Sorting by

×

The Execution of Pontius Pilate for Killing Jesus (!)

In my previous post I explained and provided a translation of the intriguing apocryphal letter that Pontius Pilate (allegedly) wrote to the Emperor Tiberius to explain why he had crucified the Son of God.  Later, another Christian author wrote a fictional account of what happened next.  Tiberius did not take kindly to Pilate's horrible crime and ... well, it ends up not going well for the governor of Judea.  But on the upside ... he converts! Here is my introduction to the text and a fresh translation of it from the Greek, as found in the collection of apocryphal Gospels I did with my colleague Zlatko Plese, The Other Gospels (Oxford University Press). ****************************** Introduction The Handing Over of Pilate (Paradosis Pilati)   The “Handing Over of Pilate” is a fictitious account of Pilate being recalled to Rome and censured by the Emperor Tiberius for his role in having the divine man, Jesus, crucified.  Pilate pays the ultimate price for his heinous behavior by being beheaded--but only after he has repented of his [...]

2026-06-20T20:48:35-04:00June 27th, 2026|Christian Apocrypha, Public Forum|

July 2026 Gold Q&A Announcement

Gold and Platinum Members, your next monthly Q&A is on the calendar. Bart will be answering your questions live on Saturday July 11th at 12pm Eastern. For July, we are continuing with the split format. Bart will spend the first half of our Zoom session answering your pre-submitted questions. Please email your questions to [email protected] no later than Thursday July 9th. For the second half of the hour, we’ll be opening things up to live attendee participation, giving you the opportunity to ask Bart questions in real time on a specific topic. For July, Bart has chosen: The Acts of the Apostles If you’d like to participate in the live Q&A: Prepare your question in advance Make sure your question is specifically focused on the Gospels Keep your question to roughly 20 seconds or less Be ready to ask it live during the session Meeting Details: Zoom Link: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/81209150304?pwd=9Y5Dett5sOHbvefD9Oc7xcSzjbfibo.1 Meeting ID: 812 0915 0304 Passcode: 372721 And if you're unable to make it live, I always send the recording of the event to all Gold and [...]

2026-06-26T10:59:24-04:00June 26th, 2026|Public Forum|

A Blog Dinner In Central London July 15. Wanna Come?

I’m in London for a bit just now, as is my summer wont, currently enjoying the heatwave (96 degrees without air conditioning!), as all you other London and thereabouts residents are!  But this too shall pass.  And so.... I would love to have a blog dinner in central London with anyone who can make it, hopefully in cooler conditions, on the evening of Wednesday July 15.  Would you be interested? I’ll probably start around 6:00 or so for a pint with whomever is interested in quenching thirst before satisfying hunger, and then head over to dinner at 7:00 or so.  Location TBD -- but somewhere relatively interesting and easy to get to. You interested?  My plan is to limit the table to 10.   For those who come there are no obligations other than: Being a blog member Showing up Talking Paying for whatever you ingest.  (Whatever you exgest is free.) If you’d like to join me and a group of other blog members for an evening of interesting discussion of areas of mutual [...]

2026-06-26T07:05:55-04:00June 26th, 2026|Public Forum|

Did Pontius Pilate Write a Letter Explaining Why He Crucified Jesus?

I was recently asked about a letter allegedly written by Pontius Pilate to the Emperor Tiberius, explaining why he crucified the Son of God.  Outside of academic circles, this apocryphal letter is not well known.  For that matter, it's not well known even within academic circles.  Most New Testament scholars don't know it exists.  But it does! It is part of a group of texts that scholars (the ones who study these things) sometimes call the "Pilate Gospels."  There are a number of these writings -- all of them legendary/apocryphal, of course.  This particular letter is called the Anaphora Pilati (= The Report of Pilate) .  I made a new translation of the text from the Greek, along with a brief explanation of what it is all about, in the the book I co-edited with my colleague Zlatko Pleše, The Other Gospels.   Here is the introduction (edited a bit) and translation.  If you're interested in this kind of thing, check out the book itself! (in my next post I'll give Tiberius's [alleged] reply!) ****************************** Introduction  The “Report” [...]

2026-06-20T20:37:20-04:00June 25th, 2026|Christian Apocrypha, Public Forum|

How Do You Publish a Book for a General Audience?

In my previous post I talked about what it takes to write and publish a scholarly book.  Most people who aren't scholars aren't thinking that way.  They want to publish a book for a broader audience to get their ideas out there.  How do you do that? These days it can be done relatively simply by self-publishing.  I know almost nothing about how that works, other than that people do it all the time (more books get published that way than with trade-book publishers, I believe).  But I can say something about what it takes to get a book published with a professional publisher. That, as it turns out, is really tricky, for reasons some people may not expect.  It involves a weird Catch-22. In most academic fields -- whether astronomy or biblical studies -- trade books (that is, books for a broader readership) have normally been published by scholars who want to communicate with non-scholars.  The problem is that most scholars are not particularly adept at doing that  -- they have difficulty explaining their [...]

