Sorting by

×

Advice About Money From a Different Universe

It should be dead easy to realize that guidelines for how to live and behave from one time and place may have almost no relevance to those living at other times elsewhere.  For ancient sailors it may have made perfect sense that “Thou shalt not sail after dark” – when there were no such things as, say, navigation lights and radar.  But to enforce it as a rule today? Or take actual legislation, such as requiring execution for witches or for disobedient children in the Hebrew Bible.  Or think of standard mores, such as how partners are to engage with each other in a pederastic relationship, as in ancient Athens. But for some reason, whereas virtually everyone agrees there are problems in these kinds of cases, many don’t see there can be equivalent problems when it comes to following the teachings of Jesus.  Hey, he’s always relevant, right? He certainly can be relevant today for people who want to follow him.  But even they would be well-served to consider the radical differences between his “then [...]

2026-11-07T17:40:48-05:00November 10th, 2026|Historical Jesus|

Outdated Religion and Modern Life

Can Jesus’ teachings on wealth and what to do with it have any relevance for a world that does not share his underlying assumptions/views/beliefs about religion and economics?  That question is not relevant only for the uber-rich in our world (name your names; some of them, of course, claim to be ardent followers of Jesus), or just to those living fairly extravagant lives, or even to those who have more than enough to live comfortably.  Just about everyone I come in contact with even below that level – and probably, though not certainly, everyone you do as well -- has and buys things they actually don’t need or much need. In this post I deal with the religious issues and in the next the economic. It is not difficult to figure out the key difference between Jesus’ religious views and those widely shared among his followers today of relevance to his teachings on wealth, but it’s surprising we don’t read/hear more about it (at least I don’t). As was long known by scholars, [...]

2026-11-05T10:04:18-05:00November 8th, 2026|Historical Jesus|

Changing Times and the Question of Relevance

If you knew for a fact that the world was going to end on March 1, how would that affect your behavior?  It’s worth thinking about. Not only because, well, hey: maybe it will!  But also because that kind of thinking can help us decide how we should behave even if the world takes a lickin’ but keeps on tickin’. When I had my birthday three weeks ago, I did a little thought experiment.  How would I change my life, if at all, if I knew for a fact I had only one more year to live, or five years, or ten years, or twenty?  How would knowing that affect what I do with myself before then, what I prioritize, whom I see and spend time with, and what of the stuff I normally do doesn’t actually matter that much.  For me it was an interesting mental exercise: The answer differed depending on the timeline.  If I had one year I would definitely make some immediate adjustments (and I realized which ones); if five, some [...]

2026-10-29T14:50:06-04:00November 7th, 2026|Historical Jesus|

A Modern Scholar Who Also Argues Jesus Did Not Die on the Cross

In my previous post I mentioned a modern forgery that claimed Jesus never actually died on the cross.  Some of those who read that will probably have immediately thought of a modern scholar who with great sensational flair and vigor argued precisely that: Hugh Schonfield in his once (and in some circles still) popular book The Passover Plot. I discuss that as well, but only briefly, in my book Forged (HarperOne, 2011).  Here is what I say there – with an opening paragraph that sets it up by mentioning several other accounts with very interesting but completely fabricated claims. ****************************** There are lots of modern apocrypha that try to report on what Jesus and those associated with him really did.  There is, for example, a book called The Confession of Pontius Pilate, which tells the story of Pilate going in exile to Vienna where he feels deep remorse for what he did to Jesus and eventually commits suicide.  Among other things, this account refers to a story in which Mary Magdalene presents the [...]

2026-10-26T17:00:44-04:00November 3rd, 2026|Historical Jesus|

Did Mark Make Up the Idea Jesus Was a Carpenter?

If Jesus was not a carpenter – I have my doubts – can we think of a reason Mark may have wanted to say he was (Mark 6:3).? I’ve never seen this discussed before, but I can indeed imagine a reason. Recall the setting.  In the opening chapters of Mark, Jesus has been preaching, healing, casting out demons, doing other miracles, and gathering crowds.  Then in chapter six we come to this: 6 He left that place and came to his hometown, and his disciples followed him. 2 On the Sabbath he began to teach in the synagogue, and many who heard him were astounded. They said, “Where did this man get all this? What is this wisdom that has been given to him? What deeds of power are being done by his hands! 3 Is not this the carpenter, the son of Mary and brother of James and Joses and Judas and Simon, and are not his sisters here with us?” And they took offense at him. 4 Then Jesus said to them, “Prophets are not without honor, [...]

