-meaning or mischievous writers of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries.  Their exposure has done little to stop laypeople from believing them.

 

Modern Forgeries, Lies, and Deceptions

I will discuss four of these writings here, just to give you a taste of the kinds of modern forgeries that have been widely read.  All four, and many others, are discussed  and demolished in two interesting books by bona fide scholars of Christian antiquity, Edgar Goodspeed, a prominent American New Testament scholar of the mid twentieth century, and Per Beskow, a Swedish scholar of early Christianity in the 1970s.[1]

 

The Unknown Life of Jesus Christ

One of the most widely disseminated modern forgeries is called The Unknown Life of Jesus Christ.[2]  From this account we learn that Jesus went to India during his formative teen years, the “lost years” before his public ministry, and there learned the secrets of the East.  The book made a big splash when it appeared in English in 1926; but as it turns out, it had already been exposed as a fraud more than thirty years earlier.  The reading public, it is safe to say, has a short attention span.

The book was first published in France in 1894 as …

To see my discussion of this fascinating account, you will need to belong to the blog.  If you don’t belong yet, why not join?  You’ll get tons for your money.  And it’s not much money: just a couple of bucks a month!  Even better, every buck goes to charity. Who loses?

The book was first published in France in 1894 as La vie inconnue de Jésus Christ, by a Russian war correspondent named Nicolas Notovitch.  Almost immediately it was widely disseminated and translated.  In one year it appeared in eight editions in French, with translations into German, Spanish, and Italian.  There was one edition published in the U.K. and three separate editions in America.

The book consisted of 244 paragraphs arranged in fourteen chapters.  Notovitch starts the book by explaining how he “discovered” it.  In 1887, he was allegedly traveling in India and Kashmir, where he heard from lamas of Tibet stories about a prophet named Issa, the Arabic form (roughly) of the name Jesus.  His further travels took him to the district of Ladak, on the border of India and Tibet, to the famous Tibetan Buddhist monastery of Hemis.  While there he heard further stories, and was told that written records of the life of Issa still survived.

Notovitch left the monastery without learning anything further.  But after a couple of days he had a bad accident, falling off his horse and breaking his leg.  He was carried back to the monastery to recuperate, and while there came to be on friendly terms with the Abbot.  When Notovitch inquired further about the stories of Issa, the Abbot agreed to give him the full account.  He produced two thick volumes, written in Tibetan, and began to read them out to Notovitch, in the presence of a translator who explained what the texts said, while Notovitch took notes.

The Unknown Life of Jesus Christ is the published edition of the careful notes that Notovitch allegedly took.  When Jesus was thirteen, according to the account, he joined a caravan of merchants to go to India to study their sacred laws.  He spent six years with the Brahmins, learning their holy books, the Vedas.  But Jesus was completely disenchanted with the Indian caste system and openly began to condemn it.  This raised the ire of the Brahmins who decided to put him to death.

Jesus fled to join a community of Buddhists, from whom he learned Pali, the language of Theraveda Buddhism, and mastered the Buddhist texts.  He next visited Persia and preached to the Zoroastrians.   Finally, as a twenty-nine year old, armed with all the sacred knowledge of the East, he returned to Palestine and began his public ministry.  The narrative concludes by summarizing his words and deeds, and giving a brief account of his death.   The story of his life was then allegedly taken by Jewish merchants back to India, where those who had known Issa as a young man realized that it was the same person.  They then wrote down the full account.

Although the narrative of The Unknown Life of Jesus Christ may sound like a rather second-rate novel, it was published as a historically factual account and was widely believed as providing the key to the questions that Christians had long asked about the lost years of Jesus.  What was he doing then?  And how had he acquired such extensive and compelling religious knowledge before beginning his public ministry?

It was not long, however, before scholars interested in historical fact began to question the account and to expose it as a complex hoax.  The tale was taken on by no less eminent an authority than Max Müller, the greatest European scholar of Indian culture of the late nineteenth century, who showed that the tale of the “discovery” of the book and the stories it told were filled with insurmountable implausibilities.  If this great book was a favorite at the monastery of Hemis, why is it not found in either of the comprehensive catalogues of Tibetan literature?  How is it that the Jewish merchants who went to India with tales of Jesus happened to meet up with precisely the Brahmins who knew Issa as a young man – out of the millions of people in India?   And how did Issa’s former associates in India realize, exactly, that the crucified man was their former student?

