I will need to take a break from posting to the blog for a few days. I am in London and the next few days will be visiting family; I will be incommunicado until the day after Boxing Day (as they call it here). For those of you who don’t know, my wife Sarah is a Brit, and her family is all here. We have a flat in London (Wimbledon, actually) and we spend 2-3 months out of the year here. This time of year there is a lot of seeing family. It’s not *exactly* the twelve days of Christmas, but sometimes it feels like it – opening presents with one part of the family, then another, then another.
This really is one of my favorite times of the year. When I was a kid, as is true for a lot of kids, Christmas was a big deal for me. I loved all the trappings: Christmas trees, Christmas shopping, Christmas lights, Christmas presents. And as a kid I very much appreciated the religious aspects of it as well. I was raised in the Episcopal church, and far and away my favorite worship service of the year was the Christmas Eve service, where carols would be sung, the story retold, the appropriate scriptures read. And it would end in candlelight, each of us holding a lit candle, softly singing Silent Night. Terrific.
I still love the season and like to listen to Christmas music starting with Thanksgiving, everything from Little Drummer Boy (I’m a complete sentimentalist when I’m not being a hard-nosed scholar and critic!) to the Messiah. But, of course, the religious dimension has disappeared for me. No more prayers, sermons, confession of sins, or Silent Night in the dark. It’s sad in some ways to have seen that part of my life disappear, and I do feel a kind of emptiness as a result. But there’s nothing for it. One can never go home again and one cannot go back to a place (in this case, a metaphorical place) that one has left for good and compelling reasons. But one does sometimes feel a hole in one’s life.
The key, I think, is not simply to wallow in pity and regret at what has been lost, but to find new meaning to fill the void. I do that in lots of ways, as I’m sure many of you do as well. I think more about the meaning of my life, why I’m here, and what I want to do while I am. I read fiction that I find meaningful and gripping. I pursue my loves and passions. I enjoy as deeply as I can my personal relationships, with Sarah, my mom, my kids, my grandkids. I try to deepen and appreciate my friendships. I enjoy the simple pleasures in life – good food, good drink, good music, good film, good books.
And I deepen my commitment to people in need. It is terrifically frustrating, aggravating, and unnerving to realize that Jesus was absolutely right, “The poor you will always have with you.” But just making a little bit of difference in some people’s lives shows me that the struggle to help others is not in vain and pays enormous rewards. It often does not take *much* to help out those in desperate need, and this time of year I resolve even more to do that, as much as I can.
So this Christmas season I’m renewing my commitments to my family, my friends, those in need, and myself, enjoying the good parts of the season – the family, food, drink, presents, trees, lights, memories of holidays past, and family and friends of the past – while feeling a little bit of sorrow, at least, for what has been lost, but a whole lot of appreciation for what has been gained.
I hope you have a terrifically relaxing rewarding and rejuvenating holiday. I will be back on the blog in several days.
AND TO YOU AND YOURS, BART, MERRY CHRISTMAS!
Merry Christmas Bart to You and the family and enjoy being in the UK!
Thanks for sharing these things about yourself and thanks for your blog and your books for the Barnes and Noble crowd which have taught me so much. Merry Christmas. I understand missing “something,” but the association of Biblical literalism with so much that is bad (abuse of women, abuse of gays, political rigidity, opposition to the teaching of evolution) leads me to miss it less and less.
I wish to say thank you for all of the work that you do, the many books you have written which have helped me to understand better this journey we share called life. My faith in the goodness of the human race enriches who I am: the true meaning of life is what we make of it. The joys, the tears, the sadness and the laughter. Looking forward to your next book. Happy holidays
Francis Dunn
Boynton Beach, Florida
Wonderful!
Any public appearances doctor?
It’s a great honour to have you in the United Kingdom professor Ehrman.
Well said!
Any fiction recommendations?
Dickens, George Eliot, Anthony Trollope, Jane Austen, Bronte sisters, and — well, as you can see, I’d recommend the 19th century….
Happy Holidays, Dr. Erhman. Thank you for your thoughts and insights. I have gained a great deal in the little time that I have been a member of your blog. I do appreciate everything you do.
Brilliant post Bart. Hope you and your better half have a fantastic holiday period with friends and family. Looking forward to your posts in the new year.
My Christmas message,
I’ve been watching a documentary video series with dozens of people giving their opinions about all sorts of issues in life. One comment was made by an Anglican priest who said that the most dangerous place to express your opinion about Life and God is in the Church. That struck me as significant. There are as many opinions about Life and God as there are people walking this planet.