2026-10-22T08:30:05-04:00October 27th, 2026|Canonical Gospels, Historical Jesus|

Casting Doubt on Jesus as the Carpenter…

As a late teenager deeply committed to Christianity and invested in debate – making arguments, evaluating evidence, convincing skeptical judges – I was naturally drawn to Christian “apologetics,” the attempt to demonstrate the truth claims of Christianity based not on faith but on proof.  And so, like others in that boat at the time, and like many still today (often still using the same arguments we did), I had at my ready disposal numerous “proofs” for the existence of God, the fulfillment of prophecy, the divine nature of Christ, his (actual, physical, historical) resurrection from the dead, and the full inspiration of Scripture. One of my favorite go-to guides for persuasive logic was a book by Josh McDowell, Evidence that Demands a Verdict.  Later I became equally interested in his Christologically-focused (but still apologetic), More than a Carpenter. These days I am obviously no longer arguing for the truth claims of Christianity, and even more – as I head further down the slippery slope that leads to perdition (as we used to say) [...]

2026-10-21T20:44:21-04:00October 25th, 2026|Historical Jesus, Public Forum|

What’s Wrong with Being a Carpenter??

In my previous post I tried to show why the evidence that Jesus was a carpenter before beginning his public ministry is thin at best.  It is found only in Mark 6:3 (“isn’t this the carpenter?”), which is changed in Matthew (to “son of the carpenter”) and Luke (to “son of Joseph”).  John doesn’t have the passage and doesn’t say anything about Jesus being a carpenter, nor do any of the other books of the New Testament, nor any other early Christian writing at all, apart from those that are getting it from Mark. This raises three questions that may seem different (since they are) but are actually related: (1)  Why did Matthew and Luke, and then later scribes of Mark, change it?  (2) Is it true historically?  (3) If not, can we think of a reason Mark may have invented it?  I’ll take them in order.  This will take three posts.   Why Did Matthew, Luke, and Later Scribes Change It? With the change, Jesus is no longer said to be a carpenter.  Later [...]

Was Jesus a Carpenter? The Surprisingly Thin Evidence.

Was Jesus a carpenter?  Nearly everyone assumes he was – not just the two billion Christians but also the other billions who have ever thought or heard about it.  And they have done so for 2000 years.  As it turns out, the evidence for it is very thin. I just came to think seriously about this recently.  I’ve been doing a lot of reading and reflecting on what it would be like to grow up and live in a place like Nazareth, a small rural village of maybe fifty small houses that together accommodated maybe 400-500 people altogether.  Archaeologists have uncovered no indications of any wealth there (e.g., nice kitchen ware, mosaics, large residences, etc); no public buildings (synagogue, school, town hall, or whatever), and have concluded that it was – like so many other rural villages – an agricultural community. Everyone would have had their own plots of land large enough to grow what they needed and nearly everyone would have “made a living” by working their plots.  Some people may have [...]

The Irony of Jesus as the King of the Coming Kingdom

Jesus believed there would be levels of reward in the coming Kingdom of God, as I began to show in my previous post.  Could there be any problems, though?  Any unruliness? Any need for discipline and judgment for people who did something illicit or harmful?  Could or would people sin in the Kingdom of God? These are tricky questions that Jesus never addresses directly in the canonical Gospels.  I never even thought about them or realized they could  be problems until, well, something like two weeks ago.  My assumption since I became a sentient human being has always been that the afterlife for the saved would be perfect in every way, that there would be no pain, misery, suffering of any kind, no harm done to anyone, no sin or disobedience.  A realm of perfection. This indeed is what most people think about heaven today.  But as I’ve repeatedly emphasized, Jesus had a different understanding than his modern day followers about the “Kingdom of God.” For him it was not to entail a [...]

2026-10-07T22:20:21-04:00October 18th, 2026|Historical Jesus|

Did Jesus Believe in Equality? You Might Think So….

Did Jesus believe in equality, and if so, what would that mean?   It obviously means different things to different people in different contexts (we don’t equally mean the same thing…). Our (the U.S.) declaration of national independence insisted that “all men are created equal,” but it really did mean “men” (not women) and none of the Founders thought that their incomes and possessions should be equal to those of hoi polloi they saw in the streets. So too, the apostle Paul said that “There is neither New nor Greek, neither slave nor free, nor male and female; you are all one in Christ Jesus” (Galatians 3:28).  But he also told women that the head of a “man” was Christ, the head of a “woman” was her husband, and women were therefore to show due deference by wearing a head covering in public (1 Corinthians 11:3-10). What about Jesus?  Did he believe everyone was “equal,” or more important, that they should be?  Was it part of his ethical teaching that we should strive for social, political, [...]

2026-09-30T17:25:10-04:00October 11th, 2026|Canonical Gospels, Historical Jesus|

Did Judas Iscariot Actually Exist? Or Was He “Made Up”?

