How appropriate for today, October 31!!
My one-time PhD student Travis Proctor, now teaching at Wittenberg University, and familiar to many of you because of the courses he’s taught for the Biblical Studies Academy, has started a very interesting new blog focusing on ghosts, spirits, hauntings, demons, and so on in the Bible. You may be interested in it! If so, check it out here: The Haunted Bible
I’ve asked Travis for a blog post to describe it, along with a sample post — and here it is, an introduction to The Haunted Bible and an example of what kinds of posts you’ll find on it, this one on the odd and spirit-like portrayal of God in the Garden of Eden. Here ‘tis.
******************************
Why does God lie to Adam and Eve? (Introducing The Haunted Bible)
This article reads like something I’d expect from an annotated bible. Its absolutely fascinating and counter intuitive, even though I know isn’t the correct term. I unfortunately cannot think of the correct term. My question, perhaps naive, to Professor is if there is an “Annotated Bible” in this flavour? I’m sure the effort would be Herculean and absent that journals of that genre? Thank you
I’m not quite sure what you’re asking. There are some terrific Annotated Bibles out there. My favorite remains the HarperCollins Study Bible.
I was one of those annoying, inquisitive Sunday school students who pestered hapless teachers with questions because so much of Genesis 1-4 didn’t make sense to me. Where did the Serpent come from- being intelligent and capable of reason and conversation compared to the other “beasts of the field”? He’s described as “more crafty”. Why didn’t less crafty animals like hippos talk? And if he was the Devil, why don’t we picture him as a snake instead of a mean man with horns and a pitchfork going around making people do naughty things? Is he a shape shifter? Why did God make a high- maintenance garden without thinking about who would take care of it? How would Adam know what “die” or “death” meant if it hadn’t happened before? As a teenager I wondered how Adam could be so excited about Eve at first, but it appears they didn’t have “relations” until after they were evicted from the Garden. Subsequent “relations” were noted by “again.” I had many youthful questions and so few good answers.
Hello, Chapel 19. You asked, “What about the Talking Reasoning Serpent? Was this Serpent actually the Devil? Was the Garden of Eden “high maintenance”? In my opinion, the Garden of Eden never existed. It is a Bronze Age allegory much as Aesop’s Fables. In Bronze Age Judaism, “Satan” did not exist. “Satan” entered Judaism around 500 BCE from Persia (Yazidism, Zoroasterism). Someone else wrote that the animals pelts that clothed Adam and Eve were symbols of the flesh-and-blood physical bodies. Cain and Abel would be extensions of the allegory. The glacial flood in Nepal a few months ago might be an indication that the Last Ice Age produced local catastrophic floods. In my opinion, the Garden was in the Punjab of India, and those rivers might have carried glacial floods. Have a good day.
Speaking of ghosts, Bart, you may be interested in my Halloween Blog post today at https://historyhighjackers.com. As you can see, I quote from both the first and last of your series of 11 Blog posts on the Holy Ghost published between May 5 and June 10 of 2021.
Thanks as always for your great scholarship and inspiration, Walt
Thanks!
I really enjoyed this post, Dr. Proctor! One point I’m interested to learn more on is the one about the “all-perfect, all-knowing” conceptions of God coming from later Platonic-Christian thinking. Are there particular dialogues of Plato that that are being drawn from for the idea of a perfect God, or does this relate more to later Christian authors radically reinterpreting Plato for their own purposes?
I would answer for Travis that the most important of the dialogues to this end is arguably the most difficult, the Timaeus.
Thank you for this post. It was fascinating. I have to say that the flawed nature of ‘God’ and/or the gods does appear to give credence to some of the claims of the ‘ancient aliens’ theorists. Just sayin’
Genesis 3:22 recognizes that humanity acquired a divine attribute (knowing good and evil) while remaining human. God’s warning that they would die need not be understood as an immediate biological death, but as the entrance of humanity into a state of corruption and mortality (Gen 5:5). God expels humanity from the Garden and bars access to the Tree of Life, not to protect divine privilege, but to prevent fallen humanity from living forever in a corrupted state (divine knowledge+human nature).
Humanity’s plight is that it remains earthly and subject to corruption. True restoration requires transformation, not merely immortality. The apostle Paul offers the solution through resurrection, where the earthly puts on immortality, power, imperishability, glory, and a spiritual body (1 Corinthians 15:53). Thus, Christ accomplishes what the Eden narrative anticipates. While Adam and Eve grasped at a divine attribute and inherited corruption and death, the gospel reveals that humanity ultimately shares in God’s life through union with the resurrected Christ.
Cool! Will follow the blog.
Thanks for introducing me to Travis Proctor. I signed up for his blog and look forward to reading it.
Just one more benefit from subscribing to your blog, Bart.
Was the idea that the messiah would be the judge of us when the Kingdom came unique to Christianity? Didn’t the Jewish tradition have God do that job?
If so, where did this change come from?
Yes, apocalyptic Jews believed that God would bring in the day of judgment. Some of them thought he would do so through a heavenly emissary; Jesus appears to have called that one the Son of Man (from Daniel 7:13-14). After his death, his disciples believed he had been taken into heaven and would himself come back to be the cosmic judge of the earth, both the messiah and the Son of Man. You get a comparable view in the Jewish book of 1 Enoch.
did God directly command Eve of the tree situation?
Mischievous Serpant wanted clarification.
Blank Slate
2) 1st question
Who violated Who?
God took advantage of his creation & condemned them!
Anyways how did they communicate?