Sorting by

×

He Said It But He Didn’t Mean It. An Intriguing Interpretation of Jesus’ Teachings

Did early church leaders take Jesus seriously when he said that it was impossible to serve God if one was interested in mammon, or when he praised those who left literally everything (spouses, children, homes, jobs) to follow him, or when he said that it was “easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for a rich person to enter the kingdom of heaven”? Only a very few one-time rich Christians took him at his word and acted accordingly. Most did not. In one of the great interpretive ironies of history, most devout readers of the Gospels admitted Jesus said it but insisted he could not have meant it. This approach to these passages makes sense.  If the affluent members of the church gave all their wealth away, who would support them? And how would funds continue to fill the church coffers to help the poor and, well, pay the pastors? But it is interesting to see how church fathers got around the problem.  In our day we (those of [...]

2026-11-07T15:24:41-05:00November 14th, 2026|Public Forum|

Jesus and the Trolley Problem – Platinum Post by Douglas Wadeson MD

I'm pleased to post this new Platinum Post by Platinum member Douglas Wadeson for all you other Platinums.  This one's a bit of a brain teaser.  Good luck working it out.  And may you never have to in practice! ****************************** In philosophy a standard thought experiment is the ‘Trolley Problem.’ There are variations, but the basic premise starts with a runaway trolley car that is heading down the track towards a group of five people. There is a switch in front of you which will divert the trolley to a sidetrack on which there is only one person. Should you pull the switch, knowing that your action will cause that one person to die, but the five will live? (No, yelling at the five to get off the track isn’t allowed!) Some would argue that allowing five to live is the better choice, so pull the switch. Others would say that pulling the switch makes you an active participant in the death of the one, so that is not morally right. Yet others would counter [...]

2026-11-12T18:04:07-05:00November 13th, 2026|Public Forum|

December 2026 Gold Q&A

Gold and Platinum Members, our final Q&A of 2026 is upon us. Bart will be answering your questions live on Sunday December 6h at 3pm Eastern and we hope you'll join us. As always, during the first half of the Zoom session, Bart will answer your pre-submitted questions. Send yours to [email protected] no later than Thursday December 3rd so we can add it to the queue. During the second half, live attendees will be invited to take the floor and ask your question to Bart live. If you’d like to participate in the live Q&A: Prepare your question in advance Keep your question to roughly 20 seconds or less Be ready to ask it live during the session Meeting Details: Zoom Link: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84158352394?pwd=hmVCUelxOIsRHlo6luDyJMmCV6Is6R.1 Meeting ID: 841 5835 2394 Passcode: 420972 I'll email the replay out to all Gold and Platinum members after the event, usually within a day. We hope to see you there. – Jen

2026-11-12T16:07:54-05:00November 13th, 2026|Public Forum|

Did Jesus Survive His Crucifixion? Depends Which Gospel You Read….

Is it possible Jesus never actually died, but survived the crucifixion -- and that's why his followers could claim they saw him afterward? Because they really did? I've been discussing a couple of the Gospels that have been forged in modern time either as hoaxes, or money-makers, or (usually) both.  Here is one that deals with a question of Jesus faked death -- an issue people occasionally ask me about still today. This discussion is taken from the final chapter of my book Forged (Harper, 2011), slightly edited here. ****************************** Unlike some other modern forged Gospels, a particularly interesting one, called The Crucifixion of Jesus, by an Eye-Witness, deals not with Jesus’ adult life but with its ending and aftermath. The account comes in the form of a letter written, in Latin, seven years after Jesus’ crucifixion, from a leader of the mysterious Jewish sect of the Essenes in Jerusalem to another Essene leader who lived in Alexandria, Egypt.  All elements of the supernatural are completely stripped away from the account’s description of [...]

2026-10-26T17:11:43-04:00November 1st, 2026|Public Forum|

Ghosts in the Bible? Check Out This New Blog by Travis Proctor

How appropriate for today, October 31!! My one-time PhD student Travis Proctor, now teaching at Wittenberg University, and familiar to many of you because of the courses he’s taught for the Biblical Studies Academy, has started a very interesting new blog focusing on ghosts, spirits, hauntings, demons, and so on in the Bible.   You may be interested in it!  If so, check it out here:  The Haunted Bible I’ve asked Travis for a blog post to describe it, along with a sample post --  and here it is, an introduction to The Haunted Bible and an example of what kinds of posts you’ll find on it, this one on the odd and spirit-like portrayal of God in the Garden of Eden.  Here ‘tis.   ******************************   Why does God lie to Adam and Eve? (Introducing The Haunted Bible) Travis Proctor   Introducing The Haunted Bible Did ancient Jews and Christians believe in ghosts? Based on biblical literature, scholars have often assumed the answer to be ‘no.’ We do not find extensive recommendations [...]

