Bart Ehrman Blog Readers Forum

A A A
Forum Scope


Match



Forum Options



Min search length: 3 characters / Max search length: 84 characters
Lost password?
sp_TopicIcon
THIS IS MAJOR ! ! ! Yahweh was not originally a Canaanite God ! ! !
Avatar
Porphyry

1972 Posts
(Offline)
61
October 23, 2026 - 3:28 pm

> I was never a fan of allegorical re-readings of scripture.

Well, neither was I insofar as it seemed not to be objective but more an eisegesis that reflects the interpreter’s concerns rather than anything in the text. 

But that also has an allure if you are trying to hold on to Scripture without committing to absurdities. Once you just accept that Scripture is meant to be read, not literally, but as a puzzle–sometimes deliberately difficult and intended to shock the reader out of complacence–it is a lot easier to reconcile it with reason.  I remember, for example, once being fascinated by Jordan Peterson’s Jungian reading of Genesis; it was a lot easier for me to make it make sense read in terms of archetypes than as history. That is entirely consonant with the general modernist project: Keep the dogma and formulae, revere them as capturing something truly profound, but as capturing something truly profound in a grasping sort of way that both allows and invites a very free, and ongoing interpretation to find its real meaning. 

> Please tell us more about why specifically condemned as a heretic. 

I can’t help but feel like this is a trap, though I doubt you intended to set one. I am confident you know at least as much as I do about the condemnations of Origen and Origenism. The only two things I would specifically draw attention to are that Origenism seems to have gone beyond Origen himself on a number of points (like transmigration of souls), but still, Origen himself certainly held a few of the condemned propositions–like preexistence of souls and the ultimate salvation of them all.

I’m also not persuaded of those specific beliefs, but I do see how they were inspired more by philosophy than Holy Writ. I don’t subscribe to them, but I understand how they are philosophically appealing, and I see how they are at home in the world of Greek philosophy. Though I disagree with the philosophy, I admire the willingness to give philosophical conviction such a defining role in his theology, despite it having so little Biblical support, and even fighting at times with the plain meaning of Scripture. 

> The appeal of Irenaeus was, I think, accompanied by liberal Catholic theologians who wanted to get back to a time before Augustine.

Yes, I suppose that if Augustine is your point of reference, Irenaeus will seem refreshingly fluid. But I feel like that would apply even more to an Origen.  

Avatar
Helen Young

564 Posts
(Offline)
62
October 23, 2026 - 3:39 pm

Robert said

Medieval monks obsessively speculating wildly about the miraculously in-tact state of Mary’s hymen prior to, during, and forever after the birth of Jesus seems comically bizarre, but it provides a window into what may have been their own struggles… 

 

It always irritates me that more people don’t see the private life of the mother of Christ as being none of their business.

I mentioned it to Bart once over on the Blog, and he said that people have mentioned this, but the only reference he could give me was from The Life of Brian.

Avatar
Robert
7768 Posts
(Offline)
63
October 23, 2026 - 4:02 pm
Avatar
Stephen
5072 Posts
(Offline)
64
October 23, 2026 - 4:09 pm

Yeah when I read Judith’s posts the first thing I think of is that she’s a “trouble-maker who trashes threads”! Ha!  Somebody hereabouts is the “mayor of nonsense” (good title!) but I don’t think it’s Judith. 

 

Robert wrote:

Yeah, I was never a fan of allegorical re-readings of scripture. A few years ago, however, I began to reconsider allegory from a more modern sociological perspective. Any reading or reception of a text, perhaps especially an allegorical reading, or any expression of belief or doctrine, may reveal something of the life-situation of the reader and her community or audience.

I think it’s useful to remember that in Origen’s day (first half of the third century) the “faith” was still in flux.  There was as yet no established orthodoxy so it is not that he was allegorizing already fixed forms of thought. Origen was simply applying common Middle-Platonic Hellenistic intellectual categories to the scriptures. 

Origen interpreted the faith like the intellectual he was.   His was one of the paths not taken.  In his day he bumped heads with his own Bishop but it was from the vantage point of a later more structured orthodoxy that he was looked on as a heretic.  
 
Please tell us more about why specifically condemned as a heretic. I am indeed drawn to heretics, and especially to apophatic types, but in addition to his allegorizing, I never liked his transmigration of pre-existing souls and reincarnation. It is especially intriguing how apophatic theology can be developed and promoted among more extreme rationalists while at the same time essentially sharing a perspective with pietists, quietists, and anti-intellectuals.
 