2026-06-20T20:40:21-04:00June 23rd, 2026|Public Forum|

The Realities of Publishing a Scholarly Book

One of the emails I get *all* the time is from authors who have written a book, or hope to write a book, who want to know how they can get a publisher to take a look at it.   The short answer: it ain’t easy.  Often the inquiry comes from someone who wants to publish a book for scholars to convince them to take a different view on a matter of scholarly importance.  How does a someone get a publisher to publish a book like that? People don't like to hear this, but if you don't already have scholarly credentials an academic publisher will almost certainly (or at least extremely rarely) even consider your manuscript.  And having the credentials, for a first-time author, almost always means having done advanced graduate level education in the field. I know a lot of authors who think that it’s not fair that they can’t get their books published “just because I don’t have a PhD.”   It get that -- it must be hugely frustrating.  But the problem is that [...]

2026-06-16T07:20:22-04:00June 21st, 2026|Public Forum|

Memory of My Past: My First Girlfriend and Jesus

Some of you have probably had this same experience.  Now that I'm 70, I'm thinking about my past a lot more than ... in the past.  The other day I was thinking about my life in high school soon after I had become a born-again Christian (an incredibly ignorant born-again Christian).  One incident quickly came to mind. Before I became a gung-ho Christian, my first serious girlfriend was Linda, whom I met when we were starting our sophomore year in high school.  She was funny, personable, attractive, intelligent, and Jewish.  I’m not sure I had ever known a Jewish person before her. Now I don’t recall that we ever talked about religion, and looking back  I suppose it’s not particularly surprising.  She and her family  certainly weren’t observant Jews and my uninformed sense is that they were completely secular.  I don’t know if they went to synagogue or kept any of the holidays, but I kind-a doubt it.  In any event, at that point in my life religion wasn’t really my main concern [...]

2026-06-16T07:12:09-04:00June 20th, 2026|Public Forum|

The Parable of the Sower as Advice for Capitalists

Is Jesus’ parable of the sower (Mark 4:1-9) best understood as providing (pre-)capitalist advice about how to think about monetary investments? Is it a divine guide for growing your portfolio?  Is it instructing us to consider the market and plant our wealth where it is most likely to grow – thirty-fold, sixty-fold, one hundred-fold? There are certainly people today who have read it that way.  If you’re a hard-core capitalist who sees everything in economic terms then it would make sense that this is how you think about the parable.  (Understanding Jesus as the “greatest businessman who ever lived” has been around for a century now; see Bruce Barton, The Man Nobody Knows, 1925 – one of the best selling non-fiction books of the 20th century!). But what if you want to understand the parable in Jesus’ own context? In that case, yeah, not so much.  This is not a guide to how to run your business or choose your investments.  When you look at the details, it is actually quite the opposite.  The parable, [...]

2026-06-12T09:33:45-04:00June 16th, 2026|Canonical Gospels, Public Forum|

Why Not Believe in a God Who is *Not* Active in the World?

Isn’t atheism an extreme position to take?  If you (or, well, I) give up believe in the Christian God we were (I was) raised on, why give up on the idea of any god entirely? I’m on a trip giving lectures to a group of folks who, well, want to see Norway (!) but also want to discuss issues closely related to what we do on the Blog – questions about the New Testament, the historical Jesus, early Christianity, related topics in religion, and questions about religion in general.  It’s a great group with people of a wide range of backgrounds and lots of interesting stories. Already we have discussed lots of interesting things, and one of my fellow travelers has pushed me on why I became an atheist.  They agree that there are real problems with believing in an all-loving and all-powerful God who wants humans to thrive, be happy, be content with life, and who is certainly able to make that happen for everyone if he chooses (even if there does [...]

2026-06-08T08:55:19-04:00June 13th, 2026|Public Forum|

Controversies About the Gospel of John: The Views of John Spong

Just how reliable is the Gospel of John?  Is there *anything* in it that is historical? A radical view of John was presented by John Shelby Spong in one of his last books (he published some nineteen or so over the course of his long career.)  In my previous post I gave a brief biographical notice about John Shelby Spong, in commemoration of his death in 2021 -- in case you don't know who he was. There aren't too many Christian scholars who are more skeptical of its historical value than I am: but he is one!  Here is how I discussed and engaged with the book when it came out.  This will take two posts. ****************************** John Shelby Spong, former Episcopal bishop of New Jersey and highly controversial author (because of his skeptical views about the New Testament and traditional Christian doctrine) has just published a new book on the Gospel of John, called The Fourth Gospel: Tales of a Jewish Mystic. He also wrote an interesting article on it that appeared [...]