2026-10-28T09:10:37-04:00October 31st, 2026|Public Forum|

Did Jesus Go to India and Tibet?

Among the questions I randomly get asked on occasion is if it’s true that Jesus went to India as a child or young man to consult with the Brahmins, or to Nepal to consult with Buddhists.  I suppose the best answer would be: “It depends which Gospel you read.”   If you read the New Testament Gospels – or in fact any writing of the New Testament, early Christianity, or Christianity down to modernity – the answer is, uh, no. So where do these ideas come from?  Modern Gospel forgeries (see my previous post).  Here’s one of the most (in)famous, as I talk about it in my book Forged (HarperCollins 2011). ****************************** One of the most widely disseminated modern Gospel forgeries is called The Unknown Life of Jesus Christ.[1]  From this account we learn that Jesus went to India during his formative teen years, the “lost years” before his public ministry, and there learned the secrets of the East.  The book made a big splash when it appeared in English in 1926; but as [...]

2026-10-25T18:30:40-04:00October 29th, 2026|Public Forum|

Casting Doubt on Jesus as the Carpenter…

As a late teenager deeply committed to Christianity and invested in debate – making arguments, evaluating evidence, convincing skeptical judges – I was naturally drawn to Christian “apologetics,” the attempt to demonstrate the truth claims of Christianity based not on faith but on proof.  And so, like others in that boat at the time, and like many still today (often still using the same arguments we did), I had at my ready disposal numerous “proofs” for the existence of God, the fulfillment of prophecy, the divine nature of Christ, his (actual, physical, historical) resurrection from the dead, and the full inspiration of Scripture. One of my favorite go-to guides for persuasive logic was a book by Josh McDowell, Evidence that Demands a Verdict.  Later I became equally interested in his Christologically-focused (but still apologetic), More than a Carpenter. These days I am obviously no longer arguing for the truth claims of Christianity, and even more – as I head further down the slippery slope that leads to perdition (as we used to say) [...]

2026-10-21T20:44:21-04:00October 25th, 2026|Historical Jesus, Public Forum|

Next Platinum Lecture on November 14th

Platinum members, as you know, one of the benefits of your subscription is a quarterly lecture by Bart followed by a Q&A. These lectures provide an opportunity to dig deeper into a particular topic and offer an opportunity to ask your questions to Bart directly. mark your calendars for our next Platinum lecture, which is scheduled to take place on Saturday November 14th at 2pm Eastern. The topic for this quarter's lecture is: The World Jesus Was Born Into: What Do We Know about Nazareth? Can't make it live? I'll send the recording out to all Platinum members shortly after the event. Here's the info you need to join live us on November 14th. When: Saturday November 14th at 2pm Eastern Zoom Link: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/87488828498?pwd=qpZuae7Da52zGVR6BuVU2o17AnU9NZ.1 Meeting ID: 874 8882 8498 Passcode: 063466   We hope to see you there!

2026-11-05T15:13:23-05:00October 23rd, 2026|Public Forum|

A Head-Scratcher in the Sermon on the Mount: Who Gets Into the Kingdom?

There is a passage in the Sermon on the Mount that is crucial for understanding Matthew’s portrayal of Jesus, as I’ve taught for years, without, though, being able to get my mind around it completely.  It doesn’t seem consistent with itself.  Here’s Matthew 5:17-20 in the New Revised Standard Version (Updated Edition): 17 “Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have come not to abolish but to fulfill. 18 For truly I tell you, until heaven and earth pass away, not one letter, not one stroke of a letter, will pass from the law until all is accomplished. 19 Therefore, whoever breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do the same will be called least in the kingdom of heaven, but whoever does them and teaches them will be called great in the kingdom of heaven. 20 For I tell you, unless your righteousness exceeds that of the scribes and Pharisees, you will never enter the kingdom of heaven. The problem I’ve had with understanding the [...]

2026-10-06T16:45:34-04:00October 17th, 2026|Public Forum|

November 2026 Gold Q&A

Gold and Platinum Members, our November Q&A is coming up. Join Bart live on Saturday November 7th at 3pm Eastern as he answers your questions. Bart will spend the first half of our Zoom session answering your pre-submitted questions. Send yours to [email protected] no later than Thursday November 5th so we can add it to the queue. Then we’ll open things up. During the second half, you’re invited to come on the microphone and ask Bart a question live. If you’d like to participate in the live Q&A: Prepare your question in advance Keep your question to roughly 20 seconds or less Be ready to ask it live during the session Meeting Details: Zoom Link: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/82830700496?pwd=X00BfdDVOTY6Vh36zDPQacEDXDArji.1 Meeting ID: 828 3070 0496 Passcode:875235 And if you’re unable to make it live, I always send the recording of the event to all Gold and Platinum members shortly after the event. We hope to see you there. – Jen

