Bart Ehrman Blog Readers Forum

A A A
Forum Scope


Match



Forum Options



Min search length: 3 characters / Max search length: 84 characters
Lost password?
sp_TopicIcon
"Love the Lord YOUR God, not OUR God," could Jesus have inherited another God than Yahweh patrilineally?
Avatar
Serene

200 Posts
(Online)
161
September 2, 2026 - 10:11 am

Steefen said
Comment 159
Thomas Didymus and “Doubting Thomas” refer to the exact same person: the Biblical Apostle Thomas. [1, 2]

The Names of Thomas

Thomas Didymus: “Thomas” comes from an Aramaic word meaning “twin,” and “Didymus” is the Greek word (Didymos) that also means “twin”. The Gospel of John refers to him as “Thomas, called the Twin (Didymus)”.

Hi Steefen! You just made a very helpful correction. You are right that Thomas’ name origin of T’ōmā is Aramaic, not Hebrew:

Serene said

Thomas (Hebrew), Didymos (Greek)


How do we know that Jesus’ Apostles are all Jewish? 

Matthew 19:28

Jesus said to them, ‘Truly I tell you, at the renewal of all things, when the Son of Man is seated on the throne of his glory, you who have followed me will also sit on twelve thrones, judging the twelve tribes of Israel.'”

 

It has long been academic consensus that some of the 12 judges of Israelites in the Book of Judges have clearly foreign names:

Othniel, son of Kenaz is Kennizite (Edomite-Canaanite clan)

Shamgar is a Hurrian or Hittite name

Gideon has the second name of Jerubabaal, a Canaanite name

They are given Jewishness after the facto.

As we move closer to the First Century Transjordan, in 1 Maccabees 5:8 (Maccabees is non-canonical to the Hebrew Bible but canonical to the Catholic Old Testament), Aretas, the Nabataean Arab king, is portrayed as exercising judicial authority over Jason, the Jewish High Priest. Again, I think this is the “second verse, same as the first” type story of Aretas IV seeking the Jewish High Priest’s emissary Saul/Paulus in 2 Corinthians 11:32 for the events described in Galatians 1:13.

They are descriptions of actions, not formal titles, like in Matthew 19:28 and Luke 22:30

…you will sit on thrones judging the twelve tribes of Israel.

When the towns are known that Jesus recruits from, they are historically found to be markedly multi-ethnic trade nodes and border junctions (like the 7 churches of Asia in miniature.) Apostles from Bethsaida would likely have been comfortable with attesting to Jesus’ signs and works to Gentiles, including Simon renamed Peter, who has an actually Hebrew birth name.

I just think it’s interesting that the Apostle Thomas is eager to take the chance that this may violate purity laws, considering that Jesus has um, not been declared alive.

And that this apparently new Apostle may not recognize what Jesus looked like before, like in the many instances of Luke 24:13–35.

** you do not have permission to see this link ** 81.3-82.5

When he said these things, I saw him as if they were seizing him. And I said, ‘What do I see, O Lord? Is it really you whom they take? And are you holding onto me? And who is this one above the cross, who is glad and laughing? And is it another person whose feet and hands they are hammering?’

The Savior said to me, ‘He whom you see above the cross, glad and laughing, this is the living Jesus. But he into whose hands and feet they drive the nails is his physical part, which is the substitute, being put to shame, the one who came into being in his likeness. Look at him and look at me.’

When I looked, I said, ‘Lord, no one is looking at you. Let us flee this place!’ But he said to me, ‘I have told you, “Leave the blind alone!” And you, see how they do not know what they are saying. For the son of their glory, instead of my servant, they have put to shame.

Avatar
Steefen
8356 Posts
(Offline)
162
September 2, 2026 - 12:34 pm

Steefen said
Bart,
Neither the Gospel of Thomas nor the Synoptics contain Thomas’ skepticism regarding the resurrection. Those are attestations that are needed.
QUESTION: Without multiple attestation, is Thomas’ skepticism not historical or is there more to this?

** you do not have permission to see this link **
  

seahawk41 September 1, 2026 at 5:04 pm
Fascinating. Thanks for sharing!
Avatar
Steefen
8356 Posts
(Offline)
163
September 2, 2026 - 12:38 pm

Comment 161

OK. Thank you.

Avatar
Steefen
8356 Posts
(Offline)
164
September 2, 2026 - 12:39 pm

I’m going to use part of your response for the thread Jesus was not a Jew.

** you do not have permission to see this link **

Avatar
Serene

200 Posts
(Online)
165
September 3, 2026 - 9:09 pm

Zebadiah, son of 👉Ishmael 👈  Judge of Jewish People

2 Chronicles 19

See, Amariah the chief priest is over you in all matters of the Lord; and Zebadiah son of Ishmael, the governor of the house of Judah, in all the king’s matters

The Bible Gateway Cliff Notes:

A “governor of the house of Judah, in all the king’s affairs” (** you do not have permission to see this link **, [http://biblegateway/wiki/Courts, Judicial COURT OF LAW].

** you do not have permission to see this link **

My bolding. 

The Question: Could a 9th Century BCE Judean really hear or use the name Ishmael without thinking of the famous son of Hagar in Genesis?

Hint: The 9th C BCE is exactly when the Ishmaelite tribal confederation begins operating in the Transjordan, per written Assyrian records.

Folk etymology implies that this Ishmael name is just a Jewish name that doesn’t nod to any sympathy or even mixed ancestry with the Ishmaelites, and I would like to offer my finest lol. All uses of the name Ishmael in the Hebrew Bible after the Ishmael of Genesis begin appearing exactly after the Ishmaelite confederation begins operating in the Transjordan, using contemporary written records.

Specifically, the first re-appearance of the name Ishmael appears in a trade-favorable Jewish administration, right before the last use of the term Ishmaelite in a trade-unfavorable Jewish administration.

Ishmaelite is an exonym. Son of Ishmael can either be an actual son of someone named Ishmael, or follow the usual tribal endonym ” Son of [Founder] pattern. Using an “Son of Ishmael” endonym would be proper once the lineage is inside the house.

Consider the example of Doeg the Edomite:

1 Samuel 21:7
Now a certain man of the servants of Saul was there that day, detained before the Lord; his name was Doeg the Edomite, the chief of Saul’s shepherds

But the Talmud explains that the “chief of Saul’s shepherds” is a euphemism. The Talmud scholars explain that Doeg the Edomite was the highest judicial authority in the land, the head of the Sanhedrin, and the highest scholar in the Kingdom of Judah, and that the sheep were his scholars.

Caveat — the Talmud is the 2nd-5th CE trying to explain the 9th C BCE, but the scholars of the Talmud would have a wider oral history and the written records of hegemons to draw from, like that of the Babylonian Exiles.
 
Could it have been politically incorrect to acknowledge someone of lowly lineage as being higher than the Jewish people? See the justification given for King Herod the Great’s actions regarding his lineage Jewish family, that they mocked his commoner (Edomite) background.

To me this really big euphemism — from “chief herdsman” to “head of the Sanhedrin,” is the legislative body over the Jewish people, raises the possibility that lowly lineage as characterized in the Hebrew Bible, like Edomite (because it is mixed with Canaanite), or Ishmaelite (dismissed slave origin), may be less overtly acknowledged as they started to rise, whereas conqueror lineage (Egyptian, Hittite, Moabite, Ammonite and others), landed kingdom lineage, would not be.

Son of [Founder], like the Son of David:

 

Luke 18:36-37

Now hearing a crowd going by, he began to inquire what this was. They told him that Jesus of Nazareth was passing by. And he called out, saying, “Jesus, Son of David, have mercy on me!”

 

 “Sons of Aretas,” are the Banu Haritat. Mary, the mother of Jesus, is called the “Daughter of Amram” (Moses’ father) in the Quran. Or like the “Sons of Light”, in the Qumran Essene texts, Light being a personified being in Mandaean cosmology.

I think Ishmael could be the name of Zebadiah’s dad, just that for this century, and considering how tribal business operated as distinct from landed kingdom business, that this may nod at mixed lineage. Again, switching to the endonym tracks if the Ishmaelite tribal confederation intermarried with Jewish or Israelite people in the Transjordan.

Zebadiah, son of Ishmael’s administration of King Jehoshaphat (c. 870-848 BCE) was particularly known for alliance-making. Then the last time we see the word Ishmaelites used is in a closely-following administration, upset that the Ishmaelite confederacy allies across different ethnic groups (Hagar’s is Egyptian):

Psalm 83:5-6

With one mind they plot together; they form a alliance against you—the tents of Edom and the Ishmaelites, of Moab and the Hagrites…

Then with the Book of Isaiah, it shows familiarity with smaller, emerging tribal confederacies, like that led by the lineages of Nebaioth and Kedar.

** you do not have permission to see this link ** that Yosef the Salit, Ya’akov, Issachar and Benoni don’t have anything to do with the Hyksos in Egypt called Salitus, Yaqub, Sakir-har and Benon — Hebrews come get your Patriarchs.

 

Luke 22:30

so that you may eat and drink at my table in my kingdom, and you will sit on thrones judging the twelve tribes of Israel

Now let’s look at this new Apostle Thomas with the Aramaean name again. The Apostle Thomas’s insistence on touching the open wounds of someone who could be a revenant, a ghost re-animating a corpse which was a fear of the First Century Mediterranean, or even a Weekend at Bernie’s disregards purity laws, the highest level of Jewish taboos, the Second Temple ritual purity laws called Tumat Met.

Early Christian history and Syriac texts (Acts of Thomas, Gospel of Thomas) sent him to the Syriac/Aramaean world — specifically Edessa (Osroene), Nisibis, Parthia, and further east.

While Thomas could certainly be Jewish, it’s not implausible that he could be a Syriac/Aramaean sent to witness to the scattered remnants of the northern Israelite tribes. They were widely documented in ancient Jewish memory as having preserved their diaspora communities in those territories.

Avatar
Steefen
8356 Posts
(Offline)
166
September 5, 2026 - 5:06 pm

Comment 158

Bart:
I don’t think the passage in John about doubting Thomas is historical, no — if that’s your question.

Avatar
Serene

200 Posts
(Online)
167
September 6, 2026 - 5:43 pm
Whether the story in John 20:24-29 was historical or fictional, the observation is still the same — the Apostle Thomas’ eagerness to touch the ventilation holes isn’t like the way that those with Jewish names act:
 
John 20:25
But he said to them, “Unless I see the nail marks in his hands and put my finger where the nails were, and put my hand into his side, I will not believe.”
Compare: 
 
Luke 24:37
They were startled and terrified, and thought that they were seeing a ghost.
 
