When the new blog site launched a week ago I decided to start off with five of my favorite posts from each of the first five years of the blog.  And then someone asked me: why just the first five?  Why not the more recent four?  And I replied:  I don’t know – I didn’t think about it!   But now I have and have decided: why not?

So here is number six of five favorite posts, this one from 2017.  It’s more of a personal topic, but it’s one that I know a lot of you can resonate with: the struggle involved in moving from being a person of faith to becoming an agnostic.


I started feeling the tug toward agnosticism sometime during my Ph.D. program.  I remember clearly a particular moment, and it was, somewhat ironically, while I was serving as the pastor of the Princeton Baptist Church.

Even though I was incredibly busy at the time (I was taking a full load of graduate seminars, preparing to take my PhD exams, serving as a Teaching Assistant for a class taught by Bruce Metzger, AND serving as the pastor of the church) I enjoyed the ministry very much.  Well, parts of the ministry.  I have never enjoyed transition rituals very much:  baptisms, weddings, funerals, and the like.  And of course, pastoring a church involves doing such things.   And I wasn’t thrilled with visiting the sick – I was a bit out of my depth on that one.  But I did very much enjoy interactions with the people I worked within the church, and I especially liked preaching nearly every week.

I remember thinking at the time, though, that being actively engaged in the church was “saving my faith.”  I had the strong sense that if I didn’t have to stand in front of a congregation every week to direct worship, say prayers, preach sermons, and so on, that I would probably be moving away from my faith.  With people depending on me and looking up to me, I really couldn’t afford to think seriously about whether I still believed all this or not.  I had to believe it.  It wasn’t that I was being hypocritical.  It’s that I knew I was putting off some serious thinking about issues that were central to my life and being.

When I stopped pastoring the church (it was only a one year gig), my mind was freed up to think deeper and deeper about my faith, and I started wondering if I could keep on believing.

One of the major issues for me will be the topic of later posts: I was wondering – the most basic question of all — whether I could really believe there was any kind of God who was active in the world or not.

As I began to wonder, I felt the pull of certain forces …

It’s easy to see the rest of this post!  Join the blog.  It’s easy and cheap, and every penny you pay goes to charity.  No downside!