If the stories about disciples of Jesus claiming (and believing) they had seen Jesus alive after his death probably go back to historical events (some of them did claim/believe that) as I argued in the previous post, what about the story of women finding the empty tomb?
I thought some readers might soon be asking me about that, so I decided to deal with it preemptively.
The issues are a bit different in this case than with the “visions.” In this case, many Christian apologists argue that “no one would have invented” the idea of women — specifically women — discovering the tomb, so … it must actually have happened.
Good argument, right? Here is what I said about it in my book How Jesus Became God.
******************************
Would Anyone Invent the Women at the Tomb?
It is often argued by Christian apologists that no one would make up the story of the discovery of the empty tomb precisely because according to these stories, it was women who found the tomb. According to this line of reasoning, women were widely thought of as untrustworthy and, in fact, their testimony could not be allowed in courts of law. According to this view, if someone wanted to invent the notion of a discovered tomb, they would be sure that it was discovered by credible witnesses, namely by the male disciples.
I used to hold this view as well, and so I see its force. But now
Leave A Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.