Matthew 14:26
But when the disciples saw him walking on the sea, they were terrified, saying, “It is a ghost!” And they cried out in fear.
John 11:39
Jesus said, “Take away the stone.” Martha, the sister of the dead man, said to him, “Lord, already there is a stench because he has been dead four days.”
This cultural taboo was again, famously exploited in the Talmudic account of Rabbi Johanan ben Zakkai’s escape from besieged Jerusalem: he was smuggled out inside a coffin because his countrymen’s intense aversion to touching or inspecting a body meant no one would open it to check.
 
Attached belatedly for reference is:
 
The Gospel of John was presumably written in Ephesus. And the mythical founder of Ephesus was claimed to be a prince from Athens, so that city was steeped in Greek myth. The myth of the revenant goes back millennia, and imo even seems to be played to in this particular Gospel, with the period of four days in re-animating Lazarus.
 
** you do not have permission to see this link ** and date to the Neolithic period (c. 4500–3900/3800).
And so I remain open to the possibility that one or more of the 12 Apostles could be multi-cultural. Not only because that is my hypothesis for Jesus, but also because serving as judges over Israelite tribes (as the Apostles are promised to become) has historically accommodated ethnically-varied backgrounds.
 
Edit: The Apostle Thomas is given a Jewish first name in the Peshitta and the Acts of Thomas, as ‘Jude Thomas’, and as ‘Jude Thomas Didymos’ in the Gospel of Thomas, which would rule out being completely foreign, but not multi-cultural.
Avatar
Serene

200 Posts
(Online)
168
September 12, 2026 - 4:03 pm

I’ve split my follow-up comment on potential multi-culturalism in the Gospels and copied part of it here, because it explores the circa-Davidic kingdom era to compare it to Jesus‘ time:

What’s really exciting today is finding an academic study discussing the Talmud’s consensus take that titles like chief ‘herder’ and ‘shepherd’ were euphemisms for high placement in government:

** you do not have permission to see this link **, Shawn Zelig Aster, Journal of Biblical Literature

1 Samuel 21:7

Now a certain man of the servants of Saul was there that day, detained before the LORD; his name was Doeg the Edomite, the chief of Saul’s shepherds.

** you do not have permission to see this link ** on Doeg’s knowledge of Torah:  

While the modern scholar, Shawn Zelig Aster concludes that shepherd in Doeg’s context was likely a title for a military commander. The use of a euphemism, shepherd (of people) for Doeg, imo could be because Doeg is an Edomite that is not related to the Jewish people.

King David’s sister Abigail was even married to an Ishmaelite, and he places his nephew Amasa as commander of the United Monarchy army:

1 Chronicles 2:17

Abigail bore Amasa, and the father of Amasa was Jether the Ishmaelite.

** you do not have permission to see this link **

King David says this to Amasa in 2 Samuel 19:13

And say to Amasa, ‘Are you not my bone and my flesh? So may God do to me, and more, if you are not the commander of my army from now on, in place of Joab.”

A son of an Ishmaelite is King David’s bone and flesh. King Solomon even avenges this patrilineally Ishmaelite family member, Amasa. King David is the king in the Hebrew Bible that explicitly has Ishmaelite and Hagarite officials, peoples who become known as Arabs. Like-wise, the Book of Isaiah, the single-most quoted Hebrew text in the New Testament and again, nicknamed the ‘Fifth Gospel’ for how often this text was present among the early Jesus movement, highlights Arab Kedar, Nebaioth, Midian, and Sela as essential participants in the messianic restoration (Isaiah 42:11, 60:6–7).

Then there is King David’s innovation of dual High Priests, and his appointment of Zadok, which many biblical scholars interpret through the Jebusite Hypothesis. By elevating a priest whose name root matches pre-Israelite Jerusalem priest-kings like Melchizedek and Adonizedek, King David makes a classic move of multi-cultural statecraft.

Many scholars also perceive Zadok’s post-exilic literary assignment of a pristine Aaronid lineage (once this lineage becomes a mandatory requirement in Ezra 2:62) as an instance of fictive kinship — the common Ancient Near East practice of informal adoption into a royal house that became codified over time.

Could it become codified without an informal adoption in the actual time period, or the “over time” part?  When according to Josephus, King Herod the Great’s close friend and biographer Nicolaus of Damascus tries to retroactively supply a royal Jewish background for him, even that great friend of the Herodian dynasty, Josephus, mouthes a silent whomp whomp:

Nicolaus of Damascus says that Antipas [Herod’s grandfather] was of the stock of the principal Jews who came out of Babylon into Judea. But this he said merely to gratify Herod and his son, who was king of Judea after him… for Herod was an Idumean by birth.”

— Josephus, Antiquities of the Jews, 14.1.3

So I wonder if new types of names in the Bible may not always be simply just the result of updated customs, or civic aliases in the lingua franca; I wonder if sometimes new types of names points to multi-culturalism.

And like the ANE “shepherd” title for king, including tribal king, that per Talmud becomes creatively utilized for a subordinate in a multi-tribal confederacy, I wonder if something like the traditional ANE practice of fictive kinship adoption is being described in the Gospels.

Avatar
Serene

200 Posts
(Online)
169
September 14, 2026 - 7:39 pm

Rejoice!

On Apostle Paul writing to the Philippians (the “Epistle of Joy”) during Greece’s first Living God drought in almost 400 years — and the potential encodement of names.

For the other gods are either far away, or they do not have ears, or they do not exist, or do not take any notice of us, but you we can see present here; you are not made of wood or stone, you are real.

— part of a hymn to King Demetrios of Athens, 291 BCE in** you do not have permission to see this link **, by Angelos Chaniotis, Oxford, 2003

As far as I know, there is not a single historical record in the ancient Mediterranean or Near Eastern world of a poor, non-elite person being legally declared or worshipped as a “God” (Theos) or “Son of God” (Theou Huios). Zero. It was an exclusive legal instrument of imperial statecraft.

Not even the very cool Hanina ben Dosa in the 1st century CE — a Galilean charismatic contemporary of early Christians. Rabbinic tradition (b. Berakhot 17b) records that a divine voice (Bat Kol) declared daily:

The whole world is sustained for the sake of My son Hanina, yet My son Hanina is satisfied with a basket of carobs from one Sabbath eve to the next.”

A divine voice calls him “my son,” and yet no religion or even sect sprouts from Hanina ben Dosa. Hanina has no happy hymn, and he’s good at being content with carob. That is because the Son of God is a title.

Assyriologist Dr. Simo Parpola claims to decode Hebrew Bible texts using alphabetic ciphers like ** you do not have permission to see this link **, 2022) analyzes the New Testament for alphabetic ciphers, he claims it yields an overriding word, “King.”

As I’ve written before, I think this might tie directly to Nabataean King Malichus II, whose name literally means “King” (MLK). We do have records of Jewish figures ruling in other kingdoms, right? Like ** you do not have permission to see this link ** (41-48 CE.)

• The abjad form MLK is written in the Aramaic portion of the tri-lingual Titulus: Jesus, King (MLK) of the Jews

• Christ, meaning “the anointed one,” is a direct legal descriptor for a rightful king

• Malichus (root meaning “King”) shares the exact Semitic root with Malchus in John 18:10

As I’ve written before, I think that the use of the name Malchus in John 18:10 could be an impressive code-talker style of cypher with a Transjordan influence, as part of the New Testament’s already-acknowledged literary syncretism.

Mapping the Gospel of John’s Greco-Roman bios onto the originally pre-Islamic Arabian poetry style called the Qasidah, the name Malchus seems to appear at the exact takhallus — the pivot where the name of the author or patron is cleverly embedded, sometimes using a root meaning or homonym. For the Qasidah, it’s traditionally embedded between parts one and two:

Part one, Nasib: Elegiac reminiscence of a person and place now gone

Part two, Rahil: The hero’s challenging journey or trial/ordeal

Part three, Madh/Fakhr: Postscript of intense praise

There’s no alphabetic cipher in this technique, the encodement is just in embedding a name creatively. So I thought to myself: “I wonder if anyone has looked at Paul’s letters for names?”

~400 Years of God-King Tradition in Greece

Though deified kingship goes back millennia, in the Greco-Roman world that Paul addresses at Philippi, Alexander the Great (4th C. BCE) was the first Greco-Roman king to accept honors as the Living Image of Zeus-Ammon in Egypt —bridging Greece (Zeus) and Egypt (Ammon). His successors, both Seleucids and Ptolemies, kept the living ruler cult alive across the Mediterranean under the official title ⁠Theos Epiphanes⁠ (“God Manifest”).

When empire continues to drift west, Julius Caesar’s stone inscriptions hail him as God Manifest in the Greek East — but never within Rome itself. To Roman elites already accustomed to water-to-wine temple automata, medicated ointments, and signaling towers delivering good news from above, the Emperor was simply a First Citizen.

Culture keeps traveling west, and finally a Roman Emperor, Gaius Germanicus (37-41 CE) declares himself a living God in Rome. Interestingly, the instances where a Roman Emperor sought living divine honors — Julius Caesar, Gaius, Nero, and Domitian basically bookend the event timeline of the New Testament. 

The rumors surrounding Gaius Germanicus, nicknamed Caligula, are gross, and it’s also reasonable to note that the rumors and his treatment seem to be not totally dissimilar to the rumors and treatment purported to be received by early Christians in Rome, so I take that with a grain of salt the size of a big thing. Or maybe he got the ring of power problem. 

** you do not have permission to see this link **

The Epistle to the Philippians  The Epistle to the Phillipians was written to a colony of retired Roman army veterans in Greece (Colonia Augusta Iulia Philippensis). Gaius Germanicus had been immensely popular among military veterans. Gaius was the son of Germanicus — the most beloved military commander among Roman legionaries — and Gaius immediately endeared himself to veterans by doubling military donatives and honoring military wills upon taking power. In fact, Gaius’ affectionate nickname, “booties” had been given to him by his father’s soldiers when he accompanied them on campaigns when he was a toddler, wearing a little soldier’s uniform that his mother made for him, including miniature military boots known as caligae. There may be a few pro-Gaius holdouts here, is what I’m saying.

