Bart Ehrman Blog Readers Forum

A A A
Forum Scope


Match



Forum Options



Min search length: 3 characters / Max search length: 84 characters
Lost password?
sp_TopicIcon
THIS IS MAJOR ! ! ! Yahweh was not originally a Canaanite God ! ! !
Avatar
Robert
7768 Posts
(Offline)
41
October 21, 2026 - 3:17 pm
Avatar
Steefen
8356 Posts
(Offline)
42
October 21, 2026 - 10:52 pm

Steefen said
Dr. Bart Ehrman,
I found this:
“Celsus argued in The True Word (Alēthēs Logos), preserved in Origen’s Against Celsus, that Jewish religion represented a departure from, and distortion of, an ancient religious tradition shared by other peoples, including the Greeks. He compared Jewish beliefs and practices with older traditions of worship and mystery cults, challenging the Jews’ claim to religious originality.” There is a comparison of Sukkot to the Thesmophoria of Ancient Greece.
Have you posted about anything in Origen’s Against Celsus. I’m interested in this. Administrators and members of the forum have reached their limits, so I thought with your background, and for reason, you are no longer a Christian, you would have a scholarly opinion on Celsus’ arguments. 
Any thoughts?
Thank you.
  

Dr. Ehrman:

Years ago Joseph Hoffman published an editoin of The True Word taken from Origen’s refuttaion, in which he didn’t include the refutation, just the things Celsus said. In many instances, it struck me that Celsus’s argument was strong than (what I new was) Origen’s response.

** you do not have permission to see this link **

Steefen:
54 ratings averaging 4.4 stars

“[An] important contribution to the wealth of patristic texts scholars are making available to English readers….Published and arranged in such a way that readers can get a fairly clear and coherent picture of Celsus’ argument.”
–Review and Expositor

“An excellent synopsis of the intellectual attack on Christianity by Roman paganism….Should spark lively discussion.”
–Edward M. Anson, University of Arkansas, Little Rock

“A fresh attempt to solve an old scholarly problem: to present the ‘True Celsus,’ in this case in a contemporary English version with up-to-date introduction and notes….The resultant text is readable.”
–Anglican Theological Review

“A lucid translation of one of the most fascinating pieces of literature left to us from the second century.”
–Frank Thielman, Beeson Divinity School, Samford University

“The first complete translation of Christianity’s most ardent second-century critic….Highly readable.”
–Free Inquiry

“A great contribution to scholarship in the study of early Christianity. The general introduction is worth the price of the book, and to have this new translation of the ancient work of Celsus is most useful and valuable.”
–J. William Angell, Wake Forest University

“Every serious student of early Christianity should give attention to Celsus….A first-rate publication with excellent, comprehensive introduction and notes.“
–Sterling M. McMurrin, University of Utah

“I am very pleased with the convenience of this edition and [with] Professor Hoffmann’s valuable general introduction, which so effectively summarizes and reviews key historical issues.”
–Harry Rosenberg, Colorado State University

“Not only a very useful and readable text but also a clear and informative introduction. This book is a first priority for theological libraries and for all working in this area of patristic studies.”
–Southwestern Journal of Theology

“Fills the gap of a long-needed and -desired English translation…. Establish[es] a solid base for the understanding of Celsus’ polemic….Even the most experienced will find ample food for thought in this work.”
–Favonius

“Does a distinct service for all of us in making Celsus’ Discourse readily available in excellent English…. We need to read Celsus in order to have a clearer understanding of our tradition and our identity.”
–Dr. Norman A. Beck, Texas Lutheran College

dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.j-z4Urq-Ifj98PLgm8c2l0dAAq4cwzqaq_2_aJaeUqYxHCOWRTZOO5ig437wTXD8kmkuyqtO5gP-WP1CUc1EfRxZvP3iniZ7Rs9u8R9K9K3GqV7l0JES6as6Hz0jmy6MdS2J8fENrJVx-N70PSr2XR6q-f6qgvA-E3wg0V0NqEMVjoug_XpsIBHcDE524zcAP6wW5wkPyVrcv40Z7Yk03OUfb3DYImhhmyue1PXP7c4.7A3Ekyq4eQOTwTSWHBVn0t7xvnARiMGKLMUa4pBxid4&dib_tag=se&keywords=joseph+hoffman+the+true+world&qid=1792636967&sprefix=joseph+hoffman+the+true+wor%2Caps%2C142&sr=8-1