2026-06-04T08:52:07-04:00June 9th, 2026|Canonical Gospels, Public Forum|

Radical Skeptic (about the Bible) and Episcopal Bishop: John Spong

I'm with a group of travelers just now who are interested in critical approaches to the Bible (not views that are criticizing per se, but views that approach the Bible using historical methods -- "Biblical Criticism").  One of them - as usually happens - has asked me about the very popular writings of John Shelby Spong, who was an unusual figure in numerous ways, most famously because he was both highly skeptical about the reliability of the New Testament AND a long-time bishop in the Episcopal church.  How does that work? Well, work it did.  He had a deservedly huge following. Years ago I posted comments on a book he wrote near the end of his career on the Gospel of John, which takes an even more skeptical view of its reliability than I do.  But I realized I should first set the context for those of you who don't know who he was by re-posting my "Memorium" for him written soon after he died.  So here is that first, then my summary/discussion of his [...]

2026-06-04T08:37:10-04:00June 7th, 2026|Public Forum|

Did the Doctrine of Predestination Lead to Capitalism?

In my previous post I gave a brief overview of the doctrine of predestination, especially as developed by the great 16th century Protestant Reformer John Calvin and his followers.  I ended the post by indicating – surely this is a surprise for many people – that one of the most interesting and formative understandings of modern capitalism is that its has it can be traced back in its origins to Protestant views of predestination.  How does that work exactly? The key text is Max Weber, The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, tr. Talcott Parsons (NY: Scribner, 1958; German original, 1920).  Weber (= VEY-ber) was an important German intellectual often credited as being the founder of modern Sociology as an academic discipline. He begins his book with an intriguing question about modern economic systems that, till then, had never posed: why [in his time, the early 20th century] are there more capitalist ventures, capitalists, and trained capitalist laborers in Protestant countries than in Catholic ones?  And in countries of mixed populations, why are there [...]

2026-05-28T15:51:58-04:00June 3rd, 2026|Public Forum|

Predestination! What do you think?

What do you think of the idea of predestination?  That only those who have been predestined by God (from eternity past) can be saved: but not anyone else. The doctrine can be found or at least intimated (possibly: depending on how you interpret them) in a few – though not many – passages of the Bible.  The following are three that seem the clearest (key words highlighted; these translations are from the NRSV ue):   Romans 8 28 We know that all things work together for good for those who love God, who are called according to his purpose. 29 For those whom he foreknew he also predestined to be conformed to the image of his Son, in order that he might be the firstborn within a large family.[s] 30 And those whom he predestined he also called, and those whom he called he also justified, and those whom he justified he also glorified.    Ephesians 1 3 Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who has blessed us in Christ with every spiritual blessing in the heavenly [...]

2026-05-28T15:41:59-04:00June 2nd, 2026|Public Forum|

Did the Glories of Martyrdom Lead to Christian Conversions?

Some think that, in contrast to miracles & martyrdom, the fear of perpetual torment in hell may be what drove the early growth of Christianity. After all, who WOULDN'T want to avoid eternal fiery torture? Here’s what I said about that in my book Triumph of Christianity (Simon & Schuster) ****************************** I’ve indicated that fire and brimstone preaching won many converts in early Christianity.  What about the idea that the stalwart faith of Christian martyrs, the willingness to “die for the truth” had a big effect on ancient people as well?  As it turns out, those two were closely related. The horrors of hell may have been the argument for why people should convert, but it was the miracles that made the argument persuasive.  God had shown, and continues to show, what he could do to counteract the ravages of pain, misery, and suffering.  Anyone who refused to side with him now would pay a price later.   Or as one group of Christian martyrs is said to have proclaimed to the pagan hordes [...]

2026-05-25T18:36:16-04:00May 30th, 2026|Public Forum|

June 2026 Gold Q&A Announcement

Gold and Platinum Members, a new month is quickly approaching, which means it's time to schedule our next Q&A. It will take place on Sunday June 21st at 2pm Eastern. For May’s Q&A, we tried a new format, and your feedback was overwhelmingly positive. So we’re bringing it back again this month. Bart will spend the first half of our Zoom session answering your pre-submitted questions. As always, you can email your questions to [email protected]. Be sure to get your questions in by end of day Thursday June 18th. For the second half of the hour, we’ll be opening things up to live attendee participation, giving you the opportunity to ask Bart questions in real time on a specific topic. For June, Bart has chosen: The Letters of Paul If you’d like to participate in the live Q&A: Prepare your question in advance Make sure your question is specifically focused on the Gospels Keep your question to roughly 20 seconds or less Be ready to ask it live during the session Meeting Details: Zoom Link: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/81230541341?pwd=JT80bFn6uO6fOw2jBpHtjPNsC5itMz.1 [...]