The Latin name Gaius derives directly from gaudere, meaning “to rejoice” or “be glad.” In this brief letter to Roman veterans, Paul repeats the word “Rejoice!” (chairō /chara) an astounding 19 times. I think that because they are in Greece, which celebrated God-Kings, like with the hymn above, for ~400 years until Rome put it on pause right at that time, and because Gaius was the reason that they were living the good life in military retirement, that Paul may be appealing to fellow divine human appreciators for help here.

Roman state prisons did not supply food, clothing, or legal representation — the Philippians sent Epaphroditus with financial contributions (Phil 4:14–18), funding Paul’s legal counsel, paying off prison guards for better conditions (custodia libera), and securing scribal materials.

As citizens of a Roman colonia holding ius Italicum (the highest tier of legal privilege outside Italy), Philippian elites had direct access to Roman courts to submit formal legal petitions (libelli) or sponsor Paul as legal patrons (patroni). And retired senior centurions maintained active correspondence networks with serving officers, provincial clerks, and imperial freedmen along the Via Egnatia trade route, allowing them to exert back-channel influence on provincial governors.

Wishing everything turns out ok, Paul.

Avatar
Serene

200 Posts
(Online)
170
September 16, 2026 - 9:29 am

The Book of Revelation — could it be using a composite literature technique to highlight large-scale efforts to help Jewish refugees?

** you do not have permission to see this link ** agree that:

The Book of Revelation reflects the heavy shadow of the First Jewish-Roman War (66–70 CE) and Rome’s subsequent militaristic propaganda.

So would it be helpful to look at this exact historical period, and see if there are any traces of the historical large-scale charity efforts of the nearest kingdom that is known to be receiving the Jewish refugees? There are two kings involved. If you’ve been reading this thread, you’ll likely know who I’ll mention.  I think it’s very likely that in Revelation they are being presented as a loose composite.

It is academic consensus that in Near Eastern scribal tradition, compressing a multi-generational dynastic arc into a single composite figure was a standard literary strategy. It was often used to preserve political continuity during times of imperial collapse.

For example, scholars generally believe that the Book of Daniel contains several historical actions of Nebuchadnezzer’s lesser-known son Nabonidus attributed to Nebuchadnezzer in it.

Ancient Near Eastern Literary Antecedents:

Sumero-Akkadian Royal Epics: The Sargon Legend and the Cuthean Legend of Naram-Sin fused the separate military campaigns, rebellions, and legal decrees of multiple Old Akkadian rulers into a single archetypal “Sargon” or “Naram-Sin.” Scribes used this composite shorthand to create a unified legal precedent for royal authority.

Dynastic Telescoping Mesopotamian scribal historiography — seen in the Sumerian King List and later Aramaic apocalyptic literature (such as the four-headed beasts and composite statues in the Book of Daniel) — routinely collapsed entire royal lineages into one emblematic figure who embodied the state’s complete lifecycle.

Nimrod in Genesis

Scholars claim that Genesis 10 constructs Nimrod as a single primordial ruler out of historical fragments from several Mesopotamian kings (including Ninurta, Tukulti-Ninurta I, and Sargon II), attributing the dynasty to the recognizable or representative name.

Revelation 19:16

16 On his robe and on his thigh he has a name inscribed, “King of kings and Lord of lords.”

It just sounds compositey. Robe and thigh, King of kings and Lord of lords.

Malichus and Rabbel? Is that you?

During the period that scholars commonly ascribe to the Book of Revelation, Nabataean Kings Malichus II (40-70 CE) and Rabbel II (70-106 CE) are the father and son duo that send auxillary troops and take in a large group of refugees from the first Jewish-Roman War. Their names work out to King and Lord God Savior, respectively, and I think it’s worth exploring, at the least, to see if their good works may be discussed in Revelation.

Babatha of the well-known book ** you do not have permission to see this link ** , 2017, by Philip Oxler, Oxford University Press, is one such Jewish person found in the Nabataean kingdom of this period, and her extensive rights there as a Jewish woman are often positively noted by modern scholars.

Revelation 12:6

…and the woman fled into the wilderness, where she has a place prepared by God, so that there she can be nourished for twelve hundred sixty days.”

Malichus is written MLK, and, Jesus Christ happens to be written as Yesu MLK in the Peshitta.

This reminds me of Thomas Didymos or other dual names that include a civic alias. So, it’s not a totally ridiculous idea to check out at least, I hope. It doesn’t take away from any possibility of miracles I think, I think it increases that possibility, and I happen to love the historical archaeological evidence for the mobilization of resources for the refugee people that really saved them from what happened to those that stayed in Jerusalem.

• Malichus II (MLK, meaning ‘King’)

Governed during the buildup and outbreak of the First Jewish-Roman War. Supplied 6,000 peace-keeping units in 70 AD; I use ‘peace-keeping’ because if you can take away anything from the First Century historians, it is that Nabataeans try everything first before conflict, but it’s just the times.

He is Nabataea’s first client king of Rome, installed by Agrippa’s best friend, Gaius Booties. Gaius The Living God Booties installed Agrippa too, something to think about when reading this fun quote:

Acts 26:28

Then Agrippa said to Paul, “Do you think that in such a short time you can persuade me to be a Christian?

He already believes in this stuff, Paul! Sell him the best eternal life tomb in Hegra!

• Rabbel II Soter (Rabb-El Soter working out to ‘Lord God Savior’)

Earned his official royal epithet, ‘nyf-dy hyyy w-šyzb ‘m-h “He who brought life and deliverance to his people” by pivoting the state’s economy away from the ending southern merchant route due to Roman action and into massive water harvesting, fruit tree planting, and grain-growing expansion in the Hauran (Auranitis).

Revelation 18:11-13

And the merchants of the earth weep and mourn for her, since no one buys their cargo anymore, cargo of gold, silver… cinnamon, spice, incense, myrrh, frankincense, wine, olive oil, fine flour and wheat…”

Reads like an itemized Nabataean customs ledger (they were also famous for gold and silver). And like the Nabaioth-led (Nabataean-led per Josephus) caravan products in Isaiah 60:6-7. Matthew 2:11, too.

So, it is Rabbel II Soter that moved the Nabataean kingdom capital from Petra to Bostra in the Hauran/Auranitis behind the neutral Decapolis city of Pella, ie having a chronological overlap with the Flight to Pella.

The Mountains

Auranitis’ mountains were famous for Nabataean wine production. Auranitis traditionally had been under Nabataean hegemony, but the matrilineally-Nabataean Herodian Dynasty, by the time of Jesus, controlled part of it for a moment under Herod Phillip. Herod Phillip’s Trachonitis is mentioned in the Gospel of Luke.

As scholars date the story in Josephus‘ AJ 18.5, by 36 CE the war against Herod Antipas of Galilee-Peraea and Herod Phillip of Trachonitis, sparked in the breaking of a marital alliance, will be won. Phillip’s own troops had been persuaded to turn against the fight, again per Josephus. I’ve written before that I think that the Parable of the Tenants is written about the Jewish estates in Trachonitis:

The Parable of the Tenants

9 He went on to tell the people this parable: “A man planted a vineyard, rented it to some farmers and went away for a long time…[stuff]

13 “Then the owner of the vineyard said, ‘What shall I do? I will send my son, whom I love; perhaps they will respect him.’…[stuff]

19 The teachers of the law and the chief priests looked for a way to arrest him immediately, because they knew he had spoken this parable against them.

I added [stuff].

So that’s the wine. The fertile plains of Auranitis supplied the grain, you might even say the Bread of Life considering Rabbel Soter’s epithet, “he who brought life…”

The Refuge

The Auranitis plains are bordered by The Lajat, which in Arabic means The Refuge or The Asylum, a lava tube field long known for being a successful place of refuge for the Jewish people. This whole greater region was the presupposed area of the Israelite lost tribes even.

Revelation 22:1-2

Then the angel showed me the river of the water of life, bright as crystal, flowing from the throne of God and of the Lamb through the middle of the street of the city. On either side of the river is the tree of life with its twelve kinds of fruit, yielding its fruit each month…”

Rabbel II Soter built massive stone aqueducts and planted fruit orchards alongside them in the new Nabataean capital build-out of Bostra. And The Nabataean Agriculture, a much later, 10th C CE  work purporting to work from an original document dated to roughly Sargon of Akkad, that historians feel has desert additions, and written in a flavor of Mesopotamian mysticism that Enochian literature enthusiasts would find familiar. devotes about a third of the book to unusual and delightful fruit tree ** you do not have permission to see this link **.

The Haraun is also what most scholars believe is being described in the Inner Hawran. The refuge place of Jewish Mandaeans (John the Baptist’s followers) first escaping Jerusalem pre and post the first Jewish-Roman war,  returning to the area around the world’s first water ablution temple of Eridu, which was on the lagion system of modern Nasoriyah. The Inner Hawran is also known as** you do not have permission to see this link **

Comparing The Book of Revelation to The Scroll of Great Revelation

Let’s see where The Scroll of Great Revelation thinks the Jewish refugees went to:👇

joineth to himself a people, and they are called Christians.

… and from Nisrat (Nazareth), a city of the Jews, which is called the city of Qum …

… because it is a shrine ; for Mercury founded a community in Qum, and Saturn founded a community in Sinai… …Jews were settled) in the Arab region which is called Basra, which is (also) called Sufat-Zaba …

👆Jews were settled in the Arab region which is called Basra

Bostra is acknowledged as this Basra/Bozrah, it’s just a Mandaean spelling variant.

Sufat-Zuba is Mandaean for the adjoining marshes. (Saturn imo might be Aretas, whose rough-and-tough epithet is Lover of His People?) Sinai is again, thought by some credible archaeologists to be the mountain at the entrance of Petra in Arabia. So does Paul, apparently:

Galatians 4:25

Now Hagar stands for Mount Sinai in Arabia…

Mount Sinai is where theThe Scroll of Great Revelation says that Jesus was ruling from.

So there are both early Christian (Eusebius and Epiphanius) and Mandaean traditions saying that Jewish refugees went to the general area (Pella is against Bostra, this counts as the general area) that is the new capital city of Rabbel II Soter, he who brings life and deliverance to his people. Building up a city when there’s a new influx of people makes sense.

Bostra even had a thriving “fortified” Jewish synagogue that is discussed several times in the Talmud, that a Galilean rabbi oversaw: ** you do not have permission to see this link **

And it’s not just the Hauran. By the time of Rabbel II Soter, in some areas of rock graffiti surrounding Petra, it rises to an average of six Jewish names to a Nabataean one.