Avatar
Steefen
8356 Posts
(Offline)
43
October 21, 2026 - 10:57 pm

Thank you Dr. Ehrman. Joseph Hoffman in 1987 did an excellent job given reviews like these two: 

“A great contribution to scholarship in the study of early Christianity. The general introduction is worth the price of the book, and to have this new translation of the ancient work of Celsus is most useful and valuable.”
–J. William Angell, Wake Forest University

“Every serious student of early Christianity should give attention to Celsus….A first-rate publication with excellent, comprehensive introduction and notes.“
–Sterling M. McMurrin, University of Utah

Steve Campbell
Author of Historical Accuracy (2021)

Avatar
Stephen
5072 Posts
(Offline)
44
October 22, 2026 - 1:36 pm

Robert said

Stephen said
… Origen was too smart for everybody! 

He was indeed. Bart and many if not most Protestants consider Augustine to be the greatest of the early patristic thinkers and theologians, and while I will readily concede there are parts of Augustine’s work that are certainly worthwhile and he had the largest influence in the West, I gotta go with Irenaeus and Origen as more creative thinkers with more acceptable and attractive versions of Christian theology.
  

Origen’s Christian enemies painted him as a Hellenist corrupted by pagan thought but when you read him you find few thinkers more reverential to the Hebrew scriptures.  Origen had some ideas common to his day that his later more ideologically pure antagonists deemed unworthy. 

I’ve always had mixed emotions about Augustine.  One can be moved by his self-awareness but appalled by his ideas.  He did a lot of damage.  

Avatar
Porphyry

1972 Posts
(Offline)
45
October 22, 2026 - 5:20 pm

I’m actually in shock that Robert would class Irenaeus–an arch hereseyologist– with Origen on that score. 

 

I tend to think of Origen as very much on the “reason sets the limits of faith” side (I think this was a mark of the entire Antiochean school), and Irenaeus as very much the, “this is the faith, so suck it up and believe” side. And on that scale, I’d put Augustine much closer to Ignatius than to Origen–though I’d readily admit Augustine’s genuine genius and his ability to see immediately the consequences of his faith. 

And Origen was the one who ended up being deemed a heretic. 

Avatar
Robert
7768 Posts
(Offline)
46
October 22, 2026 - 6:30 pm
Avatar
Steefen
8356 Posts
(Offline)
47
October 22, 2026 - 11:49 pm

@Robert

Please consider moving Comments 67 – 71 off this thread because @Judith is at it again, failing to make on-topic contributions. She is a trouble-maker who trashes threads. One would think BJH1960 would stay on topic and earn points of respect, but he joins her.

Her comments are not about Yahweh being or not being a Canaanite God.

The thread gets somewhat back on track with the help of Dr. Bart Ehrman but @DavidFord is more interested in “socializing” with Judith and BJH1960.

She could care LESS about understanding the origins of Yahweh.

People would like to concentrate on Porphyry and your exchange and let it further the conversation about Yahweh not originally being of Canaanite origin.

= = = =

I am thinking about the importance of Ugarit in this thread.

Ugarit was not formally considered part of Canaan in ancient administrative terms, though it shared deep cultural, linguistic, and religious ties with the Canaanite world.

 

Cultural and Linguistic Connections

Shared Pantheon: Ugaritic religion featured a West-Semitic pantheon—including El, Baal, and Asherah—that closely mirrored Canaanite mythology.

Language: The local Ugaritic language was an archaic, conservative Northwest Semitic language
closely related to Canaanite and biblical Hebrew, though written in a unique 30-letter cuneiform alphabet.

Conclusion

Yahweh’s absence from Ugaritic texts suggests that he was not part of the traditional Canaanite pantheon as understood in Ugarit. This supports theories that Yahweh was either a southern deity who entered the Israelite religious framework later or a deity with distinct origins who became central to Israelite identity. This development reflects the dynamic and syncretic nature of ancient Near Eastern religions.

