
Robert said
Still no response to any of my most recent questions, Helen?
No.
I see no questions or question marks made “recently”. Just statements.
We differ in our outlooks and perspectives on the subject.
Btw, what I’ve posted is from Copilot and is Copilot’s “outlook”. I agree with it; it’s what I’ve understood to be the truth for most of my adult life, but it’s still Copilot’s words and perspective.
What you are disagreeing with and have a different perspective from is Copilot, as well as with me.
We disagree; that’s plain to see. Why take it any further?

Robert said
Still no response to any of my most recent questions, Helen?
I’ll go back to your original question. My answer is No.
Are you in the habit of telling people when and if they have to respond to your comments?
Or is this a free forum with free people commenting when and if they choose to?
I don’t like the way you too often talk to me, so I choose not to respond.

I can’t help myself.
>> Are you in the habit of telling people when and if they have to respond to your comments?
>> Or is this a free forum with free people commenting when and if they choose to?
>> I don’t like the way you too often talk to me, so I choose not to respond.
What a beautiful bow on the exchange. Really brings all this full circle.
Anyway, Helen, the thing is that you have been responding, very explicitly and at some length, to Robert. The issue is that while you have been responding to him, you have been ignoring his questions.
There is a difference between, “I have bills to pay (or “errands to run,” as the case may be) so I can’t reply right now,” or “I don’t find engagement with you productive, so I have decided not to engage you,” and “I am going to take time to engage you repeatedly and at length, but in a selective way that just ignores the hard questions you have asked of me.”
The first two are understandable, the later is simply disingenuous.
This is exactly the BS you tried to pull on me, and again, it’s just intellectually dishonest.

I’m not sure you are wrong.
I don’t mean to diagnose anyone in particular in this observation, but my impression is that intellectual dishonestly is often a result of fragility: protecting ego is more important that truth. More plainly: an inability to admit–even to ourselves–that we have erred.
Jonathan Haidt has argued that reason is like a spokesman or lawyer: intuition comes first and reason’s work is to justify our foregone conclusions. This leads us to deceive even ourselves.
I think he goes much too far in diminishing the role of reason, but I also think he captured a very real dynamic we are all susceptible to, allowing reflex and emotion to dictate the foregone conclusions that reason will defend. I certainly know I have found myself defending something I would not have chosen to defend outside a particular dispute where emotions were high, and even occasionally convincing myself of the indefensible.
From time to time, that dynamic expresses itself in a particularity remarkable way.

Helen Young said
Robert – Would you please stop addressing me (or anyone) in this way:
“You really haven’t read your Bible, have you?” – comment 22
“I totally reject your elaborate fantasy” – comment 30
“Geez, Helen, please take it down a notch” – comment 45
“maybe I gave you too much credit for being clever” – comment 47
“First, I’m very glad you did some research and have presumably abandoned at least some of your earlier ideas & conjectures” – comment 47
Huhn.
I mean, Robert, you can definitely address me in that way regarding any of my possibly speculative or underinformed posts if you think it is warranted.

Anyway, the David stories are old enough that nothing really definitive can be said, but where the stories have David working for the Philistines for a while before coming back to take over the single kingdom, in a period when the strongest external evidence is that there was no early single kingdom period, it is possible to compose a story where the Biblical account is a highly plausible retelling of the story written to gloss a man in power.
But when we license ourselves to directly contradict points of the story that are not necessarily walking back a favorable re-write, we are basically licensing ourselves to tell any story whatsoever.
So David is not from a hill tribe precursor to Judah, who went to fight for the Philistines, but was instead a Philistine general who broke away from the Philistine to establish a Hill Kingdom over the precursor to Judah. Sure, we have sparse enough evidence that we can’t really contradict that, but we could equally well make him a Moabite, or an Edomite, or in fact someone from the more developed Northern Kingdom who went to fight for the Philistines and then broke away to set up his own kingdom or chieftanship over a hill tribe south of the Northern Kingdom.
There’s no positive evidence in favor of that re-write of the story, and accepting it because the available evidence does not definitively contradict it opens the door to hundreds of alternative rewrites that contradict each other, but that are each not definitively contradicted by the evidence.
If the David stories retain echoes of the original history, then perhaps we can glean a plausible rough outline of what that original history looked like … but where it does not retain that echo, that is not a positive pointer to an alternative version, it’s just the original signal is lost and there is only noise present with respect to the original history.

Jill_L said
The Origin of the Jews
I don’t know how helpful it may prove to be, but it looks like it could be interesting.
It does indeed look interesting. At present I’m more at the “Misquoting Moses” level of time and money available to devote to the topic (that is, free, and spending time I would otherwise be watching some other talkie Youtube), but if/when I have more of both, that’s looks promising.

Robert said
I’m not sure Joel Baden would say this explicitly, but he delves into many parts of the David story that I have long believed (eg, here) can support the idea that the historical David was originally a Philistine (Palestinian). …
Etymology as an indicator of descent is a shaky ground. One can write a story in which David was not an exile and foreign mercenary that rose to a position of prominence in the Philistine military, but rather a Philistine that rose to prominence in the Philistine military but ran into political hot water there, and so broke away with a loyal core from his unit and took over control of a Hebrew tribe south of the Northern Kingdom, and then use that tribe as the power base from which to take over the Northern Kingdom.
But there doesn’t seem to be any evidence that he was a Philistinian, more that we have so little documentary record apart from Biblical account which are placed in the context of the earlier Exodus from Egypt story and conquest of Canaan narratives that are contradicted by the extant external evidence, and so its possible to view the biblical David story as glossing David and imagine various actual versions which could be converted into the Biblical account by someone focused on burnishing David’s story.
And stlll more, the Philistine period of those coastal plains being followed by being a battleground between rival post-Alexandrian kingdoms, to the Roman conquest of the area, to the Arab conquest, to the Ottoman Empire, to incorporation into the British Empire, the etymological history of the term Palestine in the name referring to the ancient Philistine city-states as a group is very shaky ground for claiming any kind of strong tie between the modern Palestinians and the ancient Philistines.
BDEhrman
FreedomBen
evgendob
Robert
