Is it possible Jesus never actually died, but survived the crucifixion — and that’s why his followers could claim they saw him afterward? Because they really did?
I’ve been discussing a couple of the Gospels that have been forged in modern time either as hoaxes, or money-makers, or (usually) both. Here is one that deals with a question of Jesus faked death — an issue people occasionally ask me about still today.
This discussion is taken from the final chapter of my book Forged (Harper, 2011), slightly edited here.
******************************
Unlike some other modern forged Gospels,
If you wanted to produce a forgery that would make a real splash and had a real chance to fool Biblical experts, and assuming you had access to the necessary age-appropriate materials, what would be the text you would choose?
Do you mean what would I make it about? I suppose I would write an ending to the Gospel of Mark that would look genuine, rather than the last 12 verses added on by scribes. Or possibly a short letter of Paul’s no one had heard of.
Any evidence that the swoon theory was around in the 1st Century, and that is why the Gospel of John adds that part about Jesus being pierced with a sword, to prove he really was dead on the cross?
Interesting idea. There’s no way to know of course. But we don’t have any hints of it per se — apart I guess from this passage itself. John doesn’t indicate that the piercing was to prove Jesus had died — the soldiers had already determined it. He instead uses it for theological reasons — “blood and water” came out (as the Beloved Disciple attests) — and that is significant in some circles (1 John 5:6) since it showed that salvation through Christ comes through his death (blood) followed by water (baptism).
I read something recently about an earthquake potentially explaining parts of the resurrection myth and some scientists narrowing down the dates where Jesus could have been crucified based on that. Came across it from Christians trying to say that proved the resurrection – obviously incorrectly. I’m also thinking about the stories you mentioned about the dead being brought back to life temporarily but not leaving the tombs – which raises the issue of how anyone could know they came to life. Rather than being fully invented, do you think it’s plausible that an earthquake knocked bodies loose inside tombs, this was discovered, and early Christians assumed it was because they came to life?
It seems they would have other such earthquakes which did that – but then I just mentioned modern Christians jumping to convenient conclusions out of motivated reasoning.
No, I don’t think naturalistic explanatoins like that are generally plausible. They are almost always dreamt up to provide a more “sensible” explanation for a “miraculous” (i.e., impossible) event. Any theory like that, of course, has to be examined closely, but in part the examination involves asking what evidence there is. And in this case, there isn’t any. (The earthquake only happens in Matthew, and there it is used with a number of other signs that the death of Jesus was an “apocalyptic” event — with rocks splitting and resurrections happening, etc.). That is, it is apparently driven by a theological concern, not a historical one.
Great post, thank you!
“The narrative was then brought to Germany by the Free Masons, understood to be modern-day ancestors of the Essenes.”
As a Mason initiated into the Craft in 1989, I have never seen in all the rituals I’ve experienced, nor in all the materials I’ve studied and researched since, any reference to the Essenes being the ancestors of the Freemasons. So I’m calling BS. Big time!
Yet one more reason to do so!
“… Free Masons, understood to be modern-day ancestors of the Essenes”
This doesn’t make sense.
This seems to be an example of the very common (and baffling) modern misuse of the word “ancestors” to mean “descendants.” I’m surprised to see Dr. Ehrman make that error, but then as they say, even Homer “nods” at times.
Yup, my bad. And I certainly nod more than Homer did….
You state that the above mentioned text received monitary rewards.
Is there any evidence that the writers of the books of the New Testament, or of any of the other early Christian books would have received monitary rewards?
No, definitely not. In the ancient world, books almost never brought in any revenue. They were simply distributed.
Professor Ehrman,
Regarding the Olivet Discourse in Mark 13 and Matthew 24, it seems that the theme of the Great Tribulation and the apocalypse appears somewhat abruptly in the middle of Jesus’s ministry, which initially focused on the immediate arrival of the Kingdom of God.
Given that the Gospel of Mark was likely written around 70 CE, would it be accurate to say that the early Christian community created or heavily adapted this apocalyptic narrative directly in response to the imminent or ongoing trauma of the destruction of the Temple? In other words, was this chapter inserted primarily as a tool to preserve their identity, rationalize the catastrophe, and redefine their movement in a world without the Temple?