Origen was dismissed as a Hellenist, corrupted by paganism.  He had a lot of ideas common to intellectuals of his day,  ideas that became way way out of fashion after orthodoxy settled on certain approaches and excluded others.   Pre-existence of souls, universalism (even Satan!), a hierarchical view of the Trinity (Subordinationism) & allegorical  interpretations of the scriptures.  But in reading Origen you discover a searching mind.  You see him asking lots of questions.  His critics, invariably a dull bunch, made his questions sound like answers. 
 
In later centuries he was used as a bludgeon to hit opponents of orthodoxy over the head.  To be called an “Origenist” was the equivalent of being called a “communist” during the McCarthy period.  (Or now.)   
Avatar
Robert
7768 Posts
(Offline)
65
October 23, 2026 - 4:29 pm
Avatar
Porphyry

1972 Posts
(Offline)
66
October 23, 2026 - 4:30 pm

> Now I suspect these were just suspect aspects of his thought process and method that allowed him to stray into what would eventually be considered heresy.

Yeah, I think that is right. I didn’t mean that he was specifically condemned for those things. 

> So is it the case that Origen himself only believed in pre-existent souls but not their transmigration and reincarnation, that was only a later development within Origenism?

That is my impression, but I am not a scholar of Origen. Also, he did believe in a universal return of all souls to God. 

> Yes, that is an admirable trait in a theologian. I’m guessing you wouldn’t have thought so back in the day?

I would have admired the willingness to use philosophy. I would not have accepted the idea that reason can judge Revelation, but I was occasionally relieved when I found a reputable theologian say in essence, “Revelation can’t mean that, because it would be absurd.” I suppose I was conflicted and inconsistent. 

Avatar
Robert
7768 Posts
(Offline)
67
October 23, 2026 - 4:33 pm
Avatar
Stephen
5072 Posts
(Offline)
68
October 23, 2026 - 5:18 pm

> So is it the case that Origen himself only believed in pre-existent souls but not their transmigration and reincarnation, that was only a later development within Origenism?

That is my impression, but I am not a scholar of Origen. Also, he did believe in a universal return of all souls to God. 

Yes that is correct. (See his Commentary on Matthew.)  His later enemies heaped “reincarnation” on him.  And unfortunately some of our contemporary New Age types want to claim Origen as a fellow traveler to lands unknown.

I am not an Origen scholar.  But I remember stumbling on him somewhere and wondering why the heck I had never heard of this guy?!?   I wish he had won the day but I think if he had the church could not have developed into the world conquering force it became.   Rigid systems of belief and practice cannot tolerate flexible categories of thought.  Boundaries must not be porous but be firm and inviolable.  

I would have admired the willingness to use philosophy. I would not have accepted the idea that reason can judge Revelation, but I was occasionally relieved when I found a reputable theologian say in essence, “Revelation can’t mean that, because it would be absurd.” I suppose I was conflicted and inconsistent. 

I suspect Origen himself would have expressed similar attitudes.  Fundamentalists hate recourse to imagination and speculation.  But they’re really good at establishing inquisitions.  

Avatar
Steefen
8356 Posts
(Offline)
69
October 23, 2026 - 6:45 pm

Steefen said
Thank you Dr. Ehrman. Joseph Hoffman in 1987 did an excellent job given reviews like these two: 
“A great contribution to scholarship in the study of early Christianity. The general introduction is worth the price of the book, and to have this new translation of the ancient work of Celsus is most useful and valuable.”
–J. William Angell, Wake Forest University
“Every serious student of early Christianity should give attention to Celsus….A first-rate publication with excellent, comprehensive introduction and notes.“
–Sterling M. McMurrin, University of Utah
Steve Campbell
Author of Historical Accuracy (2021)
  

And consider this:

dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.p0J5eDzBJBXdvuFwHRgzJA.SGHx5bpIPnHAVSaQ9hOPba0oG152JewyJLAq8gleXlg&dib_tag=se&keywords=against+celsius+henry+chadwick&qid=1792795102&s=books&sprefix=against+celsus+henry+chadwick%2Cstripbooks%2C117&sr=1-1

 

 
Discerning Reader
5 out of 5 stars
An excellent source
Reviewed in the United States on May 26, 2013
Format: Paperback
Verified Purchase
 
This is an excellent translation, and window into the thoughts of one of the earliest Christian thinkers. Origin was a philosopher, theologian, and early apologist.

Be warned: this book is the size of a Bible! However, it gives an early Christian response to pagan jabs at Christianity. This allows a glimpse into what pagans were thinking.

I bought this book to test Morton Smith’s “Jesus the Magician.” It was a compelling book. However, it lost it’s appeal once I read the source. Smith cherry-picked and stretched (that is an understatement)a handful of verses. After reading Contra-Celsum, I could see why his hypothesis lost steam.