Steefen:
My position is that Yahweh, in my understanding, was not north in Syria in Ugarit, north of Lebanon or Phoenicia.

Yahweh, for me, was from the Levant culture that descended into Egypt’s Delta.

So, someone clarify how my using the Joseph story and his descent into Egypt speaks to Ugarit which was north of Egypt’s area of influence in the Levant. I wasn’t putting Canaan that far north. 

Avatar
Steefen
8356 Posts
(Offline)
48
October 22, 2026 - 11:59 pm

People like me do not want to think about an Ehrman thread just to get distracted by Judith.

People do not have time for “socializing.” 

I thought she would stick to her threads about movies or some junior/elementary topics, but no, she wants to disrupt contemplation with psychobabble and gossip.

= = = =

Yes, this is important to me because it can be reason for me editing my book.

With Erik Hornung being the source I used for descents into Egypt from the Levant, I do think it is major that Canaan is connected as for north as Ugarit.

But nooooo, Judith wants to turn an Ancient Hebrew class into her being some mayor of nonsense.

Avatar
Steefen
8356 Posts
(Offline)
49
October 23, 2026 - 12:05 am

I have no book in my bibliography about Yahweh in Ugarit.

Probably, because as Neal said, Yahweh does not appear in Ugarit text.

So, what is the lesson here?

Well #1, Biblical Joseph, son of Jacob and Jospeh’s 11 brothers were not that far north in the Levant.

#2 Ancient Egypt had influence in the Levant. I did not know from the north Ugarit was also influencing the Levant.

Avatar
Steefen
8356 Posts
(Offline)
50
October 23, 2026 - 12:11 am

Ugarit was north of much of Canaan, but it was not isolated from Canaan. Maritime trade, land routes, diplomacy, and shared cultural traditions linked these regions.

Some scholars distinguish Ugarit and northern Syria from Canaan proper. Ancient texts can even treat Ugarit and Canaan as separate entities. Yet Ugarit’s language, religious literature, and material culture have close parallels with those of the southern Levant.

Avatar
Robert
7768 Posts
(Offline)
51
October 23, 2026 - 12:15 am
Avatar
Steefen
8356 Posts
(Offline)
52
October 23, 2026 - 12:20 am

Steefen said
Ugarit was north of much of Canaan, but it was not isolated from Canaan. Maritime trade, land routes, diplomacy, and shared cultural traditions linked these regions.
Some scholars distinguish Ugarit and northern Syria from Canaan proper. Ancient texts can even treat Ugarit and Canaan as separate entities. Yet Ugarit’s language, religious literature, and material culture have close parallels with those of the southern Levant.
  

Yes, your distinction is important. The biblical story of Joseph describes a family from Canaan moving south into Egypt; it does not identify that family as originating in Ugarit or as being specifically influenced by Ugaritic culture.

In Genesis, Jacob and his family leave Canaan during a famine and settle in Egypt, where Joseph has already risen to power (Genesis 42–47). That is a southward movement from the southern Levant into Egypt, not a migration from Ugarit in northern Syria.

Avatar
Steefen
8356 Posts
(Offline)
53
October 23, 2026 - 12:25 am

So far, I am still right:

Yahweh is from the southern Levant with Jacob and his 12 sons.

= = = =

Unless Bart, and maybe Robert and one or two others can show Yahweh being all up in Syria.

That’s not the Bible at that point in time.

Avatar
Steefen
8356 Posts
(Offline)
54
October 23, 2026 - 12:34 am

Robert:
I don’t discussion of Origen will contribute to the geographic origins of Yahelweh. You brought up Origen only because he argued extensively against Celsius, who tried to relate the whole origins of Yahweh and Judaism to the Greeks, but Celsus also is not likely to shed any real light on this topic since he is merely engaging in interpretatio Graeca. Nonetheless I can keep your comment about Celsus here and move all of the discussion of Origen to one of the other threads dealing with his thought.

Steefen:
Origen is part of this discussion. Judith playing gossip and who’s popular with her isn’t.

