PLEASE NOTE: I am incommunicado for a few days on a gulet in the Aegean Sea on the west coast of Turkey. I have asked Steven, our blog support, to add some posts for me in my absence; I prepared these in advance knowing I would be out of reach. Here is one of them. I’m afraid I will not be able to respond to comments on the next few posts until I return to some form of civilization that supports Internet and all things electronic. So sorry!
****************************************************
In my previous post on the discovery of biblical manuscripts, I mentioned the most intrepid of manuscript-hunters of modern times, Tischendorf. His story is very interesting. Here is what I say about him and his most famous discovery in my book Misquoting Jesus.
The one nineteenth-century scholar who was most assiduous in discovering biblical manuscripts and publishing their texts had the interesting name Lobegott Friedrich Constantin von Tischendorf (1815-74). He was called “Lobegott” (German for “Praise God”) because before he was born, his mother had seen a blind man, and had the superstitious belief that this would cause her child to be born blind. When he was born completely healthy, she dedicated him to God by giving him this unusual first name.
Tischendorf was an inordinately ardent scholar, who saw his work on the text of the New Testament as a sacred, divinely ordained task. As he once wrote his fiancée, while still in his early twenties: “I am confronted with a sacred task, the struggle to regain the original form of the New Testament.” This sacred task he sought to fulfill by locating every manuscript tucked away in every library and monastery that he could find. He made several trips throughout Europe and into the “East” (meaning what we would call the Middle East), finding, transcribing, and publishing manuscripts wherever he went.
One of his earliest and best known successes involved a manuscript that was already known, but that no one had been able to read. This is the famous codex Ephraemi Rescriptus, a manuscript at the Bibliothèque Nationale in Paris. This was originally a fifth-century Greek manuscript of the New Testament that had been erased in the twelfth century so that its vellum pages could be used to record some sermons by the Syriac church father Ephraim. Since the pages had not been erased thoroughly, some of the underwriting could still be seen. But it could not be seen clearly enough to decipher most of its words – even though several fine scholars had done their best. By Tischendorf’s time, however, chemical reagents had been discovered which could help bring out the underwriting. Applying these reagents carefully, and plodding his way slowly through the text, Tischendorf could make out its words, and so produced the first successful transcription of this early text, gaining himself something of a reputation among those who cared about such things.
Some wealthy patrons were induced to provide financial support for Tischendorf’s journeys to other lands in Europe and the Middle East to locate manuscripts. By all counts, his most famous discovery involves one of the truly great manuscripts of the Bible still available, the codex Sinaiticus. The tale of its discovery is the stuff of legend, though we have the account direct from Tischendorf’s own hand.
THE REST OF THIS POST IS FOR MEMBERS ONLY. If you don’t belong yet, JOIN!!! It costs very little money, and all of it goes to charity!
There was a show on the Smithsonian Channel called ‘Bible Hunters’ that featured Tischendorf and his discovery of Codex Sinaiticus. Fascinating stuff!!
What a great post! What a good way to start my day.
All this is fascinating to read – and yet, doesn’t prompt this reader to ask any questions. A perfect choice for material to be posted while Bart is away!
Bart: excellent description; really did a wonderful job. Others have described him an about the Codec Sinaiticus, especially Throckmorton in the Gospel Parallels. However, your’ s truly has to be the best I have see. I hope others will take the time to see that the Codex is ons of the most fascinating true stories of modern times.
The story about the discovery of the Codex Discovery, by Tischendorf himself… http://rosetta.reltech.org/TC/extras/tischendorf-sinaiticus.html
It seems odd when any scholar today (and there are many) writes about Tischendorf’s 1844 story as if it were an historical and factual account.
The recent article by Nicholas Fyssas in the 2015 “Codex Sinaiticus: New Perspectives on the Ancient Biblical Manuscript” book said:
“These observations may also urge us to take with some reservation Tischendorf’s claim that be was allowed to take the forty-three folios.”
However, the situation historically is far worse than simply “some reservation”.
Even back in 1874, the top Scottish scholar James Donaldson wrote:
“There are many circumstances in this narrative calculated to awaken suspicion”
When Tischendorf wrote his family correspondence, (we have extracts recently published) he simply wrote of the 43 leaves as coming into his possession, which should be seen as thief-code for “I heisted the leaves when nobody was looking”. This matches the Porfiry Uspensky account of the state of the ms. in 1845.
We might also note that the “phenomenally good condition” of the leaves, as described even today by Helen Shenton of the British Library, made it possible to transport the leaves surreptitiously without difficulty or special handling. We might wonder whether such “exceptional” condition (Gavin Moorhead of the British Library) is consistent with the history of the manuscript that has become today’s Sinaiticus science.
Some of the information describing this 1844 history, with the url to the family correspondence, is at:
1844 saved from burning myth – “ich bin in den Besitzgelangt von”
http://www.purebibleforum.com/showthread.php?t=85
Steven Avery
Dutchess County, NY
[CORRECTION ]The story about the discovery of the Codex Sinaiticus, by Tischendorf himself… http://rosetta.reltech.org/TC/extras/tischendorf-sinaiticus.html
With regard to the very interesting life and work of Tischendorf (I did not know the derivation of his name), readers of this blog might have an interest in watching the really good tv documentary about him. It periodically gets reshown on the Smithsonian Channel and I have watched it a couple of times. It is Episode One of the “Bible Hunters” series and is entitled “Search for Truth.” It’s going to be shown again at noon on Monday, July 6 and at 8;00 in the morning on Sunday July 12. The website of the “Smithsonian Channel” will list the times of the next showings.
There used to be a book titled, if I remember aright, “Testaments of Time,” that was a terrific popular history of how we came to recover many of the lost works of antiquity.
The new video:
Sinaiticus Coincidences?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7_4WdDG-smU
Gives some Sinaiticus backdrop. 17 minutes, fun, will help get you thinking.
David W. Daniels is with Chick Publications. Sometimes that gets a harumph in Bible textual scholarship circles. From my studies, every point made by David in that video is accurate. The vid is trying to help lay out the issues, so individually we are able to come to a sound conclusion. If you see any errors, please share. Thanks!
Steven Avery
Asheville,NC