Among the questions I randomly get asked on occasion is if it’s true that Jesus went to India as a child or young man to consult with the Brahmins, or to Nepal to consult with Buddhists. I suppose the best answer would be: “It depends which Gospel you read.” If you read the New Testament Gospels – or in fact any writing of the New Testament, early Christianity, or Christianity down to modernity – the answer is, uh, no.
So where do these ideas come from? Modern Gospel forgeries (see my previous post). Here’s one of the most (in)famous, as I talk about it in my book Forged (HarperCollins 2011).
******************************
One of the most widely disseminated modern Gospel forgeries is called The Unknown Life of Jesus Christ.[1] From this account we learn that
Re: Matt 16:18
Is there any linguistic/grammatical considerations that could help settle all
the dispute over who, exactly, is the rock?
It’s rather the difference between a “who” (Peter) or a “what” (the confession that he is the messiah). The linguistic issue is that he says “you are Petros” (the name) and “on this Petra” (the word for a shelf of rock) “I will build my church.” Catholics pointed to the comparabe terms (rock and rock) to say the reference was the same; Protestants pointed to their different forms to say the references were different.
I am really thankful for this post because I feel like I come across the view all the time but had no idea where it stemmed from.
What do you think of the idea that Jesus traveled to England with his uncle, who was a tin merchant?
This is expressed in a poem by William Blake:
And did those feet in ancient time
Walk upon England’s mountains green?
And was the holy Lamb of God
On England’s pleasant pastures seen?
Uh, well, no. (!) But nice poem….
Well, aside from the rather obvious fact that Jesus claimed to be the Son of God, and that Buddhists are atheistic (well, pretty much, although you can have other side-beliefs as I understand it), IDK why or how this “education” supposedly helped him other than running some kind of “con job” on the Jews and Gentiles. Because if he’s the Son of God, he has/is-given DIRECT knowledge. And if he’s not, he’d be lying, and simply be starting his own “cult”…in the negative non-academic sense of the term. And to what end? Riches? No. Pleasant retirement? No…..
So I’m just guessing that these rumors are supporting an underlying agenda by the “conspiracy theorists” that the very basis of the religion is “false” and they want to find supporting evidence for such. You know, like how it was space aliens that REALLY built the pyramids, not human ingenuity. Confirmation bias, or maybe trying to make a buck off the “forgery”. As you concluded.
Dear Bart Ehrman,
I don’t have a question. I just wanted to say thank you.
About three years ago, I was squirrel hunting with my dogs when I asked myself whether I truly believed Jesus rose from the dead, walked on water, and was the son of God. The answer was no. That raised a new question: who was he, then?
This was how I came across your work. I’ve been obsessed ever since. Truly obsessed. I’m a fiction writer and poet by trade, but the historical Jesus now fills most of my free time. I even started a Substack about it. I’ve read Allison, Meier, Crossan, Sanders, and Bultmann, but you remain my favorite. Your book Apocalyptic Prophet meant the most to me, since Jesus’s apocalypticism is my main interest. I’ve branched further out though.
Friends and family now see me as a Bible guy. Some assume I’ve become a born-again believer, which I keep having to correct.
Your books and podcast changed my life. I truly mean that. I’ve just resubscribed to your blog.
Thank you for writing for ordinary people like me.
Sincerely,
Joe Sigurdson
Thanks! I hope you’re enjoying the blog!
Apparently, stories like this can be found everywhere in the world—and Japan certainly doesn’t want to be left out!
Believe it or not, there is a small village called Shingo in northern Japan where, according to local legend, Jesus actually spent his retirement!
The story goes that Jesus cleverly avoided crucifixion by having his younger brother, Isukiri, take his place. He then escaped from Jerusalem, traveled all the way to Japan, married a Japanese woman, raised a family, and reportedly lived to the ripe old age of 106! Amazingly, there are even people today who claim to be his descendants. Imagine their family tree!
But wait, there’s more!
The village has a mysterious traditional dance called “Nanyadoyara,” accompanied by a song whose lyrics nobody really understands. Naturally, some people claim the words must be Hebrew!
You can watch the villagers performing this mysterious dance here:
[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yXAQXMGwt38](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yXAQXMGwt38)
And here’s my favorite part: Every June, a **Shinto priest** conducts a memorial ceremony for Jesus, with the villagers dancing around what they believe is his grave!
A Jewish teacher from first-century Galilee, supposedly buried in rural Japan and honored by a Shinto priest two thousand years later. Now that’s what I call a truly international religious experience!
I suppose every corner of the world has its own remarkable version of history!
Whoa!! I had no idea. Who woulda thought….
Hi Prof. Ehrman,
As important a question and probably even more relevant and political is “Did St Thomas exist and go to South India?”.
A university near UNC Chapel Hill, Duke, has an essay title St. Thomas Apostle of America
https://read.dukeupress.edu/hahr/article/57/1/82/150188/Saint-Thomas-Apostle-of-America?
Questions like “In Textual Criticism when is Thomas mentioned? And did he go to Edessa? And are the Thomas visits to Gondophares territory real?” need to be examined. A Bartholomew Dias reached the Cape of Good Hope we are told. But did an Apostle named Bartholomew reach Bombay?? As a Apostle of Textual Criticism yourself(and a Bartholomew?), how do you view these claims!! As the age of Discovery dawned in Europe, did these myths gain much more of a tail wind?? … that made them larger than life and popularized them in many a distant shore?? Or is there more? Manifest Destiny??
Max Muller, like St Loyola was evangelical and never came to India and should be debunked.