Avatar
Steefen
8356 Posts
(Offline)
70
October 23, 2026 - 7:05 pm

Well, that’s $100 bucks right there and I’m supposed to get the Collected Works of Spinoza, Vol II (Edwin Curley).

The second and final volume of the most authoritative English-language edition of Spinoza’s writings

The Collected Works of Spinoza provides, for the first time in English, a truly satisfactory edition of all of Spinoza’s writings, with accurate and readable translations, based on the best critical editions of the original-language texts, done by a scholar who has published extensively on the philosopher’s work.

The centerpiece of this second volume is Spinoza’s Theological-Political Treatise, a landmark work in the history of biblical scholarship, the first argument for democracy by a major philosopher, and a forceful defense of freedom of thought and expression. This work is accompanied by Spinoza’s later correspondence, much of which responds to criticism of the Theological-Political Treatise. The volume also includes his last work, the unfinished Political Treatise, which builds on the foundations of the Theological-Political Treatise to offer plans for the organization of nontyrannical monarchies and aristocracies.

The elaborate editorial apparatus―including prefaces, notes, glossary, and indexes―assists the reader in understanding one of the world’s most fascinating, but also most difficult, philosophers. Of particular interest is the glossary-index, which provides extensive commentary on Spinoza’s technical vocabulary.

A milestone of scholarship more than forty-five years in the making, The Collected Works of Spinoza is an essential edition for anyone with a serious interest in Spinoza or the history of philosophy.

 

dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.gi4LaaU1ZX2RTlP0pbRlyNZ3QW62yRaY6ID2Yof8jk8ClvlE67VsaX1sFibi3hvGUeV307OnI2WBFF4WRPqy155zhucu_xxfZEFCMrNdT69cWMZONCxtQXuve8iRmfgU1QYABQK1Eq41ODBHgmZJH5FwTwOYHB-P5pwKdzChcUN-TFDMxA-KpJ7E4QteSw2UYaDbk_yA0HuBcyoJySYUt6HscAOqVvZFkIdRh4S4_ZI.KHfONxiLS72Ksf4cgCFUN_lU0XlRiTJMFB5ev5iDcb4&dib_tag=se&keywords=The+Collected+Works+of+Spinoza%2C+Vol+II%2C+Edwin+Curley&nsdOptOutParam=true&qid=1792796432&sprefix=the+collected+works+of+spinoza%2C+vol+ii%2C+edwin+curley%2Caps%2C212&sr=8-1

Avatar
Steefen
8356 Posts
(Offline)
71
October 23, 2026 - 7:35 pm

If your immediate objective is to investigate whether Sukkot incorporates elements of older Greek religious practices, you can postpone buying the Celsus book. Celsus is valuable for studying ancient criticism of Judaism and Christianity, but Plutarch is the more direct source for this particular question.

Avatar
Steefen
8356 Posts
(Offline)
72
October 23, 2026 - 7:57 pm

Empires associated with Ugarit

1. Hittite Empire — Anatolia

c. 1650–1200 BCE; imperial expansion especially from the 14th century BCE

The Hittites expanded into northern Syria and brought Ugarit into their sphere of influence. They competed with Egypt for control of Syria and the Levant.

 
 

2. Mitanni — northern Mesopotamia and Syria

c. 1500–1300 BCE

A powerful Hurrian-led kingdom that dominated northern Mesopotamia and exercised influence across Syria before Hittite expansion weakened it.

= = = 

Hittite gods associated with Canaan

Tarḫunna (Tarhunt) — the Storm God

Associated with storms, rain, and royal authority. His role is comparable to that of the West Semitic storm god Baal/Hadad. That similarity reflects a shared regional religious environment, but does not by itself prove that Tarhunt was the source of Baal worship.

Sun Goddess of Arinna

One of the principal deities of the Hittite state, paired with the Storm God. Her cult illustrates the importance of divine kingship and the integration of local Anatolian traditions into the imperial religion.

Teššub — the Hurrian Storm God

Especially important during the Hittite Empire period. Hurrian religion connected northern Syria and Anatolia, and Teššub’s cult had links with Syrian religious centers. His traditions are relevant to the broader environment in which Canaanite religion developed.

 
 = = = =
 
I’m not going to tie Ugarit with the Jacob and Joseph because I will not make the claim they were theologically affected by the northern Levant or southern Syria and further north to Ugarit.
Avatar
Steefen
8356 Posts
(Offline)
73
October 23, 2026 - 8:01 pm

Steefen:

So Neal’s claim that Ugarit/Northern Canaan does not mention Yahweh was interesting to learn about but the “memoir” of Jacob and Joseph and their God descending into Egypt does not include what was going on all the way up beyond southern Syria.

