When people today tell me, or want to know if, Jesus travelled to India in his youth to learn the “wisdom of the East” or to Egypt to learn how to do “magic,” or any other rather exorbitant claim for a lower-class peasant born and raised in a small rural Jewish village, I tell them that the idea comes from one of the modern-day (usually 19th century) Gospel forgeries. Sometimes my informant/questioner tells me they don’t believe the book they read about it (or heard about it) was forged but was an authentic account of Jesus hidden by the authorities (usually “the Vatican”), afraid of the truth being revealed. I simply sigh.
I’ve written about a few of the most important of these modern forgeries in my book Forged, which is mainly not about them, but about ancient Christian writings produced in the name of a famous person by someone who was, well, someone else – that is, what we would today called forgeries. Some such books are found in the New Testament (1 Timothy, 2 Peter, etc.), and lots more outside of it.
Near the end of the book, though, I talk about modern Gospel forgeries, and set them in the context of modern forgeries generally.
In the book I introduce all this by talking about one of the great forgery stories of modern times that some of you will know of and some of you not (with contemporary college students being uniformly in the latter category).
Here’s what I say about it there (Forged: Why the Bible’s Authors Are Not Who We Think They Are, HarperOne, 2011).
******************************
Whenever I teach about forgery, I think back to my first lecture on the subject, twenty-five years ago now, at Rutgers University. As odd as this might seem, forgery was on everyone’s mind at the time. Only a few months earlier forgery had been front page news for weeks
Kujau was a genius, but I don’t think he’s in the same league as Morton Smith.
There are still people who believe in the Secret Gospel of Mark.
Do you have any opinion on Mark Hoffman? The forger most famous for LDS fakes, but produced allot of other material? Do you think the main motive of modern forgers is money, and would they be different from ancient forgers?
I’m afraid I haven’t really looked into him much.
I can’t help thinking there may be a number of forgeries that are better; but of course for that reason they haven’t been exposed. 🙂
An interesting forgery is the so-called MJ-12, “Majestic 12”, documents which purported to show that President Truman was involved in the establishment of secret committees whose task was to recover and investigate alien spacecraft (i.e. UFOs). Anybody who is interested in it can check out the Wikipedia article on it below. The forgery of a document that Jesus had a wife is an interesting forgery too (see the wiki link below). All this demonstrates that anything really popular will have forgeries created about them. So, we can say that the forgeries that happened in the first two or three centuries of the Christian religion imply that it must have had enough popularity to make forgeries possible. The inauthentic Pauline epistles in the New Testament, as well as forgeries like 1Peter and 2Peter, argue against the idea that the New Testament is either revelation and/or the word of any god. So, the really interesting question is why do so many people think otherwise and continue to believe in this religion? Bart, I’d be curious to know what you think answers this question.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Majestic_12
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gospel_of_Jesus%27_Wife
I’d say most Christians aren’t believers because they’re sure Peter wrote 1 and 2 Peter; they might be offended to hear otherwise, but 99% of the time they are Christians because they hear that Christ died for their sins… etc. Not surprised about the Truman thing…
Professor Ehrman please allow me to hijack this site. There is an author named T.C. Schmidt and he has written a text titled, “Josephus and Jesus.” It sounds news breaking if reasonable. Are you aware of it? Would you offer any comments? Very respectfully, you are a subject matter expert.
Yes, I know Tom and I’ve talked with him about it. I think he is completlely wrong about it. There’s no way on God’s green earth that Josephus confessed that Jesus was the messiah who died and was raised from the dead in fulfillment of Scriptures.
Bart, what is your opinion on Luke 19:27? Does it likely go back to Jesus or is it a later addition?
I think it was originally in Luke, but I don’t think it’s something Jesus said. It presupposes that Jesus is the future king who will destroy all his enemies, and that’s not what Jesus’ message was.