Over the years on the blog whenever I have posted something about Judas Iscariot (as in my last post), I've had readers ask me whether he was a real person or, as some folk have it, he was made up by Christian story tellers who wanted to explain how Jesus ended up in the hands of his enemies?  Often it is pointed out that "Judas" sounds like "Jew": did Christian story tellers come up with the "Jew" who "betrayed Jesus" in order to make a theological point? I have a definite view about that. I think he was a real person.  Actually one of Jesus’ disciples.  And the one who betrayed him to the authorities leading to his arrest and crucifixion. Why should I think so?  The following explanation is based on the discussion in my book, The Lost Gospel of Judas Iscariot (Oxford University Press, 2006) -- where I start with the question of historical evidence and what "counts": First, in general: What kinds of sources of information do historians look for, when [...]

2026-09-27T17:32:21-04:00October 3rd, 2026|Canonical Gospels, Historical Jesus|

About the Betrayer Judas Iscariot. What’s an Iscariot?

This past weekend I sponsored the fourth annual "New Insights into the New Testament" conference, with an array of speakers giving talks for non-scholars on a particular topic.  This year the topic was "Apocrypha and Canon" which was dealing with books that did not make it into the New Testament -- other Gospels, Acts, Epistles, and Apocalypses. The most recent significant discovery in this field was the Gospel of Judas, and we certainly had a paper on that.  It made me wonder when I last discussed Judas Iscariot on the blog and I looked -- and it's been years. So I thought I should give it another go, either to refresh years-old memories or to inform others who were not here among us at the time. For starters, if he's called Judas Iscariot -- what's Iscariot mean?  It turns out, the question is much debated.  Here is what I say about it in my book. The Lost Gospel of Judas Iscariot (Oxford University Press, 2006), which includes a long section on the "historical Judas" ****************************** [...]

2026-09-27T17:45:23-04:00October 1st, 2026|Historical Jesus|

Jesus’s Salvation, Self-Identity, and Birth: Key Questions from Readers

Here are three questions I've received recently on Paul's views of Christ, Jesus's view of himself, and the marital status of his mother.   QUESTION: What is your opinion on Paul’s Greek, translated as “Faith in Jesus” vs “faith of Jesus” (the faithfulness of Jesus in God’s plan?) There are a few verses this comes up in, including gospel material. (I don’t know Greek, and I’m not a linguist or scholar, and I have basically no idea what I’m talking about. However, I’m told through literature and scholarship that the Greek seems to be able to go either way.) Do you think it changes the meaning? Having faith [IN] Jesus seems to make it more about us, and less about the free gift of God. Whereas, if salvation is through the faith [OF] Jesus, it is less about us. Although, if I understand him correctly, Paul does say that we can accept or reject this gift. RESPONSE: Yes, that's pretty much the difference (a key verse is Galatians 2:16).  Is a person [...]

2026-09-25T10:20:25-04:00September 27th, 2026|Historical Jesus, Paul and His Letters, Reader’s Questions|

Important Questions About Jesus, Paul, and the Gospels

I continue to receive significant questions from readers on key issues connected with the study of the New Testament.  Here are three of them with my responses:   QUESTION: Wouldn’t you agree that Jesus’ teaching is deeply rooted in Israel’s prophetic tradition, where judgment and restoration regularly unfold in stages rather than as a single, instantaneous event? Historically, these stages often span decades or centuries. If Jesus located his ministry within that prophetic narrative, why think there’s a contradiction between announcing an imminent judgment on Jerusalem and envisioning a kingdom whose growth and worldwide restoration would take time? The Gospels preserve both emphases. Jesus predicts the destruction of Jerusalem within “this generation,” yet he also compares the kingdom to a mustard seed, leaven, and harvest that matures over time. Rather than dismissing one set of traditions as inauthentic because they don’t fit a predetermined model, isn’t it equally plausible they reflect different stages of the same prophetic drama? Don’t you worry that the criterion of automatically assigning “delay” traditions to the post-Easter church risks becoming [...]

Pins, Gates, and Why Jesus Was Not a Capitalist

Let’s suppose Jesus was indeed a carpenter.   Where did he get his wood?  I’m assuming he didn’t pick it up at Lowe’s or Home Depot…. Pondering that question has helped me think in more granular detail about why it makes no sense to talk about Jesus in relation to modern economics.  It’s easy, of course (and completely right), to say in principle that Jesus could not be a capitalist because there was no such thing as capitalism then (or socialism, or marxism, or pick your ism).  But it’s useful to think in a bit more detail about it.  Why couldn’t Jesus be a capitalist? There certainly were people (presumably lots of them) at his time, as always, who were committed to making profits, to adjusting prices based on the market (that is, charging the most they could get), and to competing for customers without governments governing the means of production or setting prices, etc.  But a capitalist economy as we know it requires advanced technology, production, and distribution, unavailable to humans in Jesus’ [...]