Petra is acquired in 106 CE. By the early second century, the newly-discovered underground Christian city of Midyat, a city of 70,000 people at its greatest, will be within or near the ethnically-Nabataean Abgarid Osroene Kingdom’s borders, and interestingly, Midyat also had a Jewish prayer room, which is very cool.

Osroene, capital Edessa — a location of the trending Nabu “Lord of Love” religion, home to Gnostic Christianity, home to one of the world’s first, if not the first universities, said to be the first nation to consider making Christianity its official religion, and also people like Bardasain held to some pretty physics-based viewpoints.

Historians attribute the greatest geographical reach of the Nabataean kingdom to Aretas IV, and the treasury spend-down on Malichus and Rabbel Soter, but considering what they spent it on, whether their stories are similar to, or even helped inspire the Book of Revelation or not, they are my heroes.

How do you create a religion? You merit it.

Avatar
Serene

200 Posts
(Online)
171
September 17, 2026 - 5:27 pm

Who Is the Little Lamb in the Book of Revelation?

🎼Mary, had a Little Lamb, Little Lamb, Little Lamb, Mary had a Little Lamb whose fleece was white as snow” 🎶

When the Little Lamb is introduced in Revelation 5:6, it’s emphasized that he extra little:

…Little Lamb, looking as if it had been slain.

Someone give the Little Lamb some electrolytes. But wait, isn’t your English translation just “Lamb”?

Yes, why does the NRSVUE and other English translations use “Lamb,” even though Strong’s Concordance and Greek Interlinear Bibles show you that this a different word — a diminutive “arnion” which is described as little lamb, or lambkin, and not “amnos” lamb?

** you do not have permission to see this link **

The New Testament uses that different word, arnion, little lamb, 29 times in Revelation and 1 time in the Gospel of John, where Jesus is talking affectionately about his own followers, and not himself. When John the Baptist announces Jesus, he uses the standard noun, amnos, for a sacrificial sheep:

John 1:29

…”Behold, the Lamb of God!…”

Levitical law requires sheep to be grown at least a year for sacrifice, and that is known as a grown lamb, and not a little lamb or lambkin.

Neither does Revelation 5:6 make that allusion — it’s as if it appeared to be, as if slain. As if, the revolving joke of Wayne’s World.

🎼Mary, had a Little Lamb, Little Lamb, Little Lamb, Mary had a Little Lamb whose fleece was white as snow”

The Expectation

In Revelation 5:5, John weeps because no one can open the sealed scroll. An elder tells him,

…Do not weep. See, the Lion of the tribe of Judah, the Root of David, has conquered, so that he can open the scroll and its seven seals.”

Ok that makes sense — Jesus Christ in Revelation calls himself the root of David — so the Lion is Jesus. 

The Subversion

In Revelation 5:6, John turns expecting to see a military leader (the Lion) but what he actually sees standing in the center of the throne is a

…a Little Lamb, looking as if it had been slain.” 

A lamb, but make it littler.

Isaiah 11:6

…And a little child shall lead them.

Well, the Nabataean King Malichus II left a lil baby King Rabbel on the throne when he dearly departed in 70 CE, the year that Nabataea’s auxillary forces were sent in the First Jewish-Roman War.

In Aramaic, the primary administrative language of the area, the term for “little lamb” is ’talya (טַלְיָא), a polysemic noun that simultaneously means “child”, “boy,” or “young heir.”

Little lamb was a synonym for a child heir.

Scholars such as Theodor Zahn and David Aune have demonstrated that the seven-sealed scroll in Revelation mirrors a Roman client-king’s testamentum (will) — a document sealed with seven witness seals that could only be unsealed upon the ruler’s death to execute its military and dynastic clauses. Malichus happens to be a Roman client king. Mandaean texts happen to call Jesus a Roman.

Together, God and Lambkin share one throne in Revelation 22:1 and 22:3. The Apostle Thomas calls Jesus, ‘God’ in the Gospel of John, so could Jesus be God here in Revelation’s Christology?

John 20:28

Thomas answered him, “My Lord and my God!”

The Political Transmigration of the Royal Soul

In ANE divine kingship (such as the Egyptian royal Ka or Syrian Ba’al-kingship), the individual monarch was merely the temporary vessel for the eternal royal spirit.

While the Nabataean kingdom is inarguably the historian’s go-to for most syncretic, in the syncretic environment of 1st-century Syria, the Decapolis, and Phoenicia, Orphic and Pythagorean concepts of soul transmigration (metempsychosis) shaped how eastern provinces viewed their rulers. Eastern client-monarchs routinely adopted divine epithets (such as Epiphanes or Neos Dionysos) to signal that the predecessor’s divine royal principle had manifested anew in the young successor.

But what about among First Century Jewish people? In his 2024 webinar ** you do not have permission to see this link **Dr. Ehrman confirmed that the idea of soul transmigration, and not just resurrection, is present in the Gospels, like John 9:2, and Matthew 14:2.

Breaking the seal is only accessible to one who is “worthy”

** you do not have permission to see this link **, Gad Barnea, 2024

On early Nabataean silver coins, the child-king Rabbel II appears alongside his mother, Queen Shaqilat II, who served as regent. The Semitic root of her name — Š-Q-L — literally means “to weigh,” “to measure value,” or “to be worthy” (the root of the currency unit shekel).

The themes of being weighed, measured, and found worthy (axios) saturate the heavenly court scene in Revelation 4–5.

Revelation 4:11

You are worthy our Lord and God to receive glory and honor and power…

It’s like Eats, Shoots, and Leaves up in here. Worthy, Our Lord, and God receiving glory and honor and power.

In my original hypothesis, Revelation introduces a third royal investiture:

• Jewish — Herod Antipas, Sanhedrin, shining robe

• Roman — Pontius Pilate, soldier acclaim, red/purple robe

• Northwest Arabian — God, a Mesopotamianized composite of four living creatures (lamassu), and a council of 24 tribal elders (presbyteroi) gathering at what seems to be an open-air high place. The Hebrew Bible tells me there’s 12 tribes of Israel and 12 tribes of Ishmael, do what you will with that information.

Revelation 14:1

And I looked and behold the Little Lamb was standing upon Mount Zion and with him an hundred forty and four thousand

Wait, isn’t Mount Zion in Jerusalem?

In the Hebrew Masoretic Text, Deuteronomy 4:48 names Mount Hermon as Sī’ōn (שִׂיאֹן), distinct from Jerusalem’s Ṣīyyōn (צִיּוֹן) that English translators translate as Zion, with the ‘Z’. But in the Koine Greek of the Septuagint and Revelation, both are the exact same word, Siōn (Σιών). 

English translators take editorial liberties here with Siōn, just as they do with arnion. 

Wordplay is a core feature of the apocalyptic literature genre, and it would make little logistical sense for 144,000 people to seek safety within the ruins of Jerusalem, which is the overwhelming academic consensus for the great city described in Revelation 11:8.

…the great city that is prophetically called Sodom and Egypt, where also their Lord was crucified.

Mount Siōn/Mount Hermon was at one point under direct Nabataean authority, but during the First Great Jewish War was administered by part-Nabataean Herod Agrippa II, while the local population were mainly Aramaean-Arab Ituraeans who wrote with a modified Nabataean script. In other words, a Jewish-Arab mixed population was already a reality there. 

The Hauran plateau was the breadbasket of the Levant. Rabbel II and his mom, Queen Shaqilat, focused their reign on constructing massive agricultural expansion, serviced by new reservoirs, dams, and irrigation networks. Their new northern capital at Bostra hosted a thriving, diverse population, including a large Jewish community with an active synagogue important enough to be consulted by Galilean rabbis, per Shabbat 29b.

On Rabbel’s Aramaic inscriptions and coins, he adopted the regnal title Rabbel Malka, M’ḥyv v-Shyzb ‘Mheh, “King Rabbel, Who Brought Life and Deliverance To His People”. M’ḥyv, which also reads “life-giver,” is the same honorific as that of Nabataea’s supreme deity, Dushara, imparting a degree of divine identity to Rabbel. But the second half of his epithet, “Who Brings Deliverance To His People,” was rendered into Koine Greek on his coins simply as Soter (“Savior”).

Rabbel’s father Malichus II never received a savior coin. Even Augustus’s imperial birth announcements (evangelia) were kept to civic monumental decrees rather than coinage. In the Ancient Near East, while court poets and prophets might proclaim a royal heir a savior at their birth, much like the natal announcements of gospel tradition, the title Soter was ultimately sealed by public acclaim of large-scale relief. By providing water, grain, and sanctuary when Jerusalem was no more, Rabbel’s people, including Jewish people, acclaimed this former child heir as their Savior.

Reading Comprehension is a Gift 🌠 all copyright me 2026

Avatar
Serene

200 Posts
(Online)
172
September 24, 2026 - 2:22 am

Serene Decodes Revelation

In my original hypothesis, Revelation simply uses the symbols of the Babylonian, Persian, Egyptian, and Roman empires for auxiliary kings 

• Babylonian tetramorph guardians (Rev 4:7)

• Achaemenid color-coded horse patrols (Rev 6:2–8)

• Theban execration titles, like Death (Rev 6:8) and Destroyer (Rev 9:11)

• Rome’s White, Red, Blue-Black, and Green Imperial Circus horse-racing divisions that drew heavily from the auxiliary kingdoms (Rev 6:2, 4, 5, 8)

Those four horsemen of Rome’s Imperial Circus are well-attested for the 1st century in texts. A 3rd century mosaic of Rome’s four horsemen is linked ** you do not have permission to see this link **

In the 1st century world that produced Revelation, metalepsis (now called ** you do not have permission to see this link **), compressing multiple interlocking symbolic systems into a single dense image, was the gold standard of high literary and scribal genius.

Slight lexical flexing, like mapping Roman Circus venetus (deep indigo/blue-black) onto melas (black) to lock into Achaemenid black saddlecloths and Emesan black basalt was standard scribal craft in the pursuit of a deeper meaning. (For example, the blue horse of Rome’s four horsemen looks black, and its type of blue was also tied to words connected with black, like “dark.”) Apocalyptic literature is especially known to use multivalent symbols to comment on sensitive political events, and so my position is that Revelation is a text spanning from Nero to Domitian that comments on real-world events.