If Neal wants to go beyond Yahweh being from southern Levant by saying Yahweh could be thought of as being connected to Urgarit as Canaan was part of Ugarit, people can follow his reasoning. That’s easy.

If he says Celsus says Yahweh can be connected to Pre-Hellenistic Greece, Neal’s responsibility is to make a strong case for that. If he uses Celsus and if Origen says no. That is pertinent. 

Avatar
Robert
7768 Posts
(Offline)
55
October 23, 2026 - 12:54 am
Avatar
Steefen
8356 Posts
(Offline)
56
October 23, 2026 - 1:05 am

Neal is lumping all of the Levant and Canaan with the upper Levant including Syria and Ugarit.

I don’t know what empire Neal is referencing in the north with Ugarit. Egypt had influence up to southern Syria.

He’s saying, Scholars are wrong to say Yahweh was a Canaanite God, he’s not even in northern Levant-Ugaritic texts.

After he grants scholars Yahweh is supposed to be Canaanite, he then says they are wrong and moves Yahweh to Median.

Okay, Moses goes through Median. 

Moses brings Yahweh to his Median wife. But that still goes back to the bible with Jacob and Joseph bring Yahweh to the Exodus.

What was the connection before Jacob and Joseph?

Did Yahweh get to Median before Moses and his wife?

Avatar
Steefen
8356 Posts
(Offline)
57
October 23, 2026 - 1:09 am

Because he’s saying the road to a pre-Hellenistic Greek Yahweh is through Median.

I wasn’t convinced there was something with his argument until the weight of his linguistic research was backed by Celsus and others he mentions.

Avatar
Helen Young

564 Posts
(Offline)
58
October 23, 2026 - 6:19 am

Are you folks asking when was Yahweh/God first realized or discovered, or when ‘ E was first called Yahweh?

Avatar
Porphyry

1972 Posts
(Offline)
59
October 23, 2026 - 10:19 am

> I would love to hear more since I’m not very knowledgeable about either Irenaeus or Origen. 

I find myself in genuine awe, this morning, at how many truly embarrassing errors I managed to squeeze into one short post. Prudence would dictate that I humbly withdraw from the conversation, which I’m pretty clearly not qualified to participate in, but here goes:

I think of Origen’s allegorical exegesis as one method of getting around the problems and absurdities of a more literal and dogmatic reading; it gives space to harmonize faith to reason (by loosening the demands of faith). Of course, he wouldn’t have put it such terms, but functionally, it let him place reason over faith as a judge. Once you can make any passage a mere metaphor, the text is no longer the actual authority. 

That married to the way he was happy to use philosophy extensively in his theology–despoiling the Egyptians as he called it–and the way he set a new standard for rigorous academic study of Scripture and the fact that his aforementioned willingness to dismiss the more problematic parts of Scripture got him labeled a heretic, all that with his apophatic tendencies, and he seems like a the sort of person you would find a kindred spirit. And the contrast with Irenaeus–who did so much to form the dogmatic orthodox consensus, drawing sharp lines and insisting on strong formulae–seems to me especially clear. 

Avatar
Robert
7768 Posts
(Offline)
60
October 23, 2026 - 2:19 pm
Forum Timezone: America/Indiana/Indianapolis
All RSSShow Stats
Administrators:
BDEhrman
FreedomBen
evgendob
Robert
Top Posters:
Steefen: 8356
Stephen: 5072
Porphyry: 1972
godspell: 1827
DavidFord: 1790
BJH1960: 1582
brenmcg: 1184
Colin Milton: 1136
Judith: 1046
Jarek: 954
Newest Members:
ekane
ovais_khalil
charissa
Kirk3757
Janet K. Hellmann
PD_Blackwell
mattkon
Lisa2113940
mikewebb64
PastorBeals
Forum Stats:
Groups: 2
Forums: 13
Topics: 2694
Posts: 50188

 

Member Stats:
Guest Posters: 65
Members: 66512
Moderators: 0
Admins: 4
Most Users Ever Online: 3559
Currently Online: Serene, BJH1960, Judith
Guest(s) 27