In 1894 an English woman who had read the Unknown Life visited Hemis monastery.  She made inquiries and learned that no Russian had ever been there, no one had been nursed back to health after breaking his leg, and they had no books describing the life of Issa.  The next year a scholar, J. Archibald Douglas, went and interviewed the Abbot himself, who informed him that there had been no European with a broken leg in the monastery during his fifteen years in charge of the community.  Moreover, he had been a lama for forty-two years and was well acquainted with Buddhist literature.  Not only did he never read aloud a book about Issa, to a European or to anyone else, he was certain that no such book as The Unknown Life existed in Tibet.

Further internal implausibilities and inaccuracies of the story are exposed by both Goodspeed, and Beskow.   Today there is not a recognized scholar on the planet who has any doubts about the matter.  The entire story was invented by Notovitch, who earned a good deal of money and a substantial amount of notoriety for his hoax.

 

[1] Edgar J. Goodspeed, Modern Apocrypha (Boston: Beacon Press, 1956); Per Beskow, Strange Tales about Jesus: A Survey of Unfamiliar Gospels  (Philadelphia: Fortress, 1983).

[2] Discussed in Goodspeed, Modern Apocrypha, pp. 3-14; and Beskow, Strange Tales, pp. 57-65.


When Did Jesus Become Sinless?
Wine Flowing in the Kingdom: Guest Post on Papias by Stephen Carlson

26

Comments

  1. Avatar
    saavoss  May 13, 2019

    Is the hoax that Issa was Jesus? Was there an Issa who was “mistakenly” identified as Jesus? Or was there never an Issa in India at all? Did Issa not exist? How contrived is this hoax or forgery?

  2. Avatar
    rivercrowman  May 13, 2019

    Off-topic Bart, It takes continuing study to more fully absorb the contents of your books. I have “Forged: Writing in the Name of God,” where I’m currently focusing on 2 Thessalonians. … Then, I also have in my personal library your even more in-depth book “Forgery and Counterforgery,” in which I have pinpointed the sentence on page 157 that says, in part, “In 1862 Hilgenfeld made the argument still favored by *many* scholars today, that 2 Thessalonians was forged precisely in order to replace its predecessor as Paul’s (only) letter to the Thessalonians.” … Would I be somewhat safe to say that you are numbered among the many? … Thanks again!

    • Bart
      Bart  May 14, 2019

      No, I’m not sure about that. In the longer book I argue against it by pointing out that 2 Thess refers explicitly back to 1 Thess, which doesn’t make sense if it wanted it to be replaced/taken out of existence.

      2
  3. Avatar
    Edward_Dodge  May 13, 2019

    When I was young I came across a compelling book claiming to be lost teachings of Jesus hidden away in the Vatican vaults, The Essene Gospel of Peace. I found it to be full of interesting mystical knowledge, but I learned that it was a fraud in that it was fiction written in the 1930s and not 2000 years old. Judging from the reviews on Amazon, people still believe it to be real.

    https://www.amazon.com/Essene-Gospel-Peace-Book-One/dp/0895640007

  4. Avatar
    AstaKask  May 13, 2019

    But still, there are no contradictions between this tale and the Bible, so it must be true.

    7
  5. JMJ
    JMJ  May 13, 2019

    A dear friend told me she was learning Kundalini Yoga because Jesus Christ went to India to learn it during the lost years to prepare for His ministry. I asked her if that’s the case why did He never mention it? Why did Jesus never mention Plato, Socrates, or Confucius? Great people always seem to mention other great people, especially from the past. This is one of the reasons why at one point in time I wondered if Jesus Christ Himself was really just a myth. These blog posts, along with Bart’s books, are putting together pieces of the puzzle.

    1
  6. Avatar
    Hon Wai  May 13, 2019

    How indeed had Jesus acquired such extensive and compelling religious knowledge before beginning his public ministry from an apparently humble background? Was he a religious and ethical genius, or was he unexceptional?