2026-10-16T00:10:55-04:00October 16th, 2026|Public Forum|

Great News For the Blog! A Significant Milestone

I’ve got some exciting news about how we’re doing on the blog this year – with respect to funds raised, and in connection with a series of posts I did last year.  The funds, as you’ll see below, are significant.  To this point, in terms of the  monies we’ve given to our charities, this is our best year yet of the fourteen we’ve had running this show. First let me explain a long-term project that ended up making a big difference. As (lots of you) know/remember, I did that “New Testament in a Nutshell” series in 2025, producing usually 3 or 4 posts on each book of the NT in canonical sequence, from Matthew to Revelation.  You can still see them all, easily enough.  Just do a word search for “nutshell” and you’ll see them. The first post gave a 50-word (exactly!) summary of the book, and then a longer exposition of its major themes and emphases.  A second post discussed Who wrote it, When, and Why.  A third post discussed one of the more [...]

2026-10-07T22:33:38-04:00October 13th, 2026|Public Forum|

Where Christianity Started, And Why – Platinum Guest Post by Peter van Kan

I am pleased to publish this Platinum post by Peter van Kan, in which he explores why Jesus would come to think he was the messiah, and makes the case that he is best understood as a Jewish mystic, largely misunderstood by the writers of the Gospels.  Interesting thesis!   What do you think?  Feel free to comment and give your opinion. ******************************   In this article I aim to narrow down where in history the junction ‘christianity or no christianity’ lay. Having found the place, the obvious next question is: why did history take the christianity direction?   Not Before going into the issues, let me clarify that I take a lot for granted here. ‘Granted’ meaning: concluded by biblical scholars, genealogist, archeologists, etymologists and other gists. There was no Abraham and there was no Moses. And if there had been people by such names, they did not remotely resemble their namesakes pictured in the OT. God did not have a special bond with Hebrews or Jews. Or any other people for that matter. [...]

2026-10-08T09:08:23-04:00October 9th, 2026|Public Forum|

A Blog Dinner in Denver, CO on November 19. Interested?

Happy news!  Jen Olmos and I will both be in Denver this November for the annual meeting of the Society of Biblical Literature, and we'd love to get together with some fellow blog members while we're there. So, we're thinkin' Blog Dinner on Thursday, November 19?  Wanna come? For those who haven't attended one of these before, the idea is simple: a small group of us gets together for a good meal, good conversation, and a chance to meet one another in person. We can talk about the Bible, early Christianity, the blog, or whatever else comes to mind. No agenda, no lectures, and certainly no final exams to end it all. The only requirements are: You're a member of the blog You get there You pay for whatever you choose to consume You're willing to talk or at least listen (either or both is acceptable) (and zero is expertise required) If you'd like to join us, please send an email to at [email protected] (do not make reply with a comment here on the blog). We'll [...]

2026-09-22T14:54:07-04:00September 25th, 2026|Public Forum|

October 2026 Gold Q&A Announcement

NOTE: This Q&A was originally scheduled for Monday October 12th. It has been rescheduled to Monday October 19th at 7pm Eastern. Gold and Platinum members, we've set the date and time for our next monthly Gold Q&A. It's happening on Monday October 12th at 7pm Eastern. As usual, Bart will take the first 30 minutes to answer presubmitted questions. You are invited to submit your questions ahead of time to [email protected]. For the second half of the call, you're invited to raise your hand and ask your question live. We've had some especially great questions these last few months, so come up with your best! October Q&A Info: When: Monday October 19th, 2026 at 7pm Eastern Zoom Link: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/81400681523?pwd=hO5f5EPxAD9fkLE2NmfOqsHfqB8nOR.1 Meeting ID: 814 0068 1523 Passcode: 766157 Don't worry if you're unable to make it live. I'll send the recording out the following day. Hope to see you there!

2026-10-12T15:21:34-04:00September 11th, 2026|Public Forum|

My Interview with James Carville

About a week ago, out of the blue, I was contacted by the producer of James Carville's podcast/youtube channel to do an interview.  Most of you know him well -- he's one of the top political strategists of our time and an incredibly personable, affable, and funny guy.  Unlike me on the blog, he is all ABOUT taking political sides.  And I had no idea why he wanted to interview me or what we were going to talk about.  Even his producer (when I asked him) didn't really know!  OK then. So I went on, and had the time of my life.  It's was a terrifically fun interview, and no politics!  Just a lot of key questions about everything from Jesus and the Gospels to the Council of Nicea and fun conversation.   They've allowed us to put it on the blog, so here it is!   https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GGmLqJfnw6E