2026-09-10T09:42:23-04:00September 15th, 2026|Historical Jesus|

Jesus the Carpenter?

It seems to be virtually impossible for modern people to imagine what it was like for someone to live in radically different contexts – say, Jesus, in rural Galilee 2000 years ago.  It’s very difficult even for scholars who know a bit about his world. Lots of things never occur to us though.  At least to me.  Since I was roughly nine years old I “knew” that Jesus was a carpenter.  It never occurred to me until roughly three months ago to ask what that actually may have entailed.  And I’ve been reading scholarship on Jesus for over fifty years!  My reflections will take two posts.  This one focuses on the key passage, Mark 6:3. Mark 6 indicates that after engaging in his public ministry for a while, Jesus returns to Nazareth and teaches in the synagogue -- which does not have to mean a building; in most places like that it simply meant what the word literally signifies, “a gathering.”  Technically a synagogue was when a group of adult Jewish men came [...]

2026-09-08T18:10:08-04:00September 12th, 2026|Canonical Gospels, Historical Jesus|

How Old Was Jesus When He Was Baptized? And When He Died?

I have been talking about Jesus' life before he was baptized, the so-called "Lost Years."  But how many years was that?  How old was he when he met up with John the Baptist?  And beyond that, how long did his ministry last?  How old was he  when he died? The standard line is that Jesus started his ministry when he was thirty and was executed three years later when he was thirty-three.  But none of the Gospels says all that.  So why is it the common view? It'll take a bit to explain how it's calculated (and a bit more to explain why it's highly uncertain). Only one of the Gospels says about how old he was when Jesus began his ministry.  Luke says that he was “about thirty” years old when he John baptized him (Luke 3:23). This number is not confirmed by any other source and we really don’t know if Luke had special information about this or if he was just guessing. The other three canonical Gospels say nothing explicit at [...]

2026-08-26T17:18:27-04:00September 2nd, 2026|Historical Jesus|

More on Jesus’ Upbringing

I continue here with events from Jesus’ life before he started his public ministry that I think we can treat as historical.  (If you need some background on how I’m claiming this information is historical, see the previous post).   His Parents In all our sources Jesus’ parents are assumed to be Jewish.  They, as we’ve seen, came from Nazareth, a small rural village in Galilee, the northern part of what we today think of as Israel.  They are consistently named Joseph and Mary in our sources (for example, independently, Matt. 1:16-18; Mark 6:3; Luke 2:5, 16; 3:23; John 1:45; even rabbinic sources call his mother “Miriam”). In none of our traditions are there stories about Joseph after Jesus begins his public ministry.  It is usually assumed that he had died by then.  The idea that he was already an old man when he became betrothed to Mary is not found until the second century, when it is sometimes used to explain why they never had sex.  But it has absolutely no basis [...]

2026-08-26T17:16:11-04:00August 30th, 2026|Historical Jesus|

The Early Life of Jesus

I’ve been thinking a lot about the social/cultural/economic/historical context of Jesus lately, and reading a good bit on what we know about Galilee from the time.  I’ll be saying more about all that anon, but I thought this might be a good chance to cover some of the basics on the blog – what do we know about Jesus from the time he was born to the time he was baptized as an adult, which is how he begins his ministry in the Gospels. For stories of his life before that, of course, all we have are Matthew and Luke.  I won’t explain here why I don’t think their accounts of his genealogy and birth can be historical.  I’ve posted on that a good deal before and you can find them on the blog by doing a word search for “virgin,” “Bethlehem,” “census,”  and so on. But both Gospels also have short stories about him as a boy.  Matthew describes the circumstances of his “descent to Egypt” with his family to escape the [...]

2026-08-26T17:15:58-04:00August 29th, 2026|Historical Jesus|

Paying Your Religious Dues: The Studied Indifference of Jesus

I have been arguing that that are many political and social issues that many of us care deeply about that, surprisingly, Jesus apparently did not.  Another passage that illustrates Jesus relative indifference to governmental policies and economic systems is his discussion with Simon Peter about paying the “temple tax,” a story found only Matthew (17:24-27). They have come to the town of Capernaum and some collectors of the “two drachma” temple tax ask Peter if his teacher pays the tax or not. Peter replies that he does, but when he goes back home, Jesus talks to him about it, asking whether kings tax their own children or only other people.  Peter naturally replies that children of the king don’t pay taxes, only others. Jesus agrees:  the ruler’s “children” are exempt from taxes – implication being that God’s children should not have to pay for the running of God’s house any more than a king’s children pay for the running of his palace. Jesus indicates that, even so, they should “not give offense” and [...]

2026-08-09T21:40:51-04:00August 15th, 2026|Historical Jesus|
Go to Top