I’ve been spending considerable time looking at faith in all forms and in all religions, and those who have no faith or have lost their faith. I’m dealing with this as well. I’ve concluded that nothing is set in concrete and that we don’t really know the whole story. Humans can only try to find some scrap of meaning in life, not absolute truth. John says that “God so loved the world….” My Greek is not very good, but the word for “world” is “kasman.” I take that to mean cosmos…everything, everyone. John also quotes Jesus, “I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the father except through me.” What is “The Way” of Jesus? The way of Jesus is one of Love, Compassion, Forgiveness, and Self-Sacrifice. What you are doing for the poor of the world is The Way, in my opinion, and like it or not, I believe that God is with you and you are doing his work.
Bless you and have a very rewarding and loving Christmas. Todd
Best wishes to you and your family for a great holiday, and a break from the blog.
Pip-Pip and Bah, Humbug! Have a fantastic, well-deserved holiday filled with love, laughter, and the finest of the Queen’s wines. Dickens’ finale sentiment in A Christmas Carol is apropos for you: “He had no further intercourse with Spirits, but lived upon the Total Abstinence Principle, ever afterwards; and it was always said of him, that he knew how to keep Christmas well, if any man alive possessed the knowledge.”
Don’t forget all the appreciation you have gained from people like me too. I am celebrating my first Christmyth. Nothing about it is different from what my family has done in the past, but this year I am free of the internal conflict of trying to make myself believe what I could not rationally accept.
Thank you Dr. Ehrman.
Thank you for your good wishes and the wise words. I hope you enjoy your holidays with your family and hope to read you soon.
“But, of course, the religious dimension has disappeared for me. No more prayers, sermons, confession of sins, or Silent Night in the dark. It’s sad in some ways to have seen that part of my life disappear, and I do feel a kind of emptiness as a result. But there’s nothing for it. One can never go home again and one cannot go back to a place (in this case, a metaphorical place) that one has left for good and compelling reasons. But one does sometimes feel a hole in one’s life.
The key, I think, is not simply to wallow in pity and regret at what has been lost … while feeling a little bit of sorrow, at least, for what has been lost…”
When I was a novice, when my life was full of prayers, sermons, confessions, etc, I remember telling everyone that I had been cured of religion. I was quite happy at this insight and delighted in telling my fellow novices, monks, & superiors, in part because I liked to skandalize the overly pious and self-righteous, but more importantly because it truly was a very liberating and profound spiritual insight.
I suspect most of what you lost deserved to be lost and that should be a source of great joy. What you have found is, it seems to me, much closer to what Jesus probably valued in his own friendships and spirituality.
Merry Christmas, everyone!
Merry Christmas to you and your family.
Do the British celebrate any unusual Christmas traditions that Americans would be unfamiliar with?
Yes indeed! Christmas “crackers,” which are a little hard to explain; they are little packages that, before the big dinner, at the table, you grab onto in the circle, you and the person next to you (you cross arms, with a cracker in each hand), and then all together pull them apart, to the sound of a loud crack; inside are paper party hats and a joke (like a fortune cookie) and a (very) inexpensive toy, a different joke and toy for each cracker. Very traditoinal and strange, as then everyone wears the hats through the formal meal!
I was watching some British TV on PBS a couple of weeks ago and do not know the name of the program. There were 5 or 6 somewhat elderly folks having Christmas dinner and wearing party hats. They were opening packages that contained those glasses with a nose and eyebrows, or buggy eyes, and other gag gifts. It was hilarious!
I assume this is what you are referring to, something like this?
I wondered if this might not go back to the custom of trading places for a day and masquerading. This was when Christmas was celebrated in a carnivale type way, prior to it being outlawed in the 17th century. I like to remember this whenever I hear about the so-called War on Christmas. It was actually Christians who declared that war.
As a Christmas present, I sent my Evangelical Christian friend and published scholar your latest book, “Forgery and Counterforgery” in the hopes he’ll at least peruse it. I hope you and yours really enjoy the holiday break!
There was a passage in “God’s Problem” where you described going to a Christmas Eve service in spite of not being a believer anymore. Have you given up that? Is it really necessary to do so? I’m not a “Prince” fan, but he put on the best concert I’ve ever been to. I still attend midnight service (when I can) and love “Silent Night” with the candles too. I don’t feel like I’m betraying any intellectual constancy or disrespecting my parents’ faith in the act. In any case, Merry Xmas, Sol Invictus, Io Saturnalia and Happy New Year!
Ah, see today’s post!
Here’s to you Bart! Have a lovely end to the year and thanks for sharing your blog!