The big question to emerge from my previous post is: If Jesus’ disciples (or at least some of them) believed he was the messiah before he died (as I tried to show they must have done) then what would have led them to think so?
I think there are two possibilities, one of which strikes me as implausible. The implausible one, in my opinion, is that Jesus did things that the messiah was expected to do, and because of that, his followers thought he was the messiah. My reason for not being drawn to this interpretation is precisely that Jesus in fact did not do any of the things that the messiah was expected or supposed to do.
Some of my Christian students don’t get this. Doesn’t the Bible predict that…
The Rest of this Post is for Members Only. It doesn’t cost much to join — about a Starbuck’s coffee a month (NOT a decaf caramel macchiato or whatever crazy other thing people drink — just a coffee!) . And the blog will keep you so much more alert and vibrant. So JOIN!!!