Yes, that is a popular view among scholars.
Reminds me of the Jesus went to India story. Dr Ehrman, do you see a moral problem with the idea that Christ abandoned Jesus on the cross? Isn’t that, kinda mean? How did separationists deal with this problem? If at all.
Those who opposed this kind of separationist Christology certainly intimate that it was not a kind thing to do….
“The narrative was then brought to Germany by the Free Masons, understood to be modern-day ancestors of the Essenes.”
Bart, this error is so common it has become a pet peeve of mine, so I’ll share in case you ever put out an updated edition (unlikely!).
Modern-day people are not ANCESTORS of people in the past.
Yup. Pet pieve of mine too.
DID JESUS SURVIVE THE CRUCIFIXION? I am 71 y.o. in the USA. That idea was circulating in 1970. During the hunting season for Whitetail Deer in the USA, a hunter fell from his tree stand and was knocked unconscious. The Game Warden (who carried a handgun) found the unconscious hunter and called 9-1-1. The 911 dispatcher asked the Game Warden, “Is the hunter dead?” The Game Warden replied, “Let me check.” The 911 dispatcher heard a gunshot. The Game Warden said, “He’s dead, now.” A similar scenario unfolded 2000 years in Jerusalem during the Passover. Instead of a bullet to the head, the Roman soldier thrust a blade under the sternum to pierce the heart. The pericardium membrane was swollen and pressurized with (separated) coagulated blood and blood plasma John 19:34. The blood plasma was mistaken for water by the witness who reported the event. Was this crucifixion victim a “doppelganger”, a body double for Jesus? An ancient Jerry Epstein scandal? Who would know? Did Jesus have powerful friends in the occupying Roman administration? What about the guarded tomb that the women found unguarded and empty? Guarded by the same Temple police who arrested Jesus days earlier. Someone is lying.
The only way Jesus could have survived the crucifixion is if the gospels accounts are not accurate….embellished for literary effect. We know the gospels have a large fictional element. Could the account of the “Passion Week” be an element that takes a bare bones knowledge and significantly “fictionalizes” it? If Jesus was scourged as severly as the gospels describe he would already have been significantly injured and weakened. That alone could have killed him. And to have a spear thrust into his chest….. But if the gospel accounts are embellished to a good extent, one can imagine Pilate and/or the Roman guard being willing to take a bribe, and Jesus not being treated nearly as roughly as described in the gospels. That the gospels describe Pilate as hesitant to crucify Jesus in the first place may be a hint of this. I think people in the past have leaned towards these “survived the cross” theories because they can explain the resurrection appearances. But these may have been largely fictionalized as well! So it seems we have to assume a fictional account in one area of the gospels to explain a likely fictional account in another area of the gospels! 😉
Martin Hengel’s book Crucifixion was published in 1977. Give it a few years to circulate and generate comments; so after 1980 at the latest any crucifixion stories, including survival of, that are not consistent with the historical evidence should be dismissed.
Jesus survives on the cross (in a physics-based hypothesis) because it is a planned event. He is telling his disciples how the plan is going to go. Hopefully.
Heuristic:
• There are 0 (zero) other religions archaeologically known to be formed from “just a street preacher.” There’s miracles workers sure, but no religion is made for them.
• There are 100s (hundreds) of religions archaeologically known to be formed from kings.
Haile Selasse, yes. Magician with opium, no.
So a claimed descendant of -King- David ( who doesn’t claim to be a descendant of Hoboth the Street Preacher) maaaay have become a king. There’s lots of little kingdoms around the Levant that the Herods like to go and become kings in.
You get a new name when you ascend. And that’s how books get commissioned in this time period, a -king-.
Maybe in Arabia that Paul goes to on being commissioned? I think Isaiah said, “the root of Jesse” will be tributed by the tribes of Nabataea and Quedar.
So, the crucifixion to me reads as a riddle. It’s good to question why there’s no body and why Mary Magdalene and others don’t recognize Jesus.