14 votes, average: 4.79 out of 514 votes, average: 4.79 out of 514 votes, average: 4.79 out of 514 votes, average: 4.79 out of 514 votes, average: 4.79 out of 5 (14 votes, average: 4.79 out of 5)
You need to be a registered member to rate this post.

The Value (or Not) of Debates

As most readers of the blog know, I do a good number of public debates, almost always (I’m trying to think if there is an exception!) with conservative evangelical Christians or fundamentalists who think that my views are dangerous to the good Christians of their communities and to all those non-Christians they very much want to convert.   My view all along has been that my historical views are not a threat to Christian faith, but only to a particular (and particularly narrow) understanding of that faith.   But most of my debate partners can’t see things that way.  For them, their views are Christianity, and any other kind of Christianity is not actually Christianity.

I usually look forward to these debates in advance, but I have to say that almost every time I’m actually having one, I start jotting notes to myself, asking “Why Am I Doing This?” or “Why Do I Do This To Myself?”   I often find the debates very frustrating.

I imagine my debate partners do as well.  They just can’t understand why I don’t see the truth.  Or rather, they think that because I’m a fallen creature who does not have faith (or am willful; or wicked; or rebellious) that I simply can’t see the truth that is staring me right in the eyes.

For my part I certainly don’t understand why…

THE REST OF THIS POST IS FOR MEMBERS ONLY.  If you don’t belong yet, LOOK!  It doesn’t cost much to join, you get a big bang for your buck, and every one of those bucks goes to help the needy.  So JOIN ALREADY!!!

You need to be logged in to see this part of the content. Please Login to access.

My Recitation Debates
Buy New Book & Get Any Previous HarperOne Book for 50% OFF



  1. Avatar
    amyschiwitz  March 24, 2016

    Debates can be productive sometimes. I gave up young earth creationism while watching the Nye-Hamm debate.

    Even if you only change one person’s mind, or even just plant a seed of thought into someone’s mind, I think your debates would be worthwhile.

You must be logged in to post a comment.