2026-05-28T22:25:44-04:00May 29th, 2026|Public Forum|

The Fear of Hell as an Incentive to Convert

Miracles converted millions of people to the Christian faith in the ancient world.  What about the fear of hell? Here’s how I talk about it in my book Triumph of Christianity (Simon & Schuster) ****************************** One of the reasons stories of miracles proved so effective in making converts is that Christians combined them with the claim that God’s manifestation of power in the present foreshadowed what he would do in the future.  The present life may have been filled with pain and suffering: people were starving; they were afflicted with blindness, loss of hearing, paralysis, the ravages of disease, or abject poverty; they were attacked by hordes of evil demons.  Life could be, and for many it was, a wretched existence, a cesspool of misery.  But God’s miracle workers cured these ills.  They could multiply the supplies of food, cure the body’s deficiencies, heal any disease, and overpower the demons. Moreover, all that was merely a prelude to what was to come.  After this life humans could enter into a world of sheer [...]

2026-05-25T15:49:15-04:00May 28th, 2026|Public Forum|

Was Augustine Telling the Truth About Miracles He’d Seen?

Miracles seem to be everywhere in the early Christian literature, and it is striking how insistent all these ancient sources are it was precisely the wonder-working abilities of the Christians in the name of Christ and the Christian God that convinced potential converts to leave the religious traditions that nearly everyone around them had and had had for time immemorial to join this bizarre new faith in only one God who would provide salvation only to those who believed in the death and resurrection of Jesus. But that's the consistent testimony, and to cap it off I turn to Augustine, the greatest theologian in the history of Christianity, famous still today, incredibly learned, devout, and sincere, and not one who was prone to deception.  Augustine in fact wrote two treatises about lying, arguing that in NO circumstances, WHATSOEVER, was it EVER right to lie.  Not EVER. He too reports that Christians did miracles and more than that, he claims explicitly that he had seen a whole lot of them.  He gives some details. Here's what [...]

2026-05-22T12:18:46-04:00May 27th, 2026|Public Forum|

Christianity: A Weirdly Exclusivist Religion

In my previous post dealing with how Christianity managed to take over the Roman empire, I stressed its two highly unusual (and therefore -- to outsiders -- weird) aspects that in tandem ended up more or less destroying all the other religions:  their stress on evangelism and their insistence on exclusivity.  It's not that every Christian evangelized or that all Christians completely gave up all their other religious traditions, but enough did that it led to the Christianization of the West. Here I want to explain a bit more about how the virtually unparalleled exclusivity worked, again drawing on my book The Triumph of Christianity (Simon & Schuster). ****************************** One way to understand Christian exclusivity is to think about the Christians’ unusual approach to “choice.”   Of course everyone in the ancient world had to choose how to live, what to think, how to behave, and how to worship.   In fact, pagan religions in recent scholarship have been portrayed as a kind of “marketplace,” where “shoppers” would choose among competing options.  Just as you might choose to [...]

2026-05-09T11:32:12-04:00May 13th, 2026|Public Forum, Spread of Christianity|

Blog Dinner in Waynesville NC, May 19. Wanna Come?

I'll be in Waynesville NC next week and would love to have a blog dinner with anyone who can make it, on the evening of Tuesday May 19.   Interested? I'll probably start around 6:30 or so for drinks with whoever is interested in quenching thirst before satisfying hunger, with dinner at 7:15 or so.  Location TBD. You interested?  My plan is to limit the table to 8, me and the perfect number 7.   For those who come there are no obligations other than: Being a blog member Showing up Talking Paying for whatever you ingest.  (Whatever you exgest is free.) If you're interested, do NOT reply here as a comment.  Send along an email at [email protected]. Hope some of you can come!  

2026-05-09T11:25:09-04:00May 8th, 2026|Public Forum|

Jesus and Capitalism: My Next Book (A Big Change)

For over a year now I've been thinking and saying my next book would be on the formation of the New Testament canon -- how we got these 27 books and not others.  I definitely am going to write that book, but something else has come up that is going to occupy my time, brain, and research first. My publisher, now that Love They Stranger is out, has asked me to consider writing a book about Jesus and capitalism (and socialism and marxism etc.).  At first I was hesitant.  I'm obviously not an economist.  And there are plenty of books like that (look them up online).  BUT, not so much by New Testament scholars approaching the issue the way I would. So I'm gonna do it. Books like this take shape over time.  I never know exactly where my research will take me or what I will turn up that is hugely interesting but that I never thought about much before.  (Did you ever see that old Daffy Duck cartoon when he's rowing a [...]

2026-05-04T09:23:49-04:00May 7th, 2026|Public Forum|
Go to Top