In my hypothesis, Revelation’s Four Horsemen are simply the four auxiliaries of the First Jewish-Roman War, as documented by Josephus:

1. White Horse — Malichus II

2. Red Horse — Agrippa II

3. Black Horse — Sohaemus

4. Pale Green Horse — Antiochus IV of Commagene

There were also a considerable number of auxiliaries got together, that came from the Kings Antiochus and Agrippa, and Sohemus, each of them contributing one thousand footmen that were archers, and a thousand horsemen. Malchus also, the king of Arabia, sent a thousand horsemen, besides five thousand footmen, the greatest part of which were archers…

— Flavius Josephus, ** you do not have permission to see this link ** 3.4.2 (3.68–69). My bolding.

1, 2, 3, 4 👆

The auxiliary leaders rode horses. The colors would also correspond to horse saddlecloths (ephippia) in the four classic Near Eastern dye colors (undyed white, madder red, iron-black, and weld-woad pale green) that were not reserved for the imperial core (purple, hyacinth-blue, and gold) as a metaphor.

This creates four. sturdy. checksums.

Each detail of Revelation’s four horsemen must match Josephus’ four horsemen in the semiotic systems of four empires, and cannot be swapped with any of the other auxiliary horsemen.

Revelation 2:17’s white stone with writing, and Zechariah 3:9’s engraved stone, is the semiotic key

Zechariah’s empire is the Achaemenid empire. Darius I’s Susa Foundation Charter (DSf, c. 520 BCE) — inscribed in the exact decade that Zechariah wrote — identifies several regions with their stones, making an engraved stone (Zech 3:9) followed by colored horse patrols (Zech 6:2–3) standard Achaemenid imperial cartography.

Traditional commentators assume that Revelation’s colored horses borrow from Zechariah’s colored horses (Zechariah 6:2-3) as floating literary symbols. Yet commentators widely recognize that Zechariah (c. 520 BCE) drew from Darius I’s Achaemenid imperial patrol network (angarioi). The Achaemenid horse patrols, like Rome’s, relied on auxiliaries, and their saddlecloths are preserved intact in the frozen ** you do not have permission to see this link ** and carved at Persepolis.

Because the Achaemenids connected stone with region and were known for their horse patrols, I examined whether Zechariah’s horse colors might be representative of the stone color of the auxiliaries’ patrilineal homeland, as best recognized by use in their ancestor cults.

Zechariah’s colored horses match the unique stone profiles of the auxiliary regions under the Achaemenids in the “four corners”:

Zechariah’s colored horses and Achaemenid auxiliary regions

🔴🐴🐴 Zechariah’s red horses

• Idumaea

• Red sandstone

• West (the horses that don’t leave; so in a four-corners model, they’d be West which also matches Achaemenid reach)

⚫️🐴🐴 Zechariah’s black horses

• Syria, location of Emesa

• Black basalt

• North

⚪️🐴🐴 Zechariah’s white horses

• the “-enes” area that becomes Adiabene and Osroene (upper Euphrates and Mesopotamian royal highway)

• East (northeast specifically, and that’s why the white horses follow the black horses’ direction, then dip out. They have to take the north road first)

🏁 🐴🐴 Zechariah’s speckled/dappled horses

(“speckled strong,” beruddim amutzim in the Masoretic; “piebald,” literally “starling-spotted,” poikiloi psaroi, in the Septuagint; “dappled gray” in the NRSVUE)

• Arabian Egyptian Desert 

• Speckled granite (The Land of Goshen of Arabia/Avaris, being on a stoneless river plain, barged in their poikiloi granite monuments. Strabo in his Geog. 17.1.45 uses poikilos for their variegated granodiorite and porphyry stone, which Pliny in his Natural History 36.11 calls “fiery-dappled” pyrropoecilus and “white-speckled” leptopsephos.)

• South

If you weren’t getting the significance that Jesus also places on stone and the records carved into it (Luke 19:40), you should be getting it by now. Rather than inventing random woo, Revelation uses antiquarian Mesopotamian concepts (per Dr. Robin Baker in ** you do not have permission to see this link **, 2022) to reboot religion. It updates a ~600-year-old Near Eastern imperial reconnaissance code to the subsequent empire: Rome.

Six whole centuries after Zechariah, imperial power shifted northwest from Persepolis to Rome. This locks Egypt (Zechariah’s speckled/dappled horses heading south) entirely inside the Roman empire, meaning that Arabian Egypt can no longer be an auxiliary. And, this shift from Eastern Empire to Western Empire also removes the white limestone “-enes” like Adiabene and Osroene (Zechariah’s white horses heading north/northeast) who break free from Parthia, but stay apart from Rome. This is replaced by the light-green stone “-ene” region of Commagene that joins Rome, and becomes their northern auxiliary in the ANE.

History does not repeat, but it does rhyme. The over half-millennium shift from That Empire to This Empire has a syncretic replacement for both Arabian Egypt and white limestone (like that of Osroene, whose dynasty was ethnically Arab Nabataean), and that is Arab Nabataea proper, with its prominent veneration of the Egyptian goddess Isis and its white limestone ancestor cult of Obodat. 

How do four auxiliaries become four horsemen?

When the Jesus movement tries to transmit knowledge to simple folk, they turn it into simple stories:

1. ⚪️🐴 White Horse — Malichus II

Revelation 6:2

I looked, and there was a white horse! Its rider had a bow; a crown was given to him, and he came out conquering and to conquer.

In Revelation 6:2, the rider on the White Horse holds a composite bow τόξον (toxon). Similarly, Josephus singles out Malichus/Malchus’ troops as having by far the greatest amount of bowmen τοξόται (toxotai). Every auxiliary has archers, but if there was one auxiliary that would be most emblematic of the bow, it would easily be the Arabian one. Romans never wielded the bow; instead, specialized archers were recruited from the East, like the Ituraean Arabs of the Ala I Augusta Ituraeorum and the Cohors I Ituraeorum sagittariorum equitata milliaria. It is because Ituraean Arab archers entered the Roman administrative record that we have granular detail regarding Arab archers:

…at the beginning of the 1st century AD, the Arab populations, namely Nabataeans and Ituraeans, imposed their domination on the regions they occupied at the time. The recruiting of Ituraean archers was attested since the first civil war. Caesar frequently used mounted and infantry archers…

…it being one of the units that took part in the wars against the Judaeans during the rule of Vespasian. The unit was also mentioned by Josephus Flavius as belonging to the auxiliary units of 1,000 infantrymen that participated in the campaigns at issue.

— Ţentea, Ovidiu, ** you do not have permission to see this link **

Because archers are generally recruited from the East (and Parthia is never a part of 1st century Jerusalem events) that means that the other horsemen cannot be the Bow Daddy. 

Warhorses are also well-attested for the 1st-century Nabataean Arabs, with Arabian horses eventually becoming a luxury standard:

** you do not have permission to see this link ** were an integral part of the Nabataeans’ way of life; they were vital for trade, transportation, and warfare. Evidence of that is seen in many Nabataean settlements, despite Strabo’s statement (Geogr. XVI. 4.26) that the Nabataean country produced no horses, and that camels were used instead of horses for all necessary services. Horses, for instance, were mentioned in Nabataean inscriptions, such as the inscription that was found on one of the tombs at Madaʾin Saleh. The inscription mentioned a cavalry commander who had a high position within the Nabataean community and was buried in a rock-cut tomb (Healey 1986: 115).

Strabo, generalizing that “camels afford the service they require instead of horses,” was relying heavily on reports from Aelius Gallus’s 26–25 BCE military expedition, for which it is on record that the Nabataeans were massively sneaky.

Could the crown (stephanos) of Revelation 6:2 be for a proxy general?

a crown [stephanos] was given to him

A stephanos is a victor’s head ornament, usually for an athlete or general. This is unlike the diadema, the permanent crown of a king, a word also present in Revelation. This stephanos is given to the White Horse rider, meaning that it is not previously attained, as a king’s crown would be.

Notice the verb sent (pempō) in that quote by Josephus:

Malchus also, the king of Arabia, sent

Unlike Agrippa II, Sohaemus/Sohemus, and Antiochus IV who personally rode into the campaign theater to lead their troops, Malichus did not personally attend the war. He is also discussed separately from the other three.

For Malichus, Josephus switches verbs entirely to “sent” (pempō), the standard legal and diplomatic Greek verb for dispatching an embassy, an army, or an official mandate from afar. When a king stays in his palace (or when an estate executes an order) and commissions a proxy general (strategos), the Greek word is pempsantos.

This tracks with established Nabataean royal protocol for the circa-1st-century as recorded by Josephus (e.g., Ant. 18.113–114), where Nabataean kings stayed in Petra and delegated field command to an elite strategos (general, or rb mšrytʾ in Nabataean inscriptions). Thus, the White Horse rider is likely informed by the idea of a proxy general.

The NRSVUE’s “conquering and to conquer,” in my opinion, over-imperializes the Koine Greek nikōn kai hina nikēsē — literally “prevailing, and so that he might prevail/gain the victory,” the exact same verb used in Revelation 2:17 for “the one who is victorious,” fitting a decisive auxiliary intervention rather than Nabataean empire-building.

The 7 seals and the testamentum

While ultimate decision-making rested with Rome, Malichus functioned as the primary regional sovereign, contributing fully half — 6,000 of the 12,000 — auxiliary troops. As there is no precise dating for his passing beyond the general year, it is within possibility that it was his will (testamentum) that co-signed the campaign. Many scholars have pointed out that the seven seals of Revelation seem to describe a testamentum.

Direct Nabataean interventions in Judaea in 65 BCE, 4 BCE, and 36 CE were already established regional strategy during Judaea’s times of kinglessness (Agrippa was king of Chalcis and Transjordanian territories, but never a king of Judaea proper unlike his father, holding only the title of Curator of the Temple there.) Activating this testamentum would be in keeping with Rome’s geopolitical risk management, heading off regional instability in 70 CE when Malichus left his wife and small child on the throne.

White stone

Jesus promises white stone in Revelation 2:17:

…To the one who is victorious, I will give some of the hidden manna. I will also give that person a white stone with a new name written on it, known only to the one who receives it.

“Hidden,” “known only to the one,” — this is language that seems to imply esoteric knowledge.

White stone was originally ** you do not have permission to see this link ** premier medium for royal seals, judicial tokens of acquittal, and sacred dedication stones.

Nabataea’s Negev Homeland Hypothesis and its white stone

The Nabataean scholar Dr. Avraham Negev of Jerusalem University argued for the homeland of early Nabataean settlement as the** you do not have permission to see this link ** account of Nabataea as having soft rock and clay, which matches the white limestone of the Central Negev best. Whether this hypothesis is correct or not, it is still the Central Negev and its white stone that defines the Nabataean ancestor cult.

