Bart Ehrman Blog Readers Forum

A A A
Forum Scope


Match



Forum Options



Min search length: 3 characters / Max search length: 84 characters
Lost password?
sp_TopicIcon
Campbellian Concepts: Jesus is a Composite Character of Historical Fiction and DR. JAMES TABOR, Failed Apocalyptic Messiah 200 Years BEFORE Jesus
Avatar
Porphyry

1994 Posts
(Offline)
161
October 14, 2026 - 5:05 pm

>>  I have suffered for my art and now it’s your turn.

 

Oh, Stephen, we’ve suffered every of your 5,000 posts along the way. 

; )

Avatar
Stephen
5058 Posts
(Offline)
162
October 15, 2026 - 12:44 pm

Porphyry said
>>  I have suffered for my art and now it’s your turn.
 
Oh, Stephen, we’ve suffered every of your 5,000 posts along the way. 
; )
  

Porphyry I very much hope you will continue to suffer with us.  I’m glad to do my part. Laugh

Avatar
2380

92 Posts
(Offline)
163
October 15, 2026 - 6:54 pm

There are 2things I can’t stand, it’s the intolerant and the Dutch!

Avatar
Robert
7754 Posts
(Online)
164
October 15, 2026 - 7:28 pm
Avatar
BJH1960

1587 Posts
(Offline)
165
October 16, 2026 - 2:51 pm

I do have to say that those last lines are unfortunately all too true:

“What nature doesn’t do to us
Will be done by our fellow man”

Avatar
Steefen
8282 Posts
(Offline)
166
October 16, 2026 - 9:14 pm

Comment 133

 

Comment 135

Avatar
Helen Young

544 Posts
(Offline)
167
October 17, 2026 - 8:32 am

Counterpoint:

Jesus did exist, and he is the Christ/Messiah.

Is everything written about him in the NT true and the absolute facts? This is another question, but I myself would say no, not everything.

So we have a difference of perspective and opinion here. Does this constitute WWIII? I hope not.

There are proofs of Jesus’s existence in all the texts and belief systems that people have built around him.

There are also a good number of people who think that having experienced his presence and his light is proof of his eternity and his existence. – – – Does this prove it to anyone else? Probably not, or not so much.

Probably we will have to go on with this difference of perspective and opinion for some time. Possibly forever.

Do we want to “proselytize” or “convert” each other one way or the other? This is perhaps not such a good idea.

We do all have the right to state our opinions and perspectives on the subject, however.

Here’s to the right to state and be open about our outlooks and perspectives! Let Freedom Ring!

But maybe we should try to be nice about it.

Avatar
Steefen
8282 Posts
(Offline)
168
October 18, 2026 - 1:09 pm

Helen Young said
Counterpoint:
Jesus did exist, and he is the Christ/Messiah.
Is everything written about him in the NT true and the absolute facts? This is another question, but I myself would say no, not everything.
So we have a difference of perspective and opinion here. Does this constitute WWIII? I hope not.
There are proofs of Jesus’s existence in all the texts and belief systems that people have built around him.
There are also a good number of people who think that having experienced his presence and his light is proof of his eternity and his existence. – – – Does this prove it to anyone else? Probably not, or not so much.
Probably we will have to go on with this difference of perspective and opinion for some time. Possibly forever.
Do we want to “proselytize” or “convert” each other one way or the other? This is perhaps not such a good idea.
We do all have the right to state our opinions and perspectives on the subject, however.
Here’s to the right to state and be open about our outlooks and perspectives! Let Freedom Ring!
But maybe we should try to be nice about it.
  

Resolution: The Biblical Jesus existed AND he is the Christ and the Jewish Messiah and the type of Messiah Christians Need.

First Affirmative Constructive
I. Everything in the New Testament about him is not true.
II. People have experienced him. His presence and light is proof of his eternity and his existence.
     This is proof for some.
III. This proof is insufficient for all.
IV. Converting people perhaps is not a good idea.
V. We have the right and freedom to state and be open to opinions.
VI. Be nice.