Recently, the pilot of a flight to Tel Aviv, cited the VayuPutra(son of Wind God) Hanuman, as giving him the strength to help his passengers reach safety miraculously. The American and British presses wholly ignored it. But it gained enormous traction in India.
These stories have been popular among New Age groups like the Theosophical Society, Rosicrucians, and for a while, hippies. In my early 20’s, many of my friends and I had begun to doubt the bible stories. We thought such ideas were kind of cool, giving us arcane knowledge, unknown to more conventional minds.
Now, with the help of Bart and other scholars, I find the idea of any meaningful crossover between Eastern religions or philosophies and the teachings of Jesus to be flat out ridiculous. Jesus’ Jewish millennial teachings and Buddhism seem about 180 degrees different, and Jesus would have met Tibetan Buddhist monks hundreds of years before those particular monks even existed!
There is a popular myth among Ladakhis that has Jesus surviving the cross, traveling to nearby Kashmir and living and teaching there for many decades until his death. There’s even a burial site at a Srinagar shrine! It turns out that story was invented and published at the end of the 19th Century—a quite creative period, it seems. The keepers of the Srinagar shrine, Rosa Bal, say that there are sacred burials there, but not Jesus. Doesn’t matter; the myth continues.
Jesus apparently didn’t go to India, but did Thomas? There’s an ancient community of Christians in South India known as the Thomas Christians. They believe that St. Thomas traveled to India and founded their community. I suspect that you don’t believe he did. But if he didn’t, what’s the real origin story of the Thomas Christians?
That’s a legend that goes back to the second-century Acts of Thomas; it’s still available and very much worth reading, full of obvoiusly legendary material and not at all historically reliable, but very interesting and often humorous. But yes, Indian Christians have believed it for-roughly-ever.
I strongly believe that it is likely that Jesus joined a caravan around age 13 and spent ~20 years there, working and getting educated in a community of Jews whose ancestors had fled from Roman occupation of their homeland shortly after it occurred. My reason for this belief is this: He was the eldest child in a very crowded small home, and his mother required him to tend to his 4 or more younger children. His father may have died and his mother had — or soon would remarry. He was an intelligent person, and he has heard about the Jewish Community in India, and decided to run off and take his chances there — nothing could be worse than living in his current home!
I didn’t pull this belief out of thin air! My father was the oldest whose own father had run-off to live with another woman, and his mother required him to care for 3 younger siblings. He left home, quit school in the 10th grade, and lived in the YMCA. He supported himself (with some help from his grandfather) until he turned 18 and could get a job with the telephone company.
Bill Steigelmann
Dr. Elaine Pagels cites an earlier author about the presence of Buddhists in Egypt in the 1st century. Emperor Ashoka of the Mauryan Dynasty of India inscribed a message on the “Pillars of Ashoka”. He wrote that he sent Buddhist missionaries to three (3) Hellenistic kingdoms and he identified them by their names: Syria, Egypt, and mainland Greece. In the 13th chapter of 1st Corinthians, Paul wrote of “self-immolation”. So, Jesus did not go to the Brahmins of India or to the Buddhists of Nepal. The Buddhists missionaries of Emperor Ashoka arrived in 250 BCE. 300 years later, the “Q” Community of former Essenes influenced the content of the Synoptic Gospels. Emperor Ashoka invented the myth of Buddhism by fusing together his Krishna (Vishnu) Hinduism with the existing Jain religion (that honored its founder with a statue). Ashoka invented a historical narrative that the Buddha was born before the emergence of the Jain religion so that it would appear that Jainism copied Buddhism. “John of Patmos”, the author of Revelation, replicated a famous Krishna myth of the Great Dragon and the Pregnant Woman (who was carrying the unborn Krishna). “666” is an ink tattoo of a caste.
Is it possible that Thomas went to India and brought back teachings such as the Eightfold Path? If you compare the Eightfold Path with many of the teachings of Jesus and the “hidden knowledge” of the Gnostics, they seem similar.
No, I’d say it’s not possible.
Hello
The Romans once let 2 people off the cross and 1 survived do you think this indicated that Romans would have been open to the possiblity of letting Jesus off the cross after he died?
The denial of the burial was part of the punishment but couldnt the punishment been stoped at his death like the other people who punishment was stoped or is there a diffrence?
I don’t think so. Stopping an execution is not the same thing as not allowing the decent burial of an executed victim. We don’t have records of the latter.
Do you think after he was crusified and left on the cross for like 2 weeks was he then burried or then given a burrial?
I don’t know how long he would have been left on the cross, but it normally appears to have been long enough for the body to begin to decay and attacked by scavengers.
One point on this theme is important. In John, Jesus says, “If I glorify myself, my glory is nothing. It is my Father who glorifies me, of whom you say, ‘He is our God. But you have not known him. I know him. If I were to say that I do not know him, I would be a liar like you, but I do know him and I keep his word. Your father Abraham rejoiced that he would see my day. He saw it and was glad.” So the Jews said to him, “You are not yet fifty years old, and have you seen Abraham?” Jesus said to them, “Truly, truly, I say to you, before Abraham was, I am.”
In the Upanishads the Mahavakhya, “Aham Brahmasme”. Read the Wiki
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mah%C4%81v%C4%81kyas#Aham_Brahma_Asmi
“If a man knows ‘I am brahman’ in this way, he becomes the whole world. Not even the gods are able to prevent it, for he becomes their very self (ātman).”
I invite Prof. Ehrman to inquire deeply on this. Baptism through the Trinity for the absolution of Sin too is a central tenet in Hinduism. We see it in the spectacular introduction in Mark 1.