** you do not have permission to see this link **, is completely fashioned in white/off-white limestone. Anyone arriving to Nabataea from Judaea would encounter this world of white stone in entering the kingdom first.

So wait, isn’t the Nabataean capital city of Petra’s signature rock aesthetic red sandstone?

1st-century Petra was covered in white limestone

Limestone plaster exterior facades were left plain white, with a small amount of painted color on  architectural elements. For example: 

The plain surface and the protruding crowsteps were originally coated with a single layer of a fat lime wash covering most parts of the facade… The use of deep colours like red, blue and yellow on architectural elements helps to distinguish them from the plain facade surfaces.” 

“** you do not have permission to see this link ** Dr. May Shaer, 2015

It is indeed surprising for the modern visitor to learn that
the ancient inhabitants of Petra were not particularly sensitive to the natural beauty of the colourful rocks which are today the main attraction of this city, and that they coated the sand-stone with painted stucco.

— Dr. Fawzi Zayadine,
** you do not have permission to see this link ** 1987

Their limestone plaster was so advanced that people today rely on their cisterns for water. The use of light-to-white limestone in Petra extended to its pavements and the “Marble Road”:

Flagstones, trimmed to rectangular, flat shapes and recognized as limestone without exception (e.g. Scheck 1987: 366) formed the original pavements along the Wādī as-Siq and in the magnificent avenue (“Marble Road”) that connected the two centers of Petra — al-Ḥabīs, i.e. the sacral temple precinct with Qaṣr al-Bint, and the theatre area as the social center in the view of many authors.”

** you do not have permission to see this link ** Friedrich Pflüger, DAJ, 1995

And Petra’s monumental Pool and Garden Complex paving was in prestigious, imported** you do not have permission to see this link ** sacred monumental standing stones, which archaeologists observe that the Nabataeans continued to construct.

Hold that thought. 

2. 🔴🐴 Red Horse — Agrippa II

Revelation 6:4

And out came another horse, bright red; its rider was permitted to take peace from the earth, so that people would slaughter one another, and he was given a great sword.

Agrippa was leading Jewish troops against Jewish rebels in a civil conflict that Josephus called stasis. The Red Horse rider is given a machaira, the short, curved dagger/sword used for close-quarters fighting and internal insurrection (stasis), rather than the broadsword of regular foreign warfare.

Agrippa was the great-grandson of Herod the Great, so patrilineally Edomite/Idumaean, and as Rome’s key royal mediator (J.W. 2.345–404) he fought on the Roman side of a civil war (stasis) that famously drew 20,000 fellow Idumaeans into Jerusalem on the rebel side (J.W. 4.224–353). Words like earth and land in the Bible frequently denote Jewish earth and land, and not the entire earth or its land, and here it would mean the same. 

Red stone

Idumaea is the Hellenized word for Edom, denoting its remaining territory that contained the Edomite remnant after Nabonidus’ campaign; Edom literally translates to “Red,” for its** you do not have permission to see this link **.

The area of Petra was historically part of Edom until the Edomite exile and their recast as Idumaeans. The Nabataeans are relative passers-through, and they allowed Rome to acquire Petra, too. By anchoring Malichus in the white limestone aesthetic of Petra and Obodat, an aesthetic original to prestigious Mesopotamia, the red sandstone of the south is freed to perform its genealogical work in the cipher.

Artifacts of Edomite worship are much sparser than for the others, as is an archaeological understanding of their meaning; Edom was tribal and much less technologically-developed, and the general population was pre-literate. But the ** you do not have permission to see this link ** of their artifacts of worship is very uniform — figures were often rendered in local red clay while structures including masseboth were carved in red  sandstone.

 

3. ⚫️ 🐴 Black Horse — Sohaemus

Revelation 6:5-7

When he broke the third seal, I heard the third living creature call out, “Come!” I looked, and there was a black horse! Its rider held a pair of scales in his hand, and I heard what seemed to be a voice in the midst of the four living creatures saying, “A quart of wheat for a day’s pay and three quarts of barley for a day’s pay, but do not damage the olive oil and the wine!”

Compare the Black Horse rider to Josephus’ auxiliary, Sohaemus:

** you do not have permission to see this link **

Emesa was a major agricultural region for olive oil and wine sales — Revelation’s scale would fit Sohaemus just as much as the short sword would fit Agrippa’s civil war, and the bow would fit Malichus’ proxy general. It is Sohaemus’ troops that accompanied the Roman troops in sealing off Samaria and Judea creating the man-made famine; basic grain prices skyrocketed while cash crops (oil and wine) were preserved for Roman officer supply lines.

Black stone

Sohaemus’ Emesa (modern Homs, Syria) was famous for the** you do not have permission to see this link ** because its historic buildings are built from local, black basalt.

 

4. 🫥🟢🐴 Pale Green Horse — Antiochus IV of Commagene

Modern critical editions like the NRSVUE update Revelation 6:8 from the traditional rendering of “pale” to its precise Greek sense, “pale green,” because chlōros explicitly denotes a pale greenish-yellow color.

Revelation 6:8

I looked, and there was a pale green horse! Its rider’s name was Death, and Hades followed with him; they were given authority over a fourth of the earth, to kill with sword, famine, and pestilence and by the wild animals of the earth.

Death and Hades are a duo, and there’s only one auxiliary of the four that is part of a duo — Antiochus IV brought his son Antiochus Epiphanes to co-lead the shock troops during the unfortunate siege of Jerusalem, as recorded by Josephus. Death is the leader, and “Hades followed with him,” matching a king and his son. “They were given authority over a fourth of the earth,” where the earth may mean Jewish lands specifically in the Hebrew Bible, could make a match with the Herodian tetrarchy’s 4 inherited regions, 1/4 of which was Judaea where they were present.

The Seleucid-descended Antiochi (together with the broader Hellenistic Syrian-Mesopotamian dynastic web) had effectively inherited or absorbed the entire geopolitical footprint of the original 2 Kings 24:2 / Ezekiel 25 contingents — which is why the Antiochi, among the Four Horsemen, are the composite heir to all of Ezekiel’s four tasks: to kill with sword, famine, and pestilence and by the wild animals of the earth.

Revelation’s unfortuitous names would be especially fitting as their own high casualties pile up aside the high Judaean ones:

…and after a sharp conflict, in which many were slain on both sides…

— Flavius Josephus, J.W. 5.11.3 (5.464)

Pale green stone

Those early translators couldn’t just let a horse be green, could they. What horse doesn’t like to roll down hillsides of grass?

Most of ancient Commagene is within ** you do not have permission to see this link **

The pale green stone of the ancestor stelae of Commagene

The pale green stone signature wasn’t just the geological background, it was also the medium of the Commagenean royal ancestor cult. At the dynastic tomb-sanctuaries (hierothesia) of** you do not have permission to see this link **, the ancestral monuments of Antiochus IV’s house, builders carved its colossal deities from white summit limestone, but hauled blocks of a pale green sandstone called tuffite up specifically to carve the royal ancestor stelae and dexiosis reliefs, depicting the king clasping hands with syncretic deities. Those green tuffite stelae immortalized both the dynasty’s Persian lineage (Darius I) and its maternal Macedonian lineage (Alexander the Great and the Seleucid kings), the very heritage reflected in the elite “Macedonian” shock troops that Antiochus IV led into Jerusalem (J.W. 5.460).

Additionally, Commagene is considered a Neo-Hittite kingdom, a remnant after the Hittite collapse circa 1200 BCE, and of course, the famous Hittite sacred stone is the ** you do not have permission to see this link **

So, from white limestone and marble, to Edom’s red clay and sandstone, to Emesa’s black meteorite and basalt, to Commagene’s green sandstone and serpentine; the stone color association holds up. Similarly, from the bow, to the short sword, to the scale, to the duo; the defining characteristics of the Four Horsemen of Revelation matching the four auxiliaries of The Jewish War also holds up. And these unique descriptors can’t be assigned in other orders — Malichus did not rule over a breadbasket, Sohaemus wasn’t experiencing a civil conflict, Agrippa did not lead as a duo, Antiochus and his son Antiochus weren’t coming with the short swords.

But, there’s more to Revelation than just that section of it.

Can you be anti-Nero and an auxiliary for Vespasian?

It even helps! Nero became a declared enemy of the state in 68 CE, and was replaced by the Flavian dynasty who was dismayed by the prospect of a Nero Redivivus. (Both Revelation and the Lex de Imperio Vespasiani ignore the three civil war emperors in-between that ruled for just a few months — illegitimately, in the ex-post-facto view.) If this section of Revelation reflects the historical First Jewish-Roman War in this way, then it is not indistinct as to whose side the Jesus movement is on, and that would track with John the Baptist’s followers, the Mandaeans, slotting Jesus in with the Romans:

Revelation 6:16

They called to the mountains and the rocks, “Fall on us and hide us from the face of him who sits on the throne and from the wrath of the Lamb!”

Except the Koine Greek uses arnion throughout, so it’s:

…the wrath of the little lamb!”

I wonder if anyone made a miniature military costume for the little lamb, just so I could use the word “lambula.”

But mainstream scholarship says Revelation is against Rome?

I know?!!? It’s against Nero’s Rome and it’s not happy with “the bald Nero” either. Revelation could be called Against Neros. They don’t say his name because it becomes literally Abolitio Nominis‘d. This is how you get “the adversary at Pergamon,” the “666/616 Beast,” “the mortal wound that’s healed,” “the Beast messed up and burned his wh*re city,” because cities are women. Nero concerns practically bookend Revelation. 

And the “bald Nero” Domitian is apparently the end of his dynastic line for good reasons. John of Patmos, anticipating the lifting of Domitian censorship, in revealing history would obviously be motivated to do so by matters contemporary to himself.

The saucy “and do not damage the olive oil and the wine” line of the Black Horse rider best describes Emesa protecting both olive oil and wine for Roman supply lines, but it would resonate with Domitian’s unpopular 92 CE edict ordering vineyards uprooted in the East (but not olive trees). Especially when Nabataea was getting famous with its wine exports.

In the Gospels

• Jesus speaks respectfully and as a ranking peer would with Roman leaders like the Centurion and Pilate

• Jesus lauds the Syrian general Naaman

• Jesus trash talks the Jewish Second Temple establishment

Even the founder of Rabbinical Judaism, Rabbi ben Zakkai the Mysteriously Revived Man, verbally tries to hug Vespasian and Vespasian backs up a little.