Avatar
Steefen
8282 Posts
(Offline)
169
October 18, 2026 - 4:36 pm

This topic is important because it touches upon, it has implications  for the discussion of White, heterosexual, Christian men of western civilization.

See YouTube Channel: Peak Prosperity
Video: Tucker Carlson: “I’m Starting to Think That Maybe This Is by Design”

** you do not have permission to see this link ** AI and the Future of Human Population
** you do not have permission to see this link ** Europe’s Demographic Contradictions

Some of the information in those to timestamps refer to the end of the world for more than a million people which would be biblical, theological, christological, and moral.

and

** you do not have permission to see this link ** Prophets, Truth and Uncomfortable History

Long-standing historical traditions and extra-biblical writings—such as the pseudepigraphal text The Ascension of Isaiah, the Babylonian Talmud, and early Christian writers (including Justin Martyr and Jerome)—state that Isaiah suffered martyrdom during the reign of wicked King Manasseh of Judah.
Key Traditional Accounts of Isaiah’s Death

  • Sawed in Two: The predominant tradition claims that Isaiah was executed by being sawn in half with a wooden saw (or a wood-saw).
  • Hiding in a Tree: Several accounts, including ** you do not have permission to see this link ** and the Talmud, state that Isaiah fled and hid inside a hollow tree (often described as a cedar or old mulberry tree) in Silwan or near Jerusalem. King Manasseh’s men discovered him, and the tree was sawn down with the prophet inside.
  • New Testament Allusion: Many biblical commentators link the phrase “they were sawn in asunder” in Hebrews 11:37 to the martyrdom of Isaiah.
  • Reason for Execution: Jewish traditions recorded in the Talmud note that King Manasseh judged and condemned Isaiah for supposedly issuing statements that contradicted the Torah (such as contrasting views on seeing God or God’s nearness).

So, Isaiah was sawed in half and Jesus was crucified. James was killed. Peter was crucified upside down.
Allegedly. 

What I label as your fourth plank is agreeable.

 

Avatar
Steefen
8282 Posts
(Offline)
170
October 18, 2026 - 4:44 pm

Tucker said pretty much if an action is producing an outcome and the action continues, then the outcome is what is desired.

In Southern Italy the worse case scenario for the diesel problem happened: grocery stores have no products.

In the United States, diesel is not only getting more expensive for truckers, truckers are having a very serious time staying in business. Food is anticipated to get more expensive. Farmer and cowboys are having trouble producing food.

I have looked at the cost of Medicare Part B premiums from 2000 – 2026. Cost have increased.

Christianity and your Christ can do what about it?

Christianity and your Christ can do what about the reduction in the need for human labor, making human labor useless eaters?

Avatar
Steefen
8282 Posts
(Offline)
171
October 18, 2026 - 4:48 pm

Like I said earlier, a value has to be affixed to “Did Jesus exist?”

I say, so what, someone made some valid points against Pharisees and scribes. There are other problems in this world, more important matters that some ancient local god and some local Christ let go too far.

1 ... 56789
Forum Timezone: America/Indiana/Indianapolis
All RSSShow Stats
Administrators:
BDEhrman
FreedomBen
evgendob
Robert
Top Posters:
Steefen: 8282
Stephen: 5058
Porphyry: 1994
DavidFord: 1929
godspell: 1827
BJH1960: 1587
brenmcg: 1184
Colin Milton: 1142
Judith: 1040
JAS: 948
Newest Members:
rdescafano
WanaxLukos
cksyno
Vilchkov
AdrianAas
Sparafugle
airymountain
Lynnzzz
Ferryheisenberg
sruemenapp
Forum Stats:
Groups: 2
Forums: 13
Topics: 2683
Posts: 50234

 

Member Stats:
Guest Posters: 65
Members: 66432
Moderators: 0
Admins: 4
Most Users Ever Online: 3559
Currently Online: Robert
Guest(s) 31
Currently Browsing this Page:
1 Guest(s)