2026-09-01T09:12:25-04:00September 1st, 2026|Public Forum|

Platinum Lecture on October 1

Platinum members, we've got our next quarterly lecture on the calendar. It's an opportunity for Bart and just Platinum blog members get together on Zoom. Our topic for this quarter is: Matthew and the Rise of Anti-Judaism As always, there will be time at the end for questions…be prepared! Can't make it live? Don't worry. We’ll record the lecture and send it out for all Platinum members to watch after the event. Event Info: When: Thursday October 1 at 7pm Eastern Zoom Link: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/88260423137?pwd=aSwenEJvbTcsaOou6Alyqt8lINpIx8.1 Meeting ID: 882 6042 3137 Passcode: 425313

2026-09-01T09:15:38-04:00August 28th, 2026|Public Forum|

How the World Was Created in 4004 BCE

Now that I've started talking about the Hebrew Bible on the blog, I think maybe I'll keep talking about it for a bit.  Let's start at the beginning.  As in "In the Beginning..." Lots of people know that (some) fundamentalist Christians insist the beginning was when the world was created "6000 years ago."  But most of those people don't know where the idea came from.  (It's not stated, of course, in the Bible itself.  If you find dates in the margins of your Bible, it's because modern English editors have put them there.) The "6000" years is only approximately the fundamentalist view.  Well before there was fundamentalism (you can trace it to the 19th century) a standard belief among Christians (from the 17th century), before the rise of yet more modern geological science, was that the world was created in 4004 BCE.  So if we think of fundamentalists as literalists, let's be literal: it was created 6030 years ago. But whence did it come?  I talk about it briefly in one of my textbook [...]

2026-08-17T16:28:39-04:00August 26th, 2026|Public Forum|

September 2026 Gold Q&A

Gold and Platinum Members, our September Q&A is coming up. Join Bart live on Tuesday September 8th at 7pm Eastern as he answers your questions. Bart will spend the first half of our Zoom session answering your pre-submitted questions. Send yours to [email protected] no later than Monday September 6th so we can add it to the queue. Then we’ll open things up. During the second half, you’re invited to come on the microphone and ask Bart a question live. There’s no theme this month, so anything goes: the New Testament, the historical Jesus, early Christianity, Bart’s books and research, or that burning question you’ve been meaning to ask him for ages. If you’d like to participate in the live Q&A: Prepare your question in advance Keep your question to roughly 20 seconds or less Be ready to ask it live during the session Meeting Details: Zoom Link: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/89058506667?pwd=nId19nGbXjmM2YHR4BWCzPaQPbraYg.1 Meeting ID: 890 5850 6667 Passcode: 948441 And if you’re unable to make it live, I always send the recording of the event to all Gold and Platinum [...]

2026-08-24T14:58:39-04:00August 21st, 2026|Public Forum|

Blog Dinner in NYC, September 1. Interested?

I will be in NYC on Tuesday, Sept. 1, for an extremely important academic engagement (aka, the U.S. Open....).  I'll be hosting a blog dinner for any blog members who would be interested.   Yup up for it? I’ll probably start around 6:00 pm for drinks with whomever wants both to quench thirst and cha, and then head over to dinner (with both quenchers and non-quenchers) at 7:00 or so.  Location TBD -- but somewhere relatively interesting and easy to get to. My plan (subject to  whimsical change) is to limit the table to 10.   For those who come there are no obligations other than: Being a blog member Showing up Talking Paying for whatever you ingest.  (Whatever you exgest is free.) If you’d like to join me and a group of other blog members for an evening of interesting discussion of areas of mutual interest, simply send along an email at [email protected].  (NB: Please do NOT reply here as a comment). Hope you can come!  

2026-08-10T13:42:46-04:00August 10th, 2026|Public Forum|

Render Unto Caesar: Jesus’s Indifference to Human Governments and Economies

In this thread have been arguing that Jesus was decidedly a revolutionary:  he despised the current system (government) (both Roman and Jewish) and hoped for/anticipated its complete overthrow.  But he was not in support of rebellion.  That seems a bit odd, since most revolutionaries are precisely trying to incite either a violent or peaceful coup for a new system to be put in place. Jesus was different precisely because of his apocalyptic views:  governments were necessarily human institutions, the humans in power were part of a cosmic-wide network of evil and corruption, and the powers ultimately in control (above their human minions) could not be dismantled by human effort.  Only an intervention of God would resolve the world’s plight, and he would do so not through human initiative but in an act of divine judgment, to be brought by a cosmic figure, the Son of Man. What mattered for Jesus was not one government or another; one governmental policy or that, this corrupt official or that, a particular systemic problem or another – [...]

2026-08-02T16:25:32-04:00August 6th, 2026|Public Forum|
Go to Top