How anyone thought that Jesus  would be for the Second Temple administration in the First Jewish-Roman War, when the Gospels makes a point to describe the interactions, is beyond me to figure out.

Why Would There Be A Different Order of Auxiliaries/Horsemen in Revelation than in The Jewish War?

In my hypothesis:

• The Jewish War’s patron is the emperor.

• Revelation’s patron is the king-of-kings.

Therefore the order basically reverses via their proximity to the patron. The Jewish War’s naming order for these auxiliaries matches their operational participation in the First Jewish-Roman War. This order of participation is essentially a function of geographical proximity to empire, Rome, and is listed north-to-south. However, because Agrippa personally rode north to Antioch to meet Vespasian at the campaign’s outset, he reported in before the slightly more northern Sohaemus of Emesa — securing the second slot in Josephus’s Antiochus, Agrippa, Sohaemus, and Malichus line-up.

Revelation’s locusts: the making of a metaphor

Academic consensus is that the locusts are attached to the White Horse rider via the crown (stephanos) callback.

The Book of Joel has many parallels with the Book of Revelation, as I’ve discovered reading this excellent 2015 commentary by** you do not have permission to see this link ** including trumpets announcing penalties. This is easiest to see comparing Revelation’s locusts and Joel’s locusts by editing them with ellipses to show the matching order: locusts, grass, trees, war/battle, horses, and noise of chariots:

Revelation 9:3-10

…locusts came down on the earth…They were told not to harm the grass of the earth or any plant or tree…the locusts were like horses equipped for battle…their teeth like lions’ teeth…the noise of their wings was like the noise of many chariots with horses rushing into battle.

Joel 1:4-2:5

And what the hopping locust has left, the destroying locust has eaten! A powerful nation came to attack my land…Its weapons were as sharp as a lion’s teeth..Fire has changed our green fields into a desert. Flames have burned all the trees…The army will destroy the land like a burning fire…They look like horses. They run like war horses. Listen to them. It is like the noise of chariots.

The Book of Revelation appears to use metaphors for the First Jewish-Roman War like the Book of Joel uses metaphors for the Jewish-Babylonian War

** you do not have permission to see this link ** classic commentary believes that this locust army in Joel refers to the Chaldean (Neo-Babylonian) invasions of the sixth century BCE; this would be the lead-up prior to the destruction of the First Temple.

Interestingly, Joel is the only instance in the Hebrew Bible where locusts are not associated with the east (an impossibility for actual locusts). In Joel 2:20 this horde is instead called “the Northerner.” Since at least the last Neo-Babylonian, Nabonidus, is documented to have utilized Northwestern Arabian forces, we are likely back at Arabs. Mesopotamianized Arabs.

Nabonidus’ palace in Tayma was later administered by Nabataeans. Nabonidus’ seal appears over Sela, which in the 1st century sat squarely within the Nabataean kingdom. Clearly there’s a point of cultural overlap there.

The author of ** you do not have permission to see this link ** Ibn Wahshiyya, though written much later c. 903–904 CE, used the term Chaldean interchangeably with Nabataean. This aligns with Nabataean specialist Dr. David F. Graf’s position that the Nabataean people’s origins, in addition to Northwest Arabia, are in Mesopotamia, like the Chaldeans/Neo-Babylonians.

Are Revelation’s locusts Malichus’ 5,000?

Malchus also, the king of Arabia, sent a thousand horsemen, besides five thousand footmen, the greatest part of which were archers…

Romans classified camelrie under footmen. Because the bowmen riding camels also hop off to engage and shoot on foot, standard ancient military classifications group them as footmen.

In the surviving Roman army duty rosters (pridiana) of the Cohors XX Palmyrenorum (a Syrian-Arabian auxiliary unit of archers), the camel riders (dromedarii) are not listed under the cavalry squadrons (turmae of equites). Instead, they are administratively booked and grouped directly inside the infantry centuries (centuriae) under the command of infantry centurions. To a Roman military clerk or a historian reading imperial muster rolls like Josephus, camel-mounted archers were literally counted on the infantry (pezikon) ledger.

Revelation’s locust breakdown

Revelation 9:3-10:

🦗And out of the smoke locusts came down on the earth and were given power like that of scorpions of the earth. 4 They were told not to harm the grass of the earth or any plant or tree, but only those people who did not have the seal of God on their foreheads. 5 They were not allowed to kill them but only to torture them for five months…In appearance the locusts were like horses equipped for battle. On their heads were what looked like crowns of gold; their faces were like human faces, 8 their hair like women’s hair, and their teeth like lions’ teeth; 9 they had scales like iron breastplates, and the noise of their wings was like the noise of many chariots with horses rushing into battle. 10 They have tails like scorpions, with stingers…

Beginning with the introductory line:

🦗And out of the smoke locusts came down on the earth and were given power like that of scorpions of the earth

Scorpions of the Earth and Scorpion Men

Revelation’s locusts being given power “like that of scorpions of the earth” parallels the Epic of Gilgamesh’s scorpion men (girtablullû) guarding the Twin Mountains of Mount Mashu — which ANE scholars like ** you do not have permission to see this link ** and W.G. Lambert locate in the Anti-Lebanon/Jebel Druze range along the Syro-Arabian desert frontier — i.e., the exact turf of the later Ituraeans and Nabataeans. On Babylonian kudurru boundary stelae, the scorpion-man was depicted as an archer drawing a composite bow (the direct Babylonian prototype for the constellation Sagittarius) with a:

• human face

• horned/crowned cap

• wings

• scorpion stinger tail

In Mesopotamian texts such as Gilgamesh and Enkidu, being of the earth/wilderness (ki) designates being nomadic and wild, instead of being from settled areas like the scorpion men depictions that archaeologists know to represent archers.

Scorpion men are a Syro-Arabian archer identifier

The operative word “like” is repeated throughout the locust passage. This gives an opportunity to identify new players in comparison to similar roles and similar events. While the Nabataean Arabs ruling over the Arab confederacy from settled Petra were renowned for their mildness, civility, and relative reluctance to engage in conflict in Strabo’s and Josephus’s writings, the barbarian bowmen that Strabo records Aelius Gallus encountering in his Arabian campaign score a bullseye for “scorpions of the earth”:

The next country which he traversed belonged to nomads and most of it was truly desert…Here the barbarians joined battle with the Romans, and about ten thousand of them fell, but only two Romans; for they used their weapons in an inexperienced manner, being utterly unfit for war, using bows and spears and swords and slings…

—** you do not have permission to see this link **

They suck against Romans. But what about against besieged Jerusalemites, once mobilized by the Roman client-king system that has Malichus sourcing 5,000 archers for Vespasian?

In Roman frontier warfare like the First Jewish-Roman War, auxiliary archers — who, in standard Eastern and Roman military service, were frequently outfitted in scale or mail breastplates (lorica squamata or hamata) — were not heavy shock troops meant to annihilate an army, but were assigned to campaigns of harassment, perimeter screening, and attrition.

“They were told…”, this isn’t a plague of actual locusts, in case anyone was still wondering. Active field campaigns were bound to a seasonal window running approximately five months — from late spring (May/Iyyar) through early autumn (September/Tishrei), matching the dry summer weather before winter rains flooded desert wadis and compromised animal glue in composite bows. Historically, the siege of the Jewish-Roman War lasted from about late April to September 70 CE — and that is five months.

🦗In appearance the locusts

• Locusts (ʾarbeh) form an acoustic wordplay with the desert wilderness (ʿaravah), which is the source for the words Arabia, Arabian and Arab. The Hebrew Bible uses the locust metaphor when the Midianites of northwestern Arabia show up in Judges 6:2–5:

The hand of Midian prevailed over Israel, and because of Midian the Israelites provided for themselves hiding places in the mountains, caves and strongholds. 3 For whenever the Israelites put in seed, the Midianites and the Amalekites and the people of the east would come up against them…5 For they and their livestock would come up, and they would even bring their tents, as thick as locusts.

And Judges 7:12:

The Midianites and the Amalekites and all the people of the east lay along the valley as thick as locusts; neither they nor their camels could be counted…

My bolding.

🦗They were told not to harm the grass of the earth or any plant or tree, but only those people who did not have the seal of God on their foreheads. 5 They were not allowed to kill them but only to torture them for five months

• Revelation’s locusts differs from Joel’s locusts in that the pronouncements are milder; this time the land is to be unharmed, the people with a seal of God are exempt entirely, and the unexempt are not to be killed.

🦗were like horses equipped for battle

• Operative word, “like” horses. This mirrors Joel 2:4:

They look like horses. They run like war horses

• The Four Horsemen ride actual horses (hippoi), while the locust cavalry ride on something “like” horses (homoia hippois). 

Revelation’s little insect bodies are likely riding skinny skirmish camels. When Herodotus describes the Arabian contingents in Xerxes’ imperial army (Histories 7.86–87), he notes that Arabians rode camels that were like horses for endurance and speed across arid terrain.

🦗On their heads were what looked like crowns of gold

• Eastern archers wore ** you do not have permission to see this link **

🦗their faces were like human faces

 • Because they are human in the modern sense. The original, Sumero-Akkadian written designation of human though was used only to designate the settled/civilized/urbanized; a division that the Sumerians as the world’s first civilization liked to hammer on.

🦗their hair like women’s hair

• Long hair was the standard Greco-Roman marker for Arab warriors. Pliny the Elder in ** you do not have permission to see this link ** is depicted on a re-used block on the wall of Karak Castle. 

🦗and their teeth like lions’ teeth

• Locusts with teeth like lions are again, the metaphors of Joel 1:4-6:

4 What the cutting locust left,
    the swarming locust has eaten;
what the swarming locust left,
    the hopping locust has eaten;
and what the hopping locust left,
    the destroying locust has eaten…6 For a nation has invaded my land, powerful and innumerable; its teeth are lions’ teeth, and it has the fangs of a lioness.

🦗they had scales like iron breastplates

• ** you do not have permission to see this link **worn by Eastern auxiliaries. These “like” iron breastplates were likely copper alloys, the preference of Eastern auxiliaries.

🦗and the noise of their wings was like the noise of many chariots with horses rushing into battle.

• The wings (pteruges) of an ancient army specifically referred to its flanks or cavalry wings (alae) like the Ala I Augusta Ituraeorum. The sound of galloping horse-archers charging along the flanks of an advancing force created a thunderous roar.

