

“What experiments and observations demonstrate each of those 3 allegations?”
“These are conclusions based on decades of scientific research”
Many people like to allege that their claims are “based on decades of scientific research”/ based on ‘science.’
You’re the first person to claim to me that “Free Will is an illusion” is based on ‘science.’
“But why should I do the heavy lifting for you?”
If you decline to support your allegations with e.g. references to the peer-reviewed scientific literature, that’s fine with me.
“if you’re truly interested you’ll investigate yourself to see if any or all of these ‘allegations’ bear out”
According to your view, I can’t of my own free will choose to “investigate” _anything_.
“Is the first pebble that slides out of place completely responsible for the resulting avalanche that wipes out a village in the Andes and all its inhabitants?”
No.
“Is the tiger that stalks and eats a child who wanders too far from an African village morally responsible for the death of the child?”
No.
Tigers are incapable of doing anything immoral.
“At the moment of the Big Bang was it inevitable that you and I would have this exchange?”
No.
“Think of a city you’re traveled to, any city, the first that come to mind. In what sense if any did you ‘choose’ to think of that particular city?”
Beats me.
A city name plopped into my mind.
I’m unaware of having chosen to think of that particular city.
Think of a city you’ve traveled to for vacation purposes.
In what sense if any did you ‘choose’ to travel to that particular city?
BDEhrman
FreedomBen
evgendob
Robert
1 Guest(s)