Avatar
Steefen
8356 Posts
(Offline)
74
October 23, 2026 - 9:51 pm

Thank you Helen Young.

= = = =

Everyone who has said disparaging things about the value of my posts, I have spent much money and much time to get my intelligence where it is today and I do not think of your disrespectful put-downs when I spend $100 plus on my religious intelligence because I will have an impressive bibliography BACKING UP my rationale and I can hold an argument and a discussion to edify people who come in contact with me; AND, I can actively listen, participate, and go further when I do not know something.

Avatar
Robert
7768 Posts
(Offline)
75
October 24, 2026 - 9:23 am
Avatar
BJH1960

1582 Posts
(Online)
76
October 24, 2026 - 9:50 am

Robert said:

I have moved these posts for the time-being to Bruce’s thread on curtailing nonsense. If he objects, I will move them elsewhere. With Steefen’s and Bruce’s permission I would like to move all posts pertaining to criticism of Steefen’s posting behavior to that thread and let this thread be devoted to the origin of Yahweh.

That’s fine with me on both counts.

Avatar
Porphyry

1972 Posts
(Offline)
77
October 24, 2026 - 1:25 pm

> I have spent much money and much time to get my intelligence where it is today and I do not think of your disrespectful put-downs when I spend $100 plus on my religious intelligence

I’m not sure whether I ought to congratulate you for getting what you paid ($100!) or advise you that you ought to seek a refund. 

> I can hold an argument and a discussion to edify people who come in contact with me;

Might it be presumptuous to think you are edifying those who come into contact with you? Especially given how many people who have spent a lot more than $100 on their education have found it impossible to have a constructive conversation with you?

I am also surprised to learn you think you can have an argument or discussion with anyone. I suppose, to be fair, you have shown you can dismiss anyone. But that is hardly having a constructive conversation with anyone. 

>AND, I can actively listen, participate, and go further when I do not know something.

Steefen, you have a habit of responding with dismissive condescension to anyone who offers any challenge to your theories. After all, you wrote a self-published book; we should all (you seem to think) be lucky to learn at your knee.

Indeed, most of your posts aren’t even addressed to anyone; you post your notes to yourself and seem to be under the impression that we are all lucky to observe such a grand intellect at work, as though your using the forum as personal note-taking software has been a gift to us mere mortals. If any of us with actual academic qualifications dares question your theories, we have been treated as ungrateful pupils. 

Avatar
Porphyry

1972 Posts
(Offline)
78
October 24, 2026 - 5:37 pm

> Details?

Can you imagine anything I may have meant? Do you recall any time that I (or others) have openly criticized your posting patterns? If so, do you recall the substance of our complaints?

Avatar
Porphyry

1972 Posts
(Offline)
79
October 24, 2026 - 6:23 pm

> If you don’t want to supply details, that’s fine by me.

Do you think I have not previous, very explicitly and publicly and sharply, supplied specific details of my complaints about your posting habits? Do you, for example, not remember a recent post wherein I contrasted you and Socrates? 

Avatar
Porphyry

1972 Posts
(Offline)
80
October 24, 2026 - 8:21 pm

> Not AFAIK.

Would you say you habitually answer relevant questions directly put to you, or would you say your MO is to flood the forum with excerpts from books you haven’t read and to ask questions incessantly of other posters (often not even taking the time to make them full sentences, and often not on topic) without having the courtesy to answer when questions are put to you? 

> URL to your post?

You can search for the exact phrase “Brandolini’s Bullshit Asymmetry Principle ” or “partially masticated crayon” if you’d like to relive one of my more acerbic moments.  “God, you are stupid” should also pull it up. 

Forum Timezone: America/Indiana/Indianapolis
All RSSShow Stats
Administrators:
BDEhrman
FreedomBen
evgendob
Robert
Top Posters:
Steefen: 8356
Stephen: 5072
Porphyry: 1972
godspell: 1827
DavidFord: 1790
BJH1960: 1582
brenmcg: 1184
Colin Milton: 1136
Judith: 1046
Jarek: 954
Newest Members:
ekane
ovais_khalil
charissa
Kirk3757
Janet K. Hellmann
PD_Blackwell
mattkon
Lisa2113940
mikewebb64
PastorBeals
Forum Stats:
Groups: 2
Forums: 13
Topics: 2694
Posts: 50188

 

Member Stats:
Guest Posters: 65
Members: 66512
Moderators: 0
Admins: 4
Most Users Ever Online: 3559
Currently Online: Serene, BJH1960, Judith
Guest(s) 27