🦗They have tails like scorpions, with stingers.

• The “scorpion stinger” mimics the famous Parthian shot, where mounted desert archers feigned retreat while shooting low and backward over their horses’ rumps. However, this posture wasn’t restricted to Parthians but was instead an Eastern-wide practice at this point that was repeatedly linked to the Arabs by *handwaves* many ancient historians. Spears would also work here.

Now returning to Josephus’ roll call:

** you do not have permission to see this link ** also, the king of Arabia, sent a thousand horsemen, besides five thousand footmen, the greatest part of which were archers…

My bolding.

Revelation’s White Horse rider and the locusts are connected through the callback of the stephanoi crown, and similarly, Malichus’ proxy is the only auxiliary leader that is connected to an additional set of troops, the 5,000.

The Locust King 

Because the case has been made for Revelation’s White Horse being Malichus’s proxy general, I suggest that Malichus is the locust king. 

And they had as king over them the angel of the bottomless pit, whose name in Hebrew is Abaddon, but in Greek he has the name Apollyon.

The abyss is simply the underworld connected to a lot of water ablution traditions, and matches Malichus passing in 70 CE, and the seven seals as a testamentum. An angel in its original meaning is a commissioned royal envoy. A king continuing to command troops via his testamentum is quite literally an “angel [envoy] of the abyss.”

The Destroyer epithet in Isaiah, again, was utilized for Assyria and its destruction of the Israelite kingdom (Destroyer also could function as a hypocoristic for the epithet of Isis’ syncretization of Mut’s Sekhmet persona, whose myths appear to be repurposed in Isaiah — Destroyer of Rebellions.)

If Revelation does indeed draw from the First Jewish-Roman War, it is my best guess that Revelation’s locusts would be a group within Malichus’ Arabian confederacy. From the time of the Book of Maccabees and as corroborated by Josephus, the Nabataeans had repeatedly intervened directly in Judaea, marching forces to the temple complex during the civil conflict over Hyrcanus II and Archelaus II (Antiquities of the Jews 14.21), and pursuing the High Priest Jason for judicial questioning (2 Maccabees 5:7-8). In more precise language, this might be a response to the FA segment of the** you do not have permission to see this link **, perhaps beginning in 62 CE per Josephus, or in 69 CE as reported by Hegesippus (c. 107-180 CE) and preserved by Eusebius of Caesarea (c. 260–339 CE), before the FO segment.

It is academic consensus that Revelation’s final composition was written by c. 95 CE, and widely accepted by scholars that part of this book is informed by, or comments on, the First Jewish-Roman War (66–73/74 CE), before it goes on to comment on later events. Utilizing the primary imperial documentation of that time, Josephus’s The Jewish War (c. 75-79 CE) and/or the archives that the book draws from, would just be Apocalyptic Literature 101, leveraging official texts to build a counter-record.

Ezekiel and Revelation

Most scholars consider Ezekiel to be the primary template for Revelation. Ezekiel’s theme is prophesying the destruction of the First Temple. Therefore, Revelation prophesying the destruction of the Second Temple shouldn’t be a stretch, but here we are.

It is from Ezekiel that Revelation draws from the four “sore judgments,” (sword, famine, wild beasts, and pestilence/death.) Since Ezekiel is about the Jewish-Babylonian war, 2 Kings simply has a list of the Jewish-Babylonian war’s four auxiliaries:

🗡️Introducing Ammonites as Sword

  • In Revelation 6:4, the rider of the red horse is given a great sword (machaira, a short dagger or assassination blade) specifically to take peace from the earth so people slay one another. In Revelation, this matches Agrippa dealing with Judaean civil war (stasis); in Ezekiel it matches the Ammonite-backed assassination of Governor Gedaliah at Mizpah — the covert dagger plot that triggered Judean civil war that time.
  • 💀Introducing Chaldeans as Death/Pestilence
  • As the primary imperial shock troops, siege engineers, and executioners, the Chaldeans delivered mass mortality
  • 🚫🍕Introducing Moabites as Famine
  • Sealing off the Jordan River crossings and eastern agricultural trade directly starved Jerusalem of bread and grain (staple calories)
  • 🐅🐗🦔 Introducing Arameans as Wild Beasts 
     

    Nomadic provincial raiders and  steppe cavalry, the Arameans continued to exemplify the aspersions made against their geographic predecessors the Amurru (comparing them to wild beasts), roaming the open countryside picking off fugitives and leaving the unpopulated land to the wild beasts of Ezekiel 14:21.

    Zechariah, Jeremiah, Daniel, and Ezekiel

    Zechariah, Jeremiah, Daniel, and Ezekiel are all books that academic consensus recognizes as referenced in Revelation. These books form a ledger of the empires that held dominion over Jerusalem while destroying, rebuilding, or profaning its temple: the Neo-Babylonian, Achaemenid, and Seleucid empires. If you include Exodus and its Tabernacle antecedent, then you have included the time of the Egyptian empire, too. If Revelation’s Destroyer epithet echoes Isaiah’s Destroyer epithet for the Assyrian Empire, and its destruction of the Israelite kingdom, then we are one empire away from a complete set. In this hypothesis, Revelation updates that ledger to the Roman Empire. It logs the temple’s 70 CE destruction and its permanent replacement by a theological Jerusalem without a temple (Rev 21:22).

    Revelation’s timeline in this hypothesis:

    • ~54 CE: Nero at Pergamon, “where Satan [the adversary] lives” (Rev 2:13).

  •  ~61 CE: Laodicea earthquake rebuild, refuses Neronian relief funds (Rev 3:17).
  •  64 CE: Great Fire of Rome & Persecutions. Nero the Beast burns Rome, the seven-hilled capital (Rev 17:16), executes martyrs (Rev 6:9; 17:6), and debases coinage as anticipated, “gold refined by fire,” (Rev 3:18).

• 67 CE: Vespasian assembles the four client-king contingents at Ptolemais (Rev 6:2–8) as Malichus II dispatches 1,000 horsemen and 5,000 bowmen (Rev 9:3–10; J.W. 3.68–69).

• 68 CE: Nero’s Purported Unaliving With No Body To Show For It; the mortal wound that isn’t (Rev 13:3).

• 69 CE: Roman civil war disrupts all trade, destabilizing downstream (Rev 18:11–19).

• 70 CE: Malichus’s will (Rev 5:1) maintains Nabataean troop commitments under his proxy general (Rev 6:2) as “envoy of the abyss” (Rev 9:11) across the five-month siege of Jerusalem (Rev 9:5), dismantling the Second Temple (Rev 11:1–2).

• 71 CE: Malichus’ son Rabbel II receives Jerusalem refugees into the new capital city of Bostra, meaning “sheep pen” with its massive, new public water, grain, and orchard projects, and a Jewish synagogue network. He gains the name Soter, meaning “Savior.” (Rev 12:6, 14, 22:1-2)

• 79 CE: First Nero Redivivus. Terentius Maximus flees to Parthia, sparking concerns of an Eastern invasion (Rev 13:3; 16:12; 17:8)

• 81-96 CE: Tacitus notes that Domitian begins supressing literary freedom in 81 CE

• 88 CE: An unnamed Nero Redivivus candidate is backed by Parthia (“twenty years after” Nero), sparking Eastern invasion concerns again until surrendered to Rome (Rev 16:12; 17:8)

• 95 CE: Domitian interrogates Jesus’ grandniblings to prevent their rise to power as Davidic heirs, views their working-class hands (because of their land, that’s doing well for Judaea) and dismisses them, per Eusebius of Caesarea (Ecclesiastical History 3.19–20), quoting the 2nd-century  Hegesippus (c. 110–180 CE).

• ~96 CE: End of Domitian’s Reign and the Flavian dynasty, and the likely publishing of Revelation. Emperor Nerva arrives expressly with the goodwill platform of dropping treason/impiety (maiestas/asebeia) and “Jewish lifestyle” (Ioudaikos bios) prosecutions, and installing literary freedom (ingenia studiaque).

This may have allowed the regional power most involved before and after the First Jewish-Roman War the freedom to reveal their perspective in a sensitive way. Revelation concludes with a beautiful image of a theological temple-free New Jerusalem in the hearts of Jesus’ followers (Rev 21:22).

After Revelation

• 106 CE: Of the four auxiliary kingdoms in Josephus’ passage, Nabataea, including its Jewish refugees, is the last to be absorbed into a Roman province. Providentially, an early 2nd century underground Christian city appears under modern Midyat, at or near the border of ancient Osroene, the epicenter of Gnostic Christianity ruled by the ethnically-Nabataean Abgarid dynasty.

•~180 CE: Writing around 180 CE, Irenaeus states that Revelation was seen:

almost in our own day, at the end of Domitian’s reign

pros tō telei tēs Dometianou archēs

— Irenaeus, Against Heresies (5.30.3)

It’s interesting to see that the Talmud and various Jewish websites perceive what is now termed the First Jewish-Roman War as God authorizing corrective actions against Jerusalem, to correct “baseless anger.” With 2,000 years of perspective, I’m more of an “improve the system, don’t blame the people” person.

But wouldn’t any misperceptions have been corrected by the original participants?

Maybe its Revelation that attempts to do just that. But apocalyptic literature comments on sensitive political events esoterically. They use symbols. It is the reader that must rise to the level of understanding, it is the seeker who must seek.

Matthew 7:8

For everyone who asks receives, and everyone who searches finds, and for everyone who knocks, the door will be opened.

All copyright me, “I’m confident because I’m right” 2026

1 ... 56789
Forum Timezone: America/Indiana/Indianapolis
All RSSShow Stats
Administrators:
BDEhrman
FreedomBen
evgendob
Robert
Top Posters:
Steefen: 8356
Stephen: 5072
Porphyry: 1972
godspell: 1827
DavidFord: 1790
BJH1960: 1582
brenmcg: 1184
Colin Milton: 1136
Judith: 1046
Jarek: 954
Newest Members:
ekane
ovais_khalil
charissa
Kirk3757
Janet K. Hellmann
PD_Blackwell
mattkon
Lisa2113940
mikewebb64
PastorBeals
Forum Stats:
Groups: 2
Forums: 13
Topics: 2694
Posts: 50188

 

Member Stats:
Guest Posters: 65
Members: 66512
Moderators: 0
Admins: 4
Most Users Ever Online: 3559
Currently Online: Serene, Jill_L, Judith
Guest(s) 10