    • Bart
      Bart  May 14, 2019

      I think it’s hard to know how much he knew, and how he did learn what he knew. We have no indications of the latter in the Gospels. Possibly a combination of unusual attentiveness, commitment, and genius? Hard to say.

      2
    • Avatar
      Kirktrumb59  May 16, 2019

      Same questions re: the William Shakespeare whom we know really existed, he who donated his second best bed, etc. This William Shakespeare: same one who wrote the plays? If so, where did he learn all that stuff (some of which clearly is inaccurate). In Stratford?. The playwright whose life prior to the London gig is almost totally undocumented (“lost years”)?.

  7. Avatar
    Eric  May 13, 2019

    Isn’t the Book of Mormon partly about the previously-unknown visit of the resurrected Christ to the unchurched new world?

  8. Avatar
    Pattylt  May 13, 2019

    Well, at least the Russian picked a time in Jesus’s life where one could fill in details unlike a certain recent apologist that has an entire side trip to Egypt between two consecutive verses of the gospel of Luke! 😂

    6
  9. Avatar
    godspell  May 13, 2019

    I don’t see why not, if Tarzan did. (Underrated movie.)

    1
  10. Avatar
    AntiochusEpimanes  May 14, 2019

    I’ve wondered how far ancient Jews were ‘ scattered’ in the ancient world. Do you know of any good resources that show where ancient Jews lived? For example, in 700 BC, then 500 BC, 300 BC…

    • Bart
      Bart  May 14, 2019

      Not really. You might try John Barclay’s book Jews in the Mediterranean Diaspora.

  11. Avatar
    Naifeh  May 14, 2019

    There is a humorous modern account of these “hidden” years telling some of the same stories called “Lamb: The Gospel According to Biff, Christ’s Childhood Pal.” It was about the misadventures of Christ and Biff during the missing years.I thought the first part of the book was so funny that we selected it for our Dallas book club meeting. Unfortunately, others in the club did not find it as nearly as funny and we were asked to leave the book club. Oh well.

    9
    • Avatar
      jhbaker731  May 14, 2019

      Who do you meet with in Dallas that shares your views? I’m getting slaughtered because of my beliefs.

      • Bart
        Bart  May 15, 2019

        I’d start by asking some of the professors at SMU, e.g., Mark Chancey, a fine scholar of NT/Early Christainity.

  12. Avatar
    RonaldTaska  May 14, 2019

    Fascinating! Humans have a HUGE capacity to make things up and have others believe the made up stories making it quite difficult for us to know what happened yesterday much less what happened 2,000 years ago when reliable historical material was much less available than it is now. Thanks

    3
  13. Avatar
    Stephen  May 14, 2019

    Do you suppose that the historical Jesus would have even been aware that such a place as India even existed?

    thanks

    1
  14. Avatar
    AndrewJenkins  May 14, 2019

    Maybe another interesting question is whether Buddhist thought had any influence on Jesus and any others in 1st Century Palestine. After all, the Buddhist Emperor Asoka erected pillars in Afghanistan and elsewhere, some of which had inscriptions in Aramaic (and Greek), which mention the propagation of moral rules, which Ashoka called “Dharma” in his Edicts, consisting of the abandonment of vanity and respect for the life of the people and of animals. Given the quite high levels of trade between India and the Roman Empire, is there a case for mutual influence here?

    • Bart
      Bart  May 15, 2019

      I don’t know of any trade routes coming into Galilee; and from our surviving sources we don’t know of any Buddhist influence in the area. Too bad!

      2
  15. Avatar
    Brian  May 17, 2019

    Well, if Jesus studied Buddhism in India, he was a very inattentive student. There is no evidence of Buddhist teaching in the Gospels (well, maybe a little if you rad Thomas in a certain way). In Buddhism, there is no God, no soul, no sin, and enlightenment, not salvation, is the goal.

    1
  16. Avatar
    johnsotdj  July 9, 2019

    This reminds me of another modern forgery, The Aquarian Gospel of Jesus the Christ, first published I believe in 1908, but popular in the 1970s for obvious reasons (this is the dawning of.the age of Aquarius). I was a witnessing evangelical Christian at the time, and was encouraged to consider books like this, contra my “one-way to God” hang up! The “unknown years of Jesus” provided fertile ground for stories of travels in the East!

You must be logged in to post a comment.