If Jesus was not a carpenter – I have my doubts – can we think of a reason Mark may have wanted to say he was (Mark 6:3).? I’ve never seen this discussed before, but I can indeed imagine a reason.
Recall the setting. In the opening chapters of Mark, Jesus has been preaching, healing, casting out demons, doing other miracles, and gathering crowds. Then in chapter six we come to this:
6 He left that place and came to his hometown, and his disciples followed him. 2 On the Sabbath he began to teach in the synagogue, and many who heard him were astounded. They said, “Where did this man get all this? What is this wisdom that has been given to him? What deeds of power are being done by his hands! 3 Is not this the carpenter, the son of Mary and brother of James and Joses and Judas and Simon, and are not his sisters here with us?” And they took offense at him. 4 Then Jesus said to them, “Prophets are not without honor, except in their hometown and among their own kin and in their own house.” 5 And he could do no deed of power there, except that he laid his hands on a few sick people and cured them. 6 And he was amazed at their unbelief.
The comment about him being a carpenter seems a bit off the cuff and ad hoc. Mark doesn’t seem to be making a big point of it. But in fact, maybe he is trying to say something important.
The townspeople (oddly, since Jesus grew up with them and apparently left the village as an adult just some months before) wonder if this is really who he appears to be, “the carpenter.” That certainly matters for Mark.
One of the major themes found throughout this Gospel in particular is that during Jesus’ ministry, almost from beginning to end, no one can understand who he is.

Read the first half of Mark carefully and ask who knows and who doesn’t know his true identity. The only ones who know that he is the son of God are: God who tells him at his baptism (Mark 1:11); Jesus who hears God tell him (Mark 1:11), the demons he casts out (Mark 1:24); and Mark himself (Mark 1:1 etc.). No one else knows.
In this Gospel, Jesus’ mother and brothers come to rescue him from the public view because they literally think he has gone out of his mind (Mark 3:20-21); the Jewish leaders think he must be possessed by Beelzebub, that is, the Devil, since he casts out demons (3:22); and the disciples repeatedly are said not to understand who he is. In fact they wonder aloud when with a word he calms the stormy sea: “Who then is this, that even wind and sea obey him?” (Mark 4:41).
Later they see him walking on water and don’t get it: “For they did not understand … but their hearts were hardened” (Mark 6:51–52). Two chapters later, Jesus warns them “to beware of the leaven of the scribes and Pharisees” (Mark 8:15) and they mistake his meaning, thinking he is angry because they have forgotten to bring bread along, even though they had seen him miraculously feed thousands of hungry people on two different occasions. Now Jesus expresses his own exasperation: “Do you not yet understand?” (Mark 8:21).
The disciples do begin to have an inkling, just after this. The episode starts with a question from Jesus: “Who do people say that I am?” (Mark 8:27). The disciples reply that some think he is John the Baptist, others Elijah, and yet others a prophet raised from the dead. He then turns the question on them: “But who do you say that I am?” (Mark 8:29). Peter, as spokesperson for the group, replies, “You are the Christ.”
Ah, Peter finally understands, right? Wrong. He only partly understands.
Jesus reacts to Peter’s confession by ordering the disciples not to spread the word: “And he sternly ordered them not to tell anyone about him” (Mark 8:30). Then he tells them that he “must suffer many things, and be rejected by the elders and the chief priests and the scribes, and be killed, and after three days rise from the dead” (Mark 8:31). And how does Peter respond?
It makes no sense to him. He has just indicated that Jesus is the future King of the Jews (= Messiah) and now Jesus is talking about being executed by his enemies? He takes Jesus aside and begins to rebuke him and Jesus famously responds: “Get behind me Satan!. For you are setting your mind not on divine things but on human things” (Mark 8:33).
For Mark (and for all the other early Christians we know about), Jesus was the messiah who had to suffer and die. Peter can’t get his mind around it.
In this entire Gospel, it is not till after Jesus’ death that anyone understands that he – precisely as the messiah, the Son of God — had to be crucified. And the one who recognizes is not one of his family, his disciples, his townspeople, or anyone else you might expect. It’s the centurion who just crucified him. (This may be a symbolic claim on Mark’s part, that the identity of Jesus as a crucified messiah might make no sense to Jews, but it will be openly recognized by gentiles.)
So … What does this have to do with Mark’s indication Jesus was a “carpenter” (or some other manual laborer: TEKTON)?
Recall, in broader Roman society, those who worked with their hands to make things – carpenters, metal smiths, stone masons – were seen generally as having lowly work, to have been uneducated and socially unimportant. When Mark has Jesus’ hometown folk say that he is a TEKTON he is showing that they have no idea of who he really is, despite the fact that he has been doing miracles and delivering incredibly wise and insightful teachings. Isn’t he just the TEKTON? The lower-class peasant who fixed my gate one time?
But why wouldn’t Mark just have them identify Jesus as a farmer, since that’s almost certainly what he would have done for most of his life? On this theory, it’s because that would not single him out from everyone else. It wouldn’t make sense to say “Isn’t this a farmer?” They all were farmers. To separate him off as distinct, they call him a lowly occasional worker, “the” TEKTON”; that makes it clear that he is the uneducated day laborer who may be good with his hands, but he ain’t no Jesus Christ Superstar….
There is some possible support for this reading of the passage in the first mention of Jesus as a carpenter outside the New Testament, in the book called the Dialogue with Trypho by Justin Martyr, around 150 CE (it’s a debate that the Christian philosopher Justin has with a Rabbi over the truth claims of Christianity). Justin indicates that Jesus was thought to be a lowly carpenter, and that no one knew who he was during his life up till the time he got baptized by John.
When Jesus came to the Jordan, being considered to be the son of Joseph, the carpenter,³ and having no comeliness, as the Scriptures affirmed, He was thought to be a carpenter (for, when He was on earth He used to work as a carpenter, making ploughs and yokes, and thereby giving us symbolic lessons of the necessity of leading a just and active life); but then, as I already stated, the Holy Spirit for the sake of mankind descended upon Him in the form of a dove, and at the same instant a voice out of the heavens spoke the words which had also been uttered by David, when he, in the person of Christ, spoke what was later to be said to Christ by the Father: “Thou art My Son; this day have I begotten Thee,”⁴ meaning that His birth really began for men when they first realized who He was.’ (Translation of Thomas Falls, Dialogue with Trypho, in the Fathers of the Church series)
Justin gets the idea of “carpenter” from Mark and points out that as such, he was not known to be significant (let alone “the Son of God”) until he left home to be baptized by John. He (Justin) realizes that the term shows – in the eyes of his townsfolk – Jesus may have been a hardworking and innocent enough fellow, but in their eyes he was nothing more. Being a “carpenter” made him of no account to the world at large. Here the Nazareth crowd, like everyone else, simply had no understanding of who he really was.
You must be logged in to post a comment.Share Bart’s Post on These Platforms
49 Comments
Leave A Comment
Is it possible that Mark was using irony here (as he does elsewhere) to make a point about the secret identity of Jesus? Specifically, he puts the “carpenter” (τεκτον) in the mouths the unknowing Nazareth townsfolk, who think they are thereby belittling Jesus. But τεκτον is derived from the verb τίκτω, to bring into existence, thereby also suggesting a much higher connection. This would fit with passages like Mark 1:10, where the pneuma from heaven goes into Jesus (εἰς αὐτον), as well as Mark 1:24 (in which a demon identifies Jesus “the holy one of God” [ὁ ἅγιος τοῦ θεοῦ]) and Mark 3:20-21 (in which Jesus’s family says that he seems to them to be out of his senses or wits [ἐξέστη], implying a recent change). See also the Epistle to Diogenes 7:2 (referring to Jesus Christ as “τεχνιτην” of all things).
On a similar note, I wonder if Mark’s audience was already believers and would’ve seen this irony. He’s not just a “tekton” he is “the tekton” or the demiurge?
I’d say Mark doesn’t have a concept of Jesus as a pre-existent divine being.
From Mark 1:11, shouldn’t we add John the Baptist to the list of people who knew? If there was a voice from Heaven, he presumably would have heard it. Others could have been present as well.
In Mark the voice comes directly to Jesus, not to anyone else.
“He left that place and came to his hometown…he began to teach in the synagogue… Is not this the carpenter…”
If Jesus’ hometown was Nazareth, and if Nazareth was a little hamlet with no synagogue in Jesus’ time, then he couldn’t possibly have been teaching in his hometown synagogue. Isn’t that reason enough to doubt the entire story, including, but not limited to, his homies referring to him as a carpenter?
The “synagogue” at the time referred to a gathering of Jews for worship, not a building.
The “synagogue” at the time referred to a gathering of Jews for worship, not a building.
Worth noting perhaps that the word “synagogue” (in Greek) simply means “gathering/bringing together.” Similarly, the Greek word for “assembly,” ekklesia, gave many languages their word for church (e.g. Spanish “iglesia”, French “eglise”), but originally referred to the gathering of the people and *not* to the building in which they gathered.
Dr Ehrman.
I heard it said that tekton is the basis for our word technology, which we see as a desirable. However a technologist is someone who has a few basic skills but who gets told how, where and when to use them almost like an accomplished slave. Could tekton be a precurser to Jesus being at the command of God ending in thoughts like let THY will be done?
Yeah, good point. Possibly. Or I’ve wondered if it means the he’s the one who “makes” or “brings into existence” a new world of peace (or some such thing).
1. “On the Sabbath he began to teach in the synagogue”
Was there a synagogue in Nazareth?
2. “the son of Mary”
Even if Joseph was dead, wouldn’t they normally say “the son of Joseph?”
3. Is Mark 6:1-6 not historical and was just Mark’s way of saying that no one including Jesus’ hometown knew who he really was?
1. Any group of Jews come together for worship was a “synagogue.” Only later did it come to mean a building.
2. Yup!
3. Could be historical, but it seems weird they weren’t sure it was Jesus since he had lived and worked among them for his whole life until a few weeks/months previous
2. “the son of Mary”
Even if Joseph was dead, wouldn’t they normally say “the son of Joseph?”
Your answer: “2. Yup!”
Could it be that the text originally stated, “the son of Joseph” but the author of Mark changed it to “the son of Mary” since Jesus was believed to be the son of God?
Yes, that’s probably why Matthew changed it. But the fact that it’s unusual and puzzling in Mark shows why matthew wanted to do so. (That is, it argues that the unusual wording of Mark is probalby what Mark originally wrote.)
I also read that Matthew changed the carpenter from being Jesus to being Joseph because he felt that this was too lowly a job for Jesus. Is that your thought as well?
Yup, pretty much.
What do you make of the comment by Origen in Contra Celsus, Book VI, Chapter 36, “and [Celsus] being blind also to this, that in none of the Gospels current in the Churches is Jesus Himself ever described as being a carpenter.”
I think either Origen had a brain burp or he was being disingenuous OR his version of Mark was one scribes had changed to harmonize with Mark. I suspect the first, but only because I have the sense he was normally completely honest and because he know a lot of manuscripts. But I’m not sure there’s any way to tell.
Thank you Dr Ehrman. Yes, that makes a lot of sense in the context of Mark’s gospel – the Messianic secret etc. My only, slight quibble is whether craftsmen such us carpenters might have had some status in society. As most of our Roman writings come from the senatorial class (eg. you cited Cicero), their disdain for manual workers might be giving us a skewed picture. As most people in the Graeco-Roman world were illiterate, those with some skills might have been a cut above the rest. Certainly, in late medieval/early modern European society, illiterate craftsmen did have some status and could rise to be mayors of towns, eg. Shakespeare’s father. Just a thought.
Great discussion. Here’s my take. In Mark 6:3, calling Jesus a carpenter is intended as an insult, basically, a condescending remark, You’re untrained and uneducated, you’re just a blue-collar worker, who are you to act like some bigshot rabbi or educated teacher?
Mark mentions five insults against Jesus: crazy (3:21), demon-possessed (3:23, 30), carpenter, “son of Mary” (6:3), “a son of a god” (15:39). What makes me think all of these are insults is that Matthew changes all of them (except demon-possessed) so they’re not.
Insults aren’t necessarily true. In John 8:48, opponents say Jesus is a Samaritan and has a demon, neither of which were true. Is it true that Jesus was a carpenter? Who knows, since it’s mentioned in an insult.
There’s an interesting micro-progression for this episode from Mark to Matthew to Luke. In Mark, he’s insulted as if uneducated and the legitimacy of his birth is questioned. Matthew mollifies this as “son of a carpenter and Mary.” Then Luke has Jesus *reading* from the scroll of Isaiah in the synagogue. So we move from Jesus being an uneducated carpenter, to Jesus’ dad being the carpenter married to Mary, to Jesus reading in the synagogue.
Thoughts?
Yup, I think it’s all part of “no one could figure out who he was” and one wayt to get there was to attac him. As to your progression: Yup. Throw in John and it goes yet further.
Just curious, what do you see as this micro-progression going on into John? Jesus writing on the ground in the PA? Chris Keith of course argued that was to show Jesus being literate. Or was it something else you see in John that I’m overlooking?
It intrigues me that John 6:25-59 sounds like a faint echo of Jesus in his hometown synagogue (Mk 6:1-6//Matt 13:54-58) because it’s the only time in John (Jn 6:59) that Jesus teaches in a synagogue, despite what John 18:20 says. And in John 6:42, the Jews ask, “Is not this Jesus, the son of Joseph, whose father and mother we know?” which sounds so similar to Mk 6:3//Mt 13:55//Lk 4:22.
I’m not sure the pericope adulterae helps much since it was added later and it seems likely that it was not around for the first couple of centuries, at least in the form we have it. But certainly Jesus’ powers (spiritual/intellectual) progress over time when you line up the Gospels. Nothing to suggest real literacy in Mark; can read fluently in Luke; and becomes the omniscient Son of God later!
Dear Bart,
“One of the main themes of the Gospel is that, throughout Jesus’ ministry, almost from beginning to end, no one understands who he is.”
This is a useful observation, and an important one: they did not understand who he was!
When I began examining Paul’s use of language, the question was straightforward: Are the Son, Χριστός, and κύριος (Kyrios) merely different names for the same figure, or does Paul make a consistent distinction between them?
As my investigation progressed, it became increasingly clear that these three designations cannot simply be treated as synonyms. They may refer to the same figure, but Paul does not alternate between them at random. They appear in different theological contexts and emphasize different functions.
In Paul’s writings, the Son, Χριστός (the Anointed One), and Kyrios are overlapping but functionally distinct designations of the same figure. The Son primarily emphasizes his relationship to YHWH and his mission; the Anointed One particularly emphasizes death, resurrection, and the believers’ participation in him; and Kyrios emphasizes exalted lordship and sovereignty.
Mark wrote his Gospel in order to silence those who were attacking Paul! And it is Peter who provides the decisive answer: “You are the Christ.”
They are different titles for Jesus each with it’s own emphasis, but for Paul, all appropriate.
Thus, when the Son dies (not Jesus, but the Son), from that point onward he can also be known as Christ, the Anointed One. Only in this way can he be known! Then, when he is raised from the dead, his name becomes Kyrios!
If this distribution is not accidental, then Paul’s Christology cannot adequately be understood by treating the Son, the Anointed One, and the Lord as simple synonyms.
Together, these three designations trace a process: through the death of the Son sent by God, the possibility of a community existing in Christ comes into being, while the risen individual figure reigns as Lord (Kyrios) until those who are in Christ also attain the resurrection.
Dear Dr Ehrman-If I may ask, in view of your opinion that belief in the sacrificial nature of Jesus death existed prior to the entry of Paul into the Jesus movement, how would you account for the apparent absence of such a soteriology in the Didache, particularly regarding the Eucharist? Any illumination would be immensely welcome.
Whether Paul came up with it or not wouldn’t affect the interesting question about the Didache. That is, whether it was invented in 33 CE or 36 CE — it would have no bearing. The Gospel of Luke and the book of Acts, btw, are also lacking (have omitted!) the sacrificial interpretation of jesus’ death. Different people then as now held/hold different theologies. Views of atonement can’t be lined up (necessarily) chronologically.
Off topic but in your last post you mentioned that it is clear that there was place called Nazareth. Putting aside the argument that there could be no reason for the gospel writers to invent such a place (to the point both Luke and Matthew had to find a way to place Jesus at Bethlehem and why Jesus was eventually at Nazareth), was there any independent archaeological discovery of the city and if so, can you point to me where I can have a read of this? Thanks
Yes, it’s been dug up and much discussed. I have a discussion in my book Did Jesus Exist. Encyclopedias of Ancient Judaism often have entries on Nazareth. You could also look at Jonathan Reed and John Dominic Crossan Excavating Jesus.
If, as presented in the gospel of Mark, Jesus was trying to keep who he was a secret, and many, if not most people, didn’t recognize who he was, including his closest disciples, how is it that people can be faulted for not knowing who he was or seeing that he was the Messiah?
I’m thinking particularly of the Jews, but this includes other people as well.
How can people be blamed for not recognizing Jesus as the Messiah, when he himself was trying to keep it a secret?
Yup, good question. I wish Mark were around to tell us what he has in mind!!
I think that it’s implicit in Mark’s narrative that there was enough money in Jesus’ pocket to support him over a at least a short period when he could leave home and begin organising a religious movement and enough money in the family or from like minded people to keep his mother adequately while he was away. That would place him a step or two above peasant status. That he was a tecton, engaged in construction of some sort, seems like a reasonable way of suggesting – very loosely – where he stood in the economic scheme of things. I don’t know how important it was to Mark to have a background story of this kind or whether he had any direct acquaintance with Jesus’ family or with rural Galilee before his own time. He doesn’t seem to expect an audience who such matters well. He did succeed though in making his overall account memorable and lively
Interesting, thanks!
On the other hand, he would’ve had to work with something up to his 30th birthday, so why not as “το τεκτον”? Someone would have to perform that kind of work in a small village, right?
Yup. Almost certainly. But like everyone else, he would have mainly been a farmer. One of the small group though would have been able to work with wood, another with metal, etc., on the side. It’s not clear how Mark would *know* what Jesus had done brefore (writing 40 years later from a different part of the world) But it’s possible.
Yes, that makes sense.
I looked up the Greek, and I guess it should have been “ὁ τέκτων” in my first comment, sorry about that.
I wonder if you have considered Candida Moss’ suggestion that the centurion’s statement upon Jesus’ death was sarcastic, and said facetiously rather than revealing his true identity. I’m not sure I buy it, but the text could certainly be read that way.
Yes I have, and I don’t think so. On the contrary, his getting it right is one of the keys to understanding Mark’s Gospel. (Where there’s sarcasm/facetiousness/irony in a text, one usually looks for some textual clues: I don’t see any here. Mark appears to be very seroius about it)
So in Mark 8:31, Jesus is referring to himself as “Son of Man”?
Yes, for Mark he is. If Jesus actually said it, he was not.
Paul seems to make a point over and over that the messiah had to suffer and die, which wasn’t the traditional view of what a messiah would be, namely a powerful and virtuous King like David. Correct?
Paul repeatedly says this was prophesied in scripture. Was it?
He doesn’t repeatedly say that, but it occurs in 1 Cor 15:3-5. If it’s *really* there depends on how you read certain passages. It’s worth noting that there weren’t any Jews who ever read thees passages (say, Isaiah 53) as referring to a future suffering messiah, until the Christians came along. And on the surface, by modern modes of interpreation, they certainly don’t seem to be referring to one.
Dr. Ehrman,
How would you rate the education levels of the authors of Matthew/Mark/Luke/John?
John: theologically driven. Luke: used Mark, not as theologically driven. Matthew: used Mark, and was driven to demonstrate how Jesus fulfilled prophecy.
Mark: not just a story teller, but a story crafter. His is the work that I keep reading and wondering what he was up to.
They must have gone to schools in Greek speaking urban areas and got to one of the higher levels of education. They aren’t massively skilled (Luke is more than the others), but certainly write better than most of my undergraduates. Most people in that world didn’t even know the alphabet.
“What deeds of power are being done by his HANDS! 3 Is not this the carpenter”
It looks like this is just another of “Mark’s” contrived fictional contrasts:
The figurative spiritual works of his “Hands”
Verses
The literal physical works of his hands.
The theological point is his homeys still think of him in human physical terms and not in divine spiritual terms.
You’ve come a long way Bart but it’s disappointing that you still will not even mention this as a possibility.
If only that Professor had said “Maybe “Mark” was just being artistic.”
Joseph
Dear Bart!
In Romans 6:6, Paul states in the indicative mood that our old self was crucified with Christ, and in verse 7 he declares that the one who has died has been justified from sin. Only then, in verse 11, does he exhort us to regard ourselves accordingly.
Is it not possible, then, that according to Paul, the death of the old self and its justification from sin are already accomplished realities, which faith does not bring about but rather recognizes and acknowledges?
And if this is the case, who is it that continues to live by faith after the death of the old self?
The fact that he urges peole to belief/have faith for salvation must suggest that it is necessary — especially since he predicts “destruction” for those who don’t come to faith.
uneducated carpenter.
then how did Jesus spew & amaze those in the Jerusalem temple around age 12. I always thought it was because he was GOD [divinity]. in the beginning was THE WORD … I only knew the Word as the BIBLE, or over 40 years of my life.
and why does GOD & Jesus need so many names. the HS has 2.
GOOGLEAi: They saw a kid from a blue-collar, uneducated, working-class family.
The reason they were so stunned is precisely what you just realized: they were expecting the mind of an uneducated tekton, but they were interacting with the Logos—the